8 Best Christmas Rom-Coms Like Holidate
Finding a Christmas rom-com with the same cheeky, grown-up energy as Holidate can be harder than it sounds. Plenty of holiday films bring snow and twinkle lights, but this list looks for the mix that made Holidate fun: romantic complications, sharp humour, people who make questionable choices, and a festive setting that adds pressure instead of just decoration.
Holidate gives Sloane and Jackson a practical arrangement: they agree to be each other’s no-strings holiday dates so they can avoid family questions and the awkwardness of arriving alone. The plan works until their pretend relationship begins to develop real affection, and the calendar keeps presenting them with another occasion to test what they actually want. The best alternatives here also use a clear romantic setup, then let personality, family, or an imperfect first impression complicate it.
Along the way, you will find fake dating, swapped expectations, old friends, public personas, and characters who discover that the safest romantic plan is often the one that stops going to plan. Some picks lean on comedy, while others make room for sincere feelings and family drama.
Ranking a rom-com is not just a question of which couple kisses last. We weigh how clearly the story builds its central relationship, whether the leads have believable chemistry, how well the jokes land, and whether the holiday setting genuinely shapes the choices they make. A film can be charming and still sit lower if its conflict feels familiar; a higher-ranked pick needs stronger character work, a more satisfying emotional turn, or a premise that keeps paying off.
These are recommendations for viewers who want the cosy seasonal mood without giving up romantic tension or a little chaos. You can use the list to pick a light date-night movie, a heartfelt holiday watch, or a story with a premise close to Holidate’s pretend-couple spark. The entries explain what each film is about, what makes its romance work, and why it lands at that number in this countdown.
The titles here do not all use fake dating, and that is deliberate: the recommendation is about the experience as much as the exact plot device. Holidate’s appeal comes from watching two people perform a relationship until the performance gets complicated, then seeing whether they are brave enough to be honest. These films approach that pleasure from different angles, which makes the countdown useful when you want the same mix of romance, comedy and seasonal mess without simply repeating the same story.
There is also a useful difference between a film that borrows Holidate’s dating premise and one that simply recreates its holiday mood. The former gives you the pleasure of watching people negotiate the rules of a relationship they insist is temporary; the latter offers a fresh-start story shaped by family, travel or the season itself. We have included both kinds, so the list works whether you want the same trope or just the same cosy, slightly chaotic Christmas-romance feeling.
Support That Love Podcast
Enjoying the recommendations? You can help support That Love Podcast and keep independent entertainment coverage and original audio stories coming.
Looking for something new to listen to?
If you enjoyed this, check out:
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans?
If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
The Countdown
8. Love Hard
Los Angeles writer Natalie Bauer thinks she has found a promising match in Josh Lin, a man whose dating profile and charming messages seem to fit exactly what she wants. She flies to his small hometown for Christmas, only to discover that Josh used someone else’s photos. He offers to help her meet the real man in the pictures, Tag, if Natalie will pretend to be Josh’s girlfriend for the holiday. The arrangement gives Natalie access to the crush she came for, but it also puts her in close contact with the person who deceived her.
Nina Dobrev and Jimmy O. Yang make the awkwardness funny without asking the audience to forget the lie. The small-town holiday setting gives the deception a crowded stage: family traditions, local events and the pressure to keep up appearances make it difficult for anyone to be honest. The film’s best scenes let Natalie notice the difference between an idealised profile and the imperfect person in front of her.
Why it ranks here: It opens at eight because the premise is sharply connected to modern dating and has several funny set pieces, but the deception makes the romance harder to root for than the stronger couples higher in the list. It is an entertaining match for Holidate’s messy dating energy, though its emotional resolution is less layered.
Who should watch: Viewers who want an online-dating mix-up, holiday family chaos and a contemporary romantic comedy.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge? That Love Podcast creates original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories you can listen to anytime.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
7. The Holiday
Iris Simpkins is a London journalist nursing a painful unrequited love, while Amanda Woods is a Los Angeles film-trailer editor trying to escape a breakup. They meet through a home-exchange website and swap houses for Christmas. Iris lands in Amanda’s sunny California home and meets film composer Miles; Amanda arrives at Iris’s English cottage and meets Iris’s brother Graham. The exchange gives both women a change of scenery, but it also places them in the path of new relationships before either has fully dealt with the old one.
Kate Winslet and Cameron Diaz anchor two parallel stories with different rhythms. Winslet’s Iris has a more gradual recovery, helped by her friendship with elderly screenwriter Arthur, while Amanda’s guardedness meets Graham’s complicated family life. Nancy Meyers gives the film a cosy visual identity, but the appeal is not only the cottages and fireplaces; the characters have to learn what they will accept from other people.
Why it ranks here: At seven, it is an excellent comfort watch and its two romances give the film a generous, optimistic feel. It sits below the higher entries because the dual-story structure spreads attention between two couples, while the top picks have a more focused central relationship or a stronger comic engine.
Who should watch: Anyone in the mood for a warm, grown-up romance, house-swap fantasy and a gentle story about starting over.
Where to watch: Streaming and rental rights vary by country and date; check an official local listing.
6. Single All the Way
Peter is tired of his family treating his single status as a holiday project, so he asks his best friend Nick to come home with him and pretend to be his boyfriend. Peter expects the visit to be easier if his relatives believe he is settled. His mother, however, has already arranged a blind date with James, and the family’s matchmaking plans force Peter to reconsider what he wants from Nick and from the life he has built in Los Angeles.
Michael Urie and Philemon Chambers give the friends a relaxed familiarity that makes their history feel like the film’s real romantic foundation. The family ensemble supplies the seasonal commotion, from well-meant matchmaking to the uncomfortable moment when a pretend arrangement stops feeling pretend. The movie is openly warm and affectionate, and it treats queer romance as part of a familiar Christmas-comedy setting rather than as a source of tragedy.
Why it ranks here: It sits at six because the central friendship and family comedy make it an easy, generous watch, but the romantic conflict resolves more gently than the sharper or more unusual stories above it. It is one of the best picks here when you want warmth over chaos.
Who should watch: Viewers who enjoy friends-to-lovers romance, family matchmaking and an explicitly queer holiday story.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
You May Also Like
You May Also Like — more holiday romances and feel-good movie-night ideas:
5. Something from Tiffany’s
Ethan Greene is a single father in New York who buys his girlfriend Vanessa a small gift at Tiffany’s, while Gary Wilson is planning a proposal to his girlfriend Rachel. A street accident causes their gift bags to be switched, and Rachel finds the engagement ring Ethan intended for Vanessa. The mistake pulls Rachel and Ethan into each other’s lives as they try to correct the confusion, while both relationships face questions about whether the people involved truly understand one another.
Zoey Deutch gives Rachel an open, romantic curiosity, and Kendrick Sampson plays Ethan as a man trying to be responsible while his family life changes around him. The mistaken-gift premise is a classic holiday-romance device, but the film gets its momentum from the way the error reveals what the characters may have been avoiding. New York’s seasonal storefronts and crowded streets add texture without doing all the emotional work.
Why it ranks here: It reaches the top five because the mix-up gives the story a clean comic engine and the leads make its growing romance easy to follow. It ranks below the stronger entries because the familiar mistaken-identity turns are more predictable, but it is a polished, cosy choice for a holiday movie night.
Who should watch: Viewers who like city-set Christmas romances, mistaken gifts and an optimistic tone.
Where to watch: Check the official film listing and your local streaming or rental services for current availability.
🎧 Taking a break from the screen? Discover original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories from That Love Podcast.
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans?
If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
4. Falling for Christmas
Sierra Belmont is a wealthy hotel heiress whose life looks carefully arranged until a skiing accident leaves her with amnesia. After a storm, she is taken in by Jake Russell, a widowed lodge owner, and his young daughter, Avy. Sierra’s comfortable routines disappear as she helps around the lodge and gets to know the people caring for her. Jake is trying to keep the business afloat, so their growing connection unfolds alongside the practical pressures of running a small resort.
Lindsay Lohan plays Sierra with a lighter touch than the heiress’s public image suggests, while Chord Overstreet gives Jake a grounded steadiness. The lodge setting keeps the story cosy and the amnesia premise creates space for Sierra to rediscover ordinary pleasures. It is a deliberately uncomplicated holiday fantasy; the fun is watching someone accustomed to luxury learn to value a community and a family rhythm.
Why it ranks here: It earns fourth place because the setting, central pairing and fresh-start premise fit the seasonal mood particularly well. It sits below the top three because amnesia is a familiar device and the conflict follows a predictable route, but its comfort-watch appeal is stronger than several titles below it.
Who should watch: Viewers after an easy, cosy Christmas romance with a small-town lodge and a second chance at life.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
3. Our Little Secret
Avery and Logan were a couple years ago, but their relationship ended before they could make a life together. At Christmas, each arrives at a family gathering with a new partner and discovers that those partners are siblings. The former couple agree to keep their shared history quiet rather than disrupt the holiday, a decision that forces them to spend time together while pretending there is nothing unresolved between them.
Lindsay Lohan and Ian Harding give Avery and Logan a playful shorthand that suggests why the old relationship still matters. The family setting turns one private secret into a series of awkward situations, and the comedy works best when the characters’ efforts to control what others know create further complications. The film lets the leads be petty and embarrassed, which suits a story about people who have not entirely outgrown their past.
Why it ranks here: It reaches number three because the exes-at-Christmas premise creates immediate comic pressure, and the lead chemistry gives the reunion a believable spark. It falls short of the top two because the secrets-and-misunderstandings structure can feel familiar, even when the performances keep it lively.
Who should watch: Fans of second-chance romance, exes forced together and family-holiday farce.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
2. Christmas with You
Angelina is a pop star facing a career slump and a label that wants a fresh hit. She travels to a small New York town after discovering a young fan’s wish, where she meets Cristina and her father Miguel, a music teacher. Angelina agrees to help Cristina write a song, and the project brings her into Miguel’s home and community. Their collaboration gives Angelina a chance to reconnect with music while an unexpected romance begins to grow.
Aimee Garcia and Freddie Prinze Jr. give the film a gentle, adult chemistry, and the father-daughter relationship adds a family dimension to the romance. The story is less about public spectacle than about a performer finding a more personal reason to make music. Its small-town Christmas setting and songwriting thread make the film feel softer than a fake-dating comedy, but the characters still have to decide what kind of life and connection they want.
Why it ranks here: It nearly wins because the music gives the romance a specific shared activity and the family story adds warmth without overwhelming the leads. It ranks just below number one because its conflict is gentler and less surprising, while the top pick has a more distinctive high-concept obstacle and broader comic payoff.
Who should watch: Viewers who want a musical, small-town holiday romance with a parent-child story.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
🎧 Before we reveal our No. 1 pick, discover original romantic audio dramas from That Love Podcast.
1. The Knight Before Christmas
Sir Cole, a medieval English knight, is magically transported to present-day Ohio, where he meets Brooke, a science teacher trying to get through the holiday season after a painful breakup. Cole believes he has been sent on a quest, but he has little understanding of modern life; Brooke is initially sceptical of his story and unsure whether she wants another romantic complication. Their growing connection has to survive the gap between Cole’s old-fashioned sense of honour and the expectations of the present.
Josh Whitehouse gives Cole an earnest, bewildered charm, while Vanessa Hudgens makes Brooke’s guardedness feel understandable rather than simply cynical. The comedy comes from the knight’s attempts to interpret ordinary routines, but the film works best when it lets the leads share quieter scenes and recognise what the other needs. Its fairytale tone is deliberately soft, making it an easy seasonal watch.
Why it ranks here: It earns number one because the time-travelling knight premise gives the romance a memorable obstacle, and the contrast between Cole’s medieval code and Brooke’s modern life produces both humour and tenderness. It is less grounded than Holidate, but its central couple and festive rewatch value make it the strongest overall recommendation in this list.
Who should watch: Viewers who enjoy fish-out-of-water comedy, a clear central romance and a light Christmas fantasy.
Where to watch: Check Netflix’s title page for current availability in your region.
Conclusion
These films share Holidate’s interest in romance arriving through an arrangement, a misunderstanding or a change of plans, but they each take that idea in a different direction. Love Hard and Single All the Way bring fake dating into family Christmas gatherings; The Holiday and Christmas with You make a fresh start feel possible; and Our Little Secret finds comedy in the uncomfortable history between former partners.
The Knight Before Christmas takes the top spot because its time-travel premise gives the romance a distinctive comic engine, while Vanessa Hudgens and Josh Whitehouse make the central pairing easy to root for. If you want more adult dating chaos, start with Love Hard. If you want a softer seasonal escape, choose The Holiday. Tell us which one you would rank first, and which Christmas rom-com we missed.
The best follow-up depends on what you want from the evening: fake-dating mishaps, an affectionate family gathering, or a romance that makes a new beginning feel possible. That variety is what makes these films useful companions to Holidate rather than simple copies of it. Share your own ranking and tell us which seasonal rom-com should join the next update.
Support That Love Podcast
If you enjoyed this article, help support more independent entertainment coverage and original audio storytelling.
Looking for something new to listen to?
A holiday romance works best when the festive setting creates choices for the characters, rather than merely adding a decorated tree to the frame. That is the standard behind this ranking, and it is why the final recommendation edges out the other charming options. There is room here for a silly setup, a cosy escape or a more sincere story about changing direction.
You May Also Like
You May Also Like — more holiday romance, comfort watches and seasonal recommendations:
You May Also Like
You May Also Like — more romance and festive viewing ideas:
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I watch after Holidate?
Start with a holiday rom-com that pairs forced proximity with witty relationship banter. The Knight Before Christmas is the strongest all-round match in this ranking; Love Hard is the closest in its fake-dating setup. For the closest trope match, decide whether you want a pretend relationship, mistaken identity or former partners forced together. The list separates those setups so you can choose the kind of romantic tension you enjoyed most in Holidate. Check the film’s official title page for the current local listing before you stream.
Which Christmas rom-com here has fake dating?
Love Hard and Single All the Way both use pretend relationships as a central device. Their characters enter the arrangement for different reasons, so the films offer distinct versions of the trope. The shared element is romantic recovery rather than the specific fake-date pact. The Holiday gives each heroine a new environment and a chance to see herself differently, so it works best when the appeal for you was the fresh-start feeling.
Is The Holiday similar to Holidate?
Both are seasonal romantic comedies about people reassessing their love lives, but The Holiday is more earnest and has two parallel romances rather than a fake-date arrangement. For a livelier, more adult comedy, try Love Hard or Our Little Secret; for a gentler atmosphere, choose The Holiday or Christmas with You. Tone and age ratings differ, so check the local rating if the movie night includes younger viewers.
Is Love Hard a Christmas movie?
The story unfolds during a Christmas visit, with dating-app deception, family traditions and holiday activities driving the comedy. The strongest cozy choice depends on whether you want a house-swap fantasy, small-town warmth or a family gathering. The Holiday is the most relaxed option here; Falling for Christmas is an uncomplicated seasonal escape. Its modern dating premise gives it a distinctly contemporary holiday-comedy feel.
Which pick is the funniest?
The answer depends on your taste: Love Hard and Our Little Secret lean into awkward lies and social chaos, while The Knight Before Christmas gets much of its humour from Cole encountering modern life. It weighs the story, performances, chemistry, seasonal setting and rewatchability.
Which film is best for a cozy holiday night?
The Holiday is a strong choice for a cozy night because its home swap gives the film two winter settings and two romance storylines, with time for the characters to settle into new routines. Falling for Christmas is a lighter option if you want a simpler, more openly festive story. Both work well when you want seasonal atmosphere and a gentle romantic payoff rather than a fast, joke-heavy comedy.
Are these movies suitable for a family watch?
They are mainstream romantic comedies, but they are not all aimed at the same age group. Some include adult language, sexual references, drinking or relationship themes that may not suit younger viewers. Check the age rating and content notes on your local streaming service before pressing play with children. For a mixed-age gathering, choose based on the youngest viewer and preview the film if you are unsure.
Where can I stream these movies?
Streaming rights vary by country and change over time, so there is no single service that carries every title everywhere. Love Hard and Single All the Way are Netflix titles, while other films may rotate between subscription services and digital rental stores. Search the exact title in your local service or consult its official title page on the day you plan to watch. The article avoids promising a platform where availability may have changed.
Do these films all have happy endings?
These are romantic comedies, so they generally aim for emotional resolution, but the tone and route to that resolution differ. Some endings feel cosy and reassuring; others spend more time with family conflict or the consequences of a messy choice. If you want to avoid spoilers, skip plot summaries and trailers that reveal late scenes. Our ranking focuses on the journey and chemistry rather than giving away how each couple finishes.
What makes a good Holidate follow-up?
Look for a clear relationship setup, leads whose chemistry makes the complications worth following, and a holiday setting that changes what the characters do. A good follow-up does not need the same fake-date arrangement; it can offer the same mix of adult romantic tension, awkward family expectations and seasonal warmth. That is why this list includes both close trope matches and films that capture Holidate’s broader mood.
More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows
For further discovery, browse ScreenRant, CBR, Collider, IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, MovieWeb, Slash Film and Comic Book Movie. These outlets cover entertainment news, reviews, cast information and recommendations.
Enjoyed what you read? Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for new articles, entertainment recommendations, podcast updates and giveaways. Share the article with someone who loves movies and television.
Explore More on Amazon
.jpg)
.jpg)
