6 Perfect Crime Shows Worth Watching Over and Over, Ranked
The pleasure of a crime-show rewatch
A crime series can be a strange thing to revisit. You may remember the answer to the central mystery, but that knowledge often changes the viewing rather than spoiling it. A second watch lets you notice the detail a character avoids, the moment a partnership begins to crack, or the small choice that sets a much larger disaster in motion. The best crime shows are not puzzles you solve once and leave behind. They are stories about people, power and consequence that become richer when you can see the whole shape.
This ranking brings together six crime shows worth watching over and over: a drug trade turning into a family catastrophe, a lawyer’s gradual reinvention, a profile of criminal psychology, an anthology built around haunted detectives, a British small-town investigation and a Belfast pursuit told with unusual patience. These series range from procedural mystery to criminal saga, from slow-burn character drama to limited-event television. Your ranking is fixed: Breaking Bad takes No. 1, followed by Better Call Saul, Mindhunter, True Detective, Broadchurch and The Fall in the countdown.
I have ranked them for rewatch value, performance, writing, atmosphere, and the way each show turns crime into more than a plot device. They are very different binges. Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul build cumulative character arcs; Mindhunter is a quiet, unsettling study of how an investigation changes its investigators; True Detective changes its cast and story across seasons. Broadchurch and The Fall let place and routine become part of the tension. If you want a one-weekend limited crime series, this list has shorter options; if you want a world to live in for a while, it has those too.
Streaming availability is regional and changes as rights move. The viewing notes link to a live UK directory rather than promising that a particular subscription service will always carry a show. For more detective recommendations, see 15 Binge-Worthy ITV Detective Shows, Ranked. Let’s get into it 👇
SUPPORT THAT LOVE PODCAST
Enjoying the recommendations? Help support That Love Podcast and keep independent entertainment content like this coming. Donate to That Love Podcast.
If you love this, check out 8 Best British Mystery Shows to Watch If You Love Ludwig.
Listen to That Love Podcast episodes for original romantic audio dramas and stories to enjoy after a tense finale.
ADVERTISE WITH THAT LOVE PODCAST
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans? If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business, or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast, and newsletter. Find out more: Advertise with That Love Podcast.
6. The Fall
The Fall is a crime drama that gets much of its unease from refusing to make investigation feel like a race. Allan Cubitt created the series, which premiered in 2013 and is set in Belfast. Gillian Anderson plays Detective Superintendent Stella Gibson, a senior investigator brought in to review an unsolved murder. Jamie Dornan plays Paul Spector, a family man who is also a serial killer. The series follows both sides of the pursuit, allowing the audience to see the ordinary routines and private distortions that exist alongside the police work.
Gibson’s arrival unsettles a local investigation that has stalled. As she reviews the evidence, she notices links that connect a series of killings and directs the team towards a suspect they have not yet identified. Spector’s life appears domestic and controlled from the outside, while the work of the investigation reveals how difficult it is to detect the danger embedded in normal routines. The show moves between interview rooms, streets, homes and workplaces, giving the case a quiet, institutional texture. It is less interested in a clever puzzle-box than in the different ways people observe, dismiss or interpret behaviour.
Anderson plays Gibson with precision and reserve; the character’s composure makes her both authoritative and difficult to read. Dornan’s performance keeps Spector unnerving without turning him into a theatrical monster. The show’s patient camera work and Belfast setting create a sense of place that is more than scenery. It asks the viewer to sit with investigative details and power dynamics, particularly in the way institutions respond to violence against women. That attention makes the series a serious watch, and also means it can be emotionally heavy.
The Fall ranks sixth because its deliberate pace and subject matter demand more patience than the other shows on this list. It is not a casual background binge, and its tension comes from discomfort rather than frequent action. For viewers who want a psychologically focused British crime drama, a strong lead performance and a meticulous serial investigation, it is a distinctive choice. Rewatching can reveal how carefully the series positions what the audience knows against what the investigators know. For another batch of British mysteries, browse The 20 Most Binge-worthy BBC Detective Shows, Ranked.
Where to watch in the UK: check live JustWatch listings for current streaming, rental and purchase availability.
5. Broadchurch
Broadchurch turns a single crime into a portrait of a town trying to continue after its private life has become public. Chris Chibnall created the ITV drama, which began in 2013. David Tennant plays Detective Inspector Alec Hardy, a newcomer to the seaside community, and Olivia Colman plays Detective Sergeant Ellie Miller, who expected to be promoted into the role he receives. Their first case is the murder of an eleven-year-old boy, Danny Latimer, whose family and neighbours are part of the community both detectives must investigate.
The premise rests on a painful contradiction: everyone wants the truth, but each new detail makes life in the town more difficult. Hardy and Miller interview residents, test timelines and follow leads while Danny’s parents, Beth and Mark, struggle with grief under the scrutiny of neighbours and reporters. The cliffs, beach and close-knit streets give Broadchurch a beautiful landscape that never feels like a holiday brochure. It is a town where people know one another’s routines, which makes the investigation feel intimate and claustrophobic at once. Later seasons widen the story, but the first case remains the show’s defining emotional event.
Tennant and Colman create a detective partnership built on friction and gradual respect. Hardy’s guarded exhaustion contrasts with Miller’s local knowledge and human warmth. Colman gives Ellie a vivid emotional life without making her simply the sympathetic one; she is a mother, a colleague and a person who has to keep doing her job while the town changes around her. The ensemble performance is a major strength, and the score and coastal imagery allow silences to carry as much weight as dialogue. Broadchurch understands that a murder mystery is also a story about survivors and neighbours.
It ranks fifth because its first season’s central revelation is difficult to revisit in the same way once you know it, although the performances and slow accumulation of clues remain rewarding. This is a good choice if you want a British detective series with strong character drama, a vivid seaside setting and a mystery that does not forget its human cost. It is ideal for viewers who like crime shows that leave room for grief and community. More British investigations are collected in 8 Best British Mystery Shows to Watch If You Love Ludwig.
Where to watch in the UK: check current JustWatch listings before you start; regional services can change.
4. True Detective
True Detective is built around the idea that the most interesting crime stories are often about the people who cannot leave them behind. Nic Pizzolatto created the HBO anthology, which debuted in 2014. The first season follows Louisiana detectives Rust Cohle (Matthew McConaughey) and Marty Hart (Woody Harrelson) across an investigation that stretches through decades. Later seasons introduce new cases, settings and casts, including Colin Farrell, Rachel McAdams, Mahershala Ali and Jodie Foster. Each season offers a self-contained crime narrative, so viewers can choose a starting point without committing to one continuous cast.
The first season’s central mystery reaches back through time, revisited through interviews and fragmented memories. Rust and Marty are both capable detectives but very different men, and their methods and personal lives shape the case as much as the evidence does. The show moves through Louisiana’s landscapes and institutions, using place as a source of atmosphere and unease. Later chapters experiment with different forms of mystery and different emotional centres. True Detective can be a police investigation, a philosophical character study, a family drama or a portrait of a community affected by violence, depending on the season.
The anthology structure is a gift to the rewatcher. A season’s conclusion reframes the relationships and clues that came before it, while a new season gives you a fresh world to compare. McConaughey and Harrelson have an exceptional chemistry in the first season; their scenes can be funny, tense and melancholy at once. The show’s visual style and sound design create a strong sense of mood, though the tone can be deliberately bleak. Later seasons are uneven by design as well as reception, but their differences make the anthology interesting to revisit and debate.
True Detective ranks fourth because its seasons vary in focus and consistency; not every viewer will love every chapter equally. But it belongs among the best crime series to binge for viewers who value atmosphere, performances and stories that linger after the final scene. Start with the season whose cast or setting appeals to you, then decide if you want to continue through the anthology. It is a useful choice when you want a serious mystery but do not want to begin a multi-season story with one fixed hero. For more ongoing detective binges, see The 10 Most Binge-worthy Detective Shows of the 2010s.
Where to watch in the UK: check the live JustWatch directory for current service listings.
You’ll also love
🎧 Pause the investigation
Taking a break from the screen? Listen to original romance and drama stories from That Love Podcast. Explore the latest episodes.
3. Mindhunter
Mindhunter is a quiet, methodical crime series about the early development of criminal profiling and the people trying to make an emerging field useful. Joe Penhall developed the Netflix drama from the book by John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker. Jonathan Groff plays FBI agent Holden Ford, Holt McCallany is his colleague Bill Tench, and Anna Torv plays psychologist Wendy Carr. The show begins in the late 1970s, when Ford and Tench start interviewing imprisoned murderers in order to understand how violent offenders think and whether their patterns can help solve active cases.
At first, the work seems almost academic. The agents travel to prisons, conduct interviews and return with observations that colleagues may not trust. As their method develops, the FBI must decide whether conversation with killers can be turned into a practical investigative tool. Meanwhile, the agents’ work changes their personal lives and the culture of the bureau. Wendy’s involvement brings a thoughtful perspective on research and professional credibility; Tench’s experience as a family man creates a different point of pressure from Holden’s restless ambition. The series also threads in cases and details from the era without turning every episode into a conventional chase.
The interviews are the show’s most memorable set pieces. The actors playing incarcerated killers do not perform them as colourful villains, but as people whose conversational manner can become more unsettling the longer it goes on. Groff’s Holden is intellectually curious and sometimes unable to recognise the emotional cost of curiosity. McCallany provides a grounded counterweight, and Torv gives Wendy’s professional intelligence a measured confidence. The production design and restrained direction create a period atmosphere without making the series feel like a costume exercise. It is a procedural with very little procedural comfort.
Mindhunter ranks third because it is absorbing and beautifully controlled, but its slow pace and unresolved larger arc may frustrate viewers who want a clear ending. It is the right pick if you are drawn to psychological crime dramas, investigative method and performances that make a conversation feel tense. It also rewards a rewatch: once you understand how the agents’ approach evolves, early interviews and office debates take on new meaning. For people curious about what a profile-driven series can do, it is essential viewing. The guide 20 Binge-Worthy TV Crime and Detective Dramas of 2026 So Far offers more contemporary choices.
Where to watch in the UK: check the live JustWatch listings for current access and purchase options.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your book, entertainment brand, streaming service, product, or business in front of readers who love movies, television, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers sponsorship and advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter. Learn more.
2. Better Call Saul
Better Call Saul is a crime drama about the choices that make a person’s transformation feel both inevitable and avoidable. Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould created the Breaking Bad prequel, which premiered in 2015. Bob Odenkirk plays Jimmy McGill, a struggling lawyer whose charm, ingenuity and appetite for shortcuts slowly reshape him into Saul Goodman. Rhea Seehorn plays Kim Wexler, a highly capable attorney and Jimmy’s partner, while Jonathan Banks returns as Mike Ehrmantraut, whose parallel story draws the series into the criminal world around Albuquerque.
The early story follows Jimmy as he tries to build a legitimate legal career while living in the shadow of his older brother Chuck (Michael McKean), a brilliant lawyer who distrusts him. Jimmy takes low-budget cases, hustles for clients and tries to prove he can be respected. Kim’s career gives the couple both a point of connection and a source of conflict: they admire one another’s skill, but they do not always agree about what their skills should be used for. Mike’s work as a fixer develops alongside Jimmy’s story, showing the small transactions and loyalties that make a criminal operation function.
What makes the series extraordinary is its patience. A glance, a document or an improvised scheme can receive the same care as an action scene. Odenkirk keeps Jimmy funny and affectionate even as the character’s choices become harder to defend. Seehorn gives Kim a complete inner life and a moral imagination of her own, making her far more than a witness to Jimmy’s decline. The show’s legal world is specific without requiring viewers to follow every technical detail, and its visual storytelling often explains how a character feels before the character says anything.
Better Call Saul sits at No. 2 because its slow-burn craft and character writing are astonishing, even if it asks for more patience than the briskest crime binges. Knowing where Jimmy ends up makes the rewatch especially compelling: early choices carry a double meaning, and Kim’s decisions become more revealing as the consequences accumulate. It is ideal for viewers who like morally complicated characters, legal drama and precise storytelling. It can be watched after Breaking Bad for chronological context, though watching it first gives a different kind of suspense. See 8 Best New Crime TV Shows of 2026 So Far, Ranked for newer investigations.
Where to watch in the UK: check current JustWatch listings for subscription, rental and purchase choices.
Before the No. 1 pick
Before we reveal our No. 1 pick, discover original romantic audio dramas from That Love Podcast. Listen here.
1. Breaking Bad
Breaking Bad is the best crime show to watch over and over because every rewatch changes the balance between the story’s early desperation and its later consequences. Vince Gilligan created the AMC drama, which began in 2008. Bryan Cranston plays Walter White, a high-school chemistry teacher diagnosed with cancer who turns to making methamphetamine with former student Jesse Pinkman (Aaron Paul). Anna Gunn plays Walter’s wife Skyler, Dean Norris is his DEA-agent brother-in-law Hank Schrader, and Bob Odenkirk introduces the lawyer Saul Goodman, who would later lead his own series.
Walter’s initial explanation is that he wants to secure his family’s financial future. His first partnership with Jesse gives him a way into a criminal business he does not understand, and each attempt to control the consequences pushes him further from the person he believes himself to be. Albuquerque becomes a vivid landscape for this transformation: a family home, a car wash, a desert road and a hidden workspace each take on a different meaning as Walter’s choices expand. The show’s plot moves with suspense, but it is the conflict between intention and impact that gives the story its force.
Cranston’s performance is one of television’s great long arcs. He can make Walter seem vulnerable, clever, frightened and frightening, sometimes in the same episode. Paul gives Jesse a deeply human centre; the character’s humour, grief and moral confusion keep the show from treating criminal success as a victory. Gunn’s Skyler becomes more complex when the family’s secrets force her into decisions of her own. The writing is careful about consequences: the story does not allow a clever scheme to remain clever once other people have to live with it.
Breaking Bad takes No. 1 because its five-season shape feels both gripping in the moment and deliberately constructed for a second look. It is the strongest recommendation for viewers who want a complete crime saga, a tense character transformation and a finale that brings the central conflict to a meaningful end. The violence and moral decline can make it a heavy binge, so it is not comfort viewing in the usual sense. But it rewards attention like few crime series do. After the finale, The 10 Best Michael Scott Quotes From The Office, Ranked is very much the opposite mood; for related crime stories, return to the detective guides linked above.
Where to watch in the UK: check the live JustWatch directory before viewing; availability and purchase options change.
How to choose your next crime-series binge
If you want one complete story with a decisive shape, Breaking Bad is the natural choice. Better Call Saul makes a more measured, character-led follow-up and is especially satisfying if you enjoy legal stories. Mindhunter suits a quiet evening when you want investigative psychology rather than a fast chase. True Detective lets you choose a self-contained season, while Broadchurch gives you a close-knit community mystery with emotional fallout. The Fall is the most patient and unsettling option here, and it deserves a viewer who is ready to sit with difficult subject matter.
A second viewing also gives you a different experience depending on what you remember. With Breaking Bad, you know the direction of Walter’s choices and can see the warning signs earlier. With Better Call Saul, you notice how often Jimmy’s kindness and self-justification share the same moment. With Broadchurch, the central mystery may no longer surprise you, but the acting and town-wide ripple effects become the main attraction. True Detective invites a season-by-season conversation about how setting and character alter the same genre. These are good crime shows to binge precisely because they do not all use suspense in the same way.
It helps to decide whether you want a case or a character. Procedural mysteries give a viewer the pleasure of evidence and deduction. Character-driven crime dramas turn the investigation into pressure that exposes relationships and values. The best series on this list combine both, but usually one element leads. If your mood is low-energy, Mindhunter or Better Call Saul can be absorbing without relying on constant action. If you want momentum, Breaking Bad and True Detective’s stronger seasons provide more immediate propulsion.
More crime and detective recommendations
15 Binge-Worthy ITV Detective Shows, Ranked is a good next stop for classic investigation stories. For more British cases, explore The 20 Most Binge-worthy BBC Detective Shows, Ranked and The 10 Most Binge-worthy Detective Shows of the 2000s. Readers wanting a mix of new and familiar titles can visit 20 Binge-Worthy TV Crime and Detective Dramas of 2026 So Far.
Work With That Love Podcast
If you're a brand, author, publisher, entertainment company or business looking to connect with an audience that loves movies, television, romance, books and pop culture, we'd love to hear from you.
Conclusion
The best crime shows leave you thinking about more than who committed the crime. They ask what people tell themselves, what institutions notice too late and how a community or family changes when a secret becomes impossible to contain. The Fall offers a patient, unsettling pursuit; Broadchurch turns investigation into communal grief; True Detective builds season-length portraits of detectives; Mindhunter studies the work of listening; Better Call Saul traces an identity taking shape; and Breaking Bad turns a single premise into a complete moral collapse.
Breaking Bad earns the top spot because its characters, pacing and consequences fit together with rare precision. Choose Better Call Saul if you want the slower, subtler companion; pick Broadchurch for a human-scale mystery or True Detective for an anthology. What would you rank differently? Share the crime series you return to, and tell us which finale still stays with you.
Support That Love Podcast
If you enjoyed this article and want to support independent entertainment coverage and original audio storytelling, donate to That Love Podcast. For something new to listen to, explore the episodes page.
You May Also Love
The 10 Most Binge-worthy Detective Shows of the 2010s
FAQs
What is the best crime show to watch over and over?
Breaking Bad is the strongest all-around recommendation in this ranking because its character arc and plot are carefully connected, and knowing the ending adds meaning to the early episodes. Better Call Saul is the best choice if you prefer a slower legal drama. For a mystery focused on a community, try Broadchurch; for a season-long anthology story, choose True Detective.
Is Breaking Bad still worth watching if I know the ending?
Yes. The show’s rewatch value comes partly from seeing how Walter’s early rationalisations lead toward later choices. Knowing the outcome lets you notice performances, visual details and turning points you may have missed while waiting to discover what happens. It remains tense because the consequences are often more important than the surprise itself.
Should I watch Better Call Saul before or after Breaking Bad?
Either order works, but the intended release order is Breaking Bad followed by Better Call Saul. Watching Breaking Bad first preserves the original introductions and lets the prequel’s later connections land as callbacks. Watching Better Call Saul first creates a different kind of dramatic irony, since you know what some characters become. Choose based on whether you prefer release order or chronological story order.
Which crime show is best for a short binge?
Broadchurch’s first season is a compact choice if you want a contained mystery and a strong emotional arc. Mindhunter is also manageable in shorter stretches, though it is deliberately slow. True Detective lets you choose a single season rather than follow one long continuous story. Check the episode count for the season you plan to watch, since platform packages and editions can differ.
Is Mindhunter based on a true story?
Mindhunter is based in part on the book by former FBI profiler John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker, and it dramatizes the early development of criminal profiling. The series uses real historical cases and figures as inspiration but is a scripted drama, so individual scenes and character details should not be treated as a documentary record. It is best viewed as a fictionalised account shaped for television.
Which show on this list has the best detective partnership?
Broadchurch has the clearest two-detective partnership in this ranking. Ellie Miller and Alec Hardy begin with a professional imbalance and gradually learn to work together. True Detective’s first season also centres on a memorable pair, Rust Cohle and Marty Hart, whose conflicting worldviews shape the investigation. The Fall takes a different approach, placing Stella Gibson at the centre of a larger team.
Is True Detective an anthology series?
Yes. Each season tells a largely self-contained story with a new central case, setting and main cast. This makes it possible to choose a season based on its premise or performers. The tone and critical response vary between seasons, so viewers should not assume every chapter feels identical. The anthology format is part of its appeal for viewers who like crime dramas with changing creative directions.
Where can I stream these crime shows in the UK?
UK rights can move between streaming subscriptions and digital stores. Use a current listing service such as JustWatch, then confirm the title inside the platform before subscribing or renting. Search for the exact series and season where possible, since libraries sometimes carry only selected seasons. The available options may be different in other countries.
Which series is best if I like British detective dramas?
Broadchurch and The Fall are the most direct choices here, both set in the UK and shaped by a strong sense of place. Broadchurch is a community mystery with a large ensemble; The Fall is a more patient psychological pursuit in Belfast. If you want more options, browse the site’s ITV and BBC detective-show guides linked above.
Are these crime shows suitable for background viewing?
Most of these series reward close attention, especially Better Call Saul, Mindhunter, Broadchurch and The Fall, where small details and performance choices carry weight. Breaking Bad and True Detective also depend on continuity and atmosphere. For casual viewing, choose an episode you already know or select a less complex procedural from the linked detective guides. These shows are better when you can focus on them.
More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows
For cast, episode and production details, browse IMDb. Compare reviews at Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, then use JustWatch UK to check changing streaming, rental and purchase availability. Other useful sources include TV Guide, Entertainment Weekly, Deadline, The Hollywood Reporter and Wikipedia’s television portal.
Newsletter
Enjoyed what you read? Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest blogs, entertainment recommendations, updates and exclusive giveaways. If you know someone who loves movies, television, books or pop culture, share this article with them too. Let’s spread the love together!
.jpg)
.jpg)
Comments