The 20 Most Binge-worthy BBC Detective Shows, Ranked

It’s a Sunday morning in late August, and a cool, contemplative mood is settling over London. The vibrant, chaotic energy of the summer is beginning to mellow, giving way to the cozy, "back to school" focus of autumn. It’s the perfect time to trade sun-drenched adventures for something more immersive, more complex, and more thrilling. It is, in short, the perfect time to get lost in a great British detective show. And for over a century, the undisputed home of the genre, the gold standard for mystery and intrigue, has been the BBC.

The British detective is a global cultural icon, and the BBC has been instrumental in crafting its legacy. On platforms like TikTok and Pinterest, the appeal is as strong as ever. We see "dark academia" aesthetic boards inspired by the moody, intellectual world of Sherlock, fan edits celebrating the raw, visceral power of Luther, and a growing appreciation for the bleakly beautiful, "cozy mystery" landscapes of shows like Shetland and Vera. The trend is clear: audiences around the world are captivated by the unique blend of sophisticated plotting, brilliant character work, and atmospheric tension that defines the British detective drama.

To rank the twenty “best” BBC detective shows is a monumental and wonderfully subjective task. It is to navigate a landscape populated by iconic, world-famous sleuths, from the quirky and eccentric to the dark and tormented. It is a journey through decades of television history, from groundbreaking classics that defined the genre to modern masterpieces that have redefined it. This is not just a list; it is a celebration of a proud and enduring television tradition.

This is your definitive, in-depth guide to the essential viewing for any fan of the genre. We have considered a range of factors, from critical acclaim and cultural impact to the sheer, undeniable, "just one more episode" binge-worthiness of each series. From the windswept moors of Northumberland to the gritty, rain-slicked streets of London, these are the twenty shows that represent the pinnacle of BBC detective drama.

Enjoyed what you read? If you find this article insightful and it helps you discover your next great binge-watch, please consider supporting our work. Your generosity allows us to continue creating and sharing in-depth cultural commentary. You can make a donation by moving your cursor to the top of the article or scrolling down to the bottom. Every little bit helps us spread the love, one article at a time!

20. Silent Witness (1996–present)

The Vibe: A long-running, slick, and fascinating forensic procedural that puts the science of crime-solving at the forefront.

Synopsis: One of the longest-running crime dramas in the world, Silent Witness follows a team of brilliant forensic pathologists and scientists at the Lyell Centre. Each week, they are presented with a new, often baffling, death, and it is their job to speak for the dead. Using cutting-edge science, meticulous examination, and a healthy dose of deductive reasoning, they uncover the hidden clues within the body to reveal the truth behind the crime.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Silent Witness is the ultimate procedural. It’s a show that offers the deep, satisfying pleasure of watching brilliant experts solve a complex puzzle. While the cast has evolved over its nearly three-decade run, the show's core appeal has remained consistent: a perfect blend of fascinating science and compelling human drama. The cases are often dark and complex, but the show is grounded in the unwavering dedication of its characters to finding the truth.

What Makes It a Classic: The show’s incredible longevity is a testament to its quality and its ability to reinvent itself. It has consistently adapted to reflect the latest advances in forensic science, making it feel both timeless and incredibly modern. It’s a show that has inspired a generation of forensic scientists and remains a cornerstone of the BBC’s drama lineup. For more on the real-world science behind the show, the Forensic Science Society has some fascinating resources.

Where to Watch: Stream Silent Witness on BBC iPlayer.

19. McMafia (2018)

The Vibe: A slick, stylish, and globe-trotting thriller that is a deep dive into the complex, corporate world of modern organized crime.

Synopsis: The series follows Alex Godman, the English-raised son of Russian mafia exiles. Alex has spent his life trying to escape his family's criminal past, building a legitimate career as a hedge fund manager in London. However, when his family is threatened, he is drawn back into the world he has tried so desperately to avoid. He is forced to navigate a treacherous global network of organized crime, from Russian mobsters and Balkan smugglers to Israeli narco-traffickers.

Why It's Binge-worthy: While not a traditional detective show, McMafia is a brilliant piece of investigative drama. The show is a fascinating and often terrifying look at how modern organized crime operates like a multinational corporation. The series is visually stunning, with a cinematic scope that takes the viewer from the lavish penthouses of London to the gritty backstreets of Mumbai. James Norton is fantastic as Alex, a good

man who is slowly and seductively corrupted by the world he is forced to enter.

What Makes It a Classic: The show, based on the non-fiction book by Misha Glenny, was a critical and popular success, praised for its intelligence, its authenticity, and its gripping, high-stakes narrative. It’s a show that is as much a lesson in global economics as it is a thrilling crime story. The show’s complex hero is a fascinating character study, a theme you can explore in our list of the Top 5 Favorite Movie Anti-Heroes of All Time.

Where to Watch: Stream McMafia on BBC iPlayer.

18. New Tricks (2003–2015)

The Vibe: A charming, witty, and incredibly cozy procedural about a group of retired detectives who are brought back to solve the unsolvable.

Synopsis: The series follows the Unsolved Crime and Open Case Squad (UCOS), a fictional branch of the Metropolitan Police Service. The team is made up of three retired, old-school detectives, led by the brilliant but often exasperated Detective Superintendent Sandra Pullman. Using their decades of experience and their often-unorthodox methods, the team tackles cold cases, bringing fresh eyes and old tricks to crimes that have remained unsolved for years.

Why It's Binge-worthy: New Tricks is the ultimate comfort watch. It’s a show with a huge amount of heart and a brilliant sense of humour. The chemistry between the veteran cast, including legends like Dennis Waterman, Alun Armstrong, and James Bolam, is an absolute delight. The mysteries are clever and well-plotted, but the true joy of the show is in watching these grumpy but lovable old detectives bicker, bond, and ultimately, get the job done.

What Makes It a Classic: The show’s incredible, enduring popularity is a testament to its brilliant premise and its wonderful characters. It’s a gentle, charming, and thoroughly entertaining series that proves that you’re never too old to learn new tricks—or to solve a murder. For more on the show's long run, the BBC's official page is a great resource. The show's focus on a found family is a huge part of its appeal, a dynamic explored in our list of The Top 5 Best Movies With An Ensemble Cast.

Where to Watch: Stream New Tricks on BBC iPlayer.

17. Shetland (2013–present)

The Vibe: A moody, atmospheric, and beautifully bleak detective series set against the stunning, windswept landscape of the Shetland Islands.

Synopsis: The series follows the quiet, compassionate, and deeply intuitive Detective Inspector Jimmy Pérez. Set in the remote and isolated archipelago of Shetland, the series sees Pérez and his team investigate a series of dark and often disturbing crimes. The tight-knit, claustrophobic nature of the island community means that the killer is almost always someone they know, adding a layer of personal tragedy to every case.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Shetland is a masterpiece of atmosphere. The landscape itself is a major character—beautiful, unforgiving, and full of secrets. The show is a slow-burn, character-driven mystery that is as much about the emotional lives of its characters as it is about the crimes they are solving. Douglas Henshall's (and later, Ashley Jensen's) performance in the lead role is understated and brilliant, creating a detective who is both gentle and relentless.

What Makes It a Classic: The show has been a critical and popular success, praised for its intelligent writing, its stunning cinematography, and its powerful sense of place. It’s a show that proves that a compelling mystery doesn't need to be set in a bustling city. The quiet, melancholic beauty of Shetland is utterly unique and unforgettable. For a taste of the real Shetland, the official Shetland tourism website has some breathtaking images.

Where to Watch: Stream Shetland on BBC iPlayer.

16. Father Brown (2013–present)

The Vibe: A charming, witty, and incredibly cozy period detective drama set in the idyllic English countryside of the 1950s.

Synopsis: Based on the classic short stories by G. K. Chesterton, the series follows Father Brown, a Roman Catholic priest in the fictional Cotswold village of Kembleford. While he may be a humble man of the cloth, he has a brilliant, insightful mind and a deep understanding of the human soul. Using his keen powers of observation and his gentle, empathetic nature, he has a remarkable knack for solving the surprisingly frequent murders that occur in his seemingly peaceful parish.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Father Brown is the television equivalent of a warm cup of tea on a rainy afternoon. It’s a delightful and utterly charming "cozy mystery" series. The 1950s setting is beautifully realised, and the Cotswold village is the perfect, picturesque backdrop for the drama. Mark Williams is perfectly cast as the clever and compassionate Father Brown. The mysteries are clever and engaging, but the show's true appeal lies in its warmth, its humour, and its gentle, optimistic spirit.

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a global phenomenon, a testament to the enduring appeal of the cozy mystery genre. It’s a show that is both a clever detective series and a heartwarming drama about a community and the kind, intelligent man at its heart. For more on the original author, the American Chesterton Society has a wealth of information. The show’s focus on a powerful community is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Movies About Friendship.

Where to Watch: Stream Father Brown on BBC iPlayer.

15. The Fall (2013–2016, BBC Two)

The Vibe: A chilling, intense, and deeply unsettling psychological thriller that is a masterclass in suspense. This is a dark and compelling cat-and-mouse game between two brilliant and obsessive individuals.

Synopsis: The series follows two parallel storylines. The first is that of Detective Superintendent Stella Gibson (a phenomenal Gillian Anderson), a brilliant, cool, and fiercely intelligent police officer who is brought to Belfast to review a murder investigation. The second is that of Paul Spector (a terrifying Jamie Dornan), a seemingly ordinary family man and grief counsellor who is secretly a meticulous and sadistic serial killer. The show follows Stella’s relentless hunt for Spector, and Spector’s own dark, psychological games as he taunts the police.

Why It's Binge-worthy: The Fall is one of the most suspenseful and psychologically astute thrillers ever made. Unlike a traditional "whodunit," we know who the killer is from the very first scene. The tension comes from the incredibly tense, slow-burn cat-and-mouse game between Stella and Spector. The performances from Anderson and Dornan are absolutely electrifying. It is a dark, complex, and often uncomfortable show that is a powerful exploration of misogyny, obsession, and the nature of evil.

What Makes It a Classic: The show was a critical sensation, praised for its intelligent writing, its feminist perspective, and its masterful creation of suspense. It’s a show that is not for the faint of heart, but for those who appreciate a dark, complex, and character-driven thriller, it is essential viewing. The show's intricate plot will keep you guessing, a quality it shares with the films on our list of 6 Gripping Suspense Thriller Movies You Can't Miss.

Where to Watch: Stream The Fall on BBC iPlayer.

14. Line of Duty (2012–2021)

The Vibe: A tense, complex, and incredibly addictive police procedural that turns the genre on its head by focusing on the police who police the police.

Synopsis: The series follows the investigations of AC-12, a controversial anti-corruption unit within the police force. The show is led by the trio of Superintendent Ted Hastings, DS Steve Arnott, and DI Kate Fleming. Each season sees them investigating a different, seemingly heroic police officer who is suspected of being corrupt. Their investigations invariably lead them into a vast and dangerous web of conspiracy involving organized crime and a network of corrupt officers at the very highest levels of the police force.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Line of Duty is one of the most successful and critically acclaimed British dramas of the 21st century. It is famous for its incredibly tense and brilliantly written interrogation scenes, which can often last for over twenty minutes of uninterrupted, dialogue-driven drama. The show is packed with police jargon, acronyms, and intricate plotting that rewards close attention. It is a show that will have you on the edge of your seat, shouting at the television, and desperately trying to unravel the central mystery of "H."

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a cultural phenomenon in the UK, a true "water-cooler" show that had the entire nation talking. Its creator, Jed Mercurio, is a master of the modern thriller. The show is a must-watch for anyone who loves a smart, complex, and incredibly suspenseful story. The show’s unflinching portrayal of betrayal and corruption is a powerful theme, one you can explore in our list of the Top 7 Best Movies About Betrayal, Revenge, and Deception.

Where to Watch: Stream Line of Duty on BBC iPlayer.

13. The Suspicions of Mr Whicher (2011–2014)

The Vibe: A dark, atmospheric, and beautifully crafted series of period detective films based on a real-life Victorian super-sleuth.

Synopsis: Based on the bestselling book by Kate Summerscale, this series of four feature-length films follows the real-life detective, Inspector Jonathan "Jack" Whicher, one of the original members of Scotland Yard's new detective branch in the mid-19th century. Each film sees the brilliant but troubled Whicher investigating a dark and shocking crime that exposes the hypocrisy and secrets lurking beneath the surface of respectable Victorian society.

Why It's Binge-worthy: This is a must-watch for any fan of historical true crime. The series is meticulously researched and does an incredible job of recreating the gaslit, often brutal world of Victorian England. Paddy Considine is magnificent as the melancholic and deeply moral Mr. Whicher. The mysteries are complex and compelling, but the true strength of the series is its powerful sense of atmosphere and its unflinching look at the dark side of the Victorian era.

What Makes It a Classic: The series was a critical success, praised for its intelligence, its historical authenticity, and its powerful central performance. It’s a show that will appeal to fans of classic detective stories and anyone who is fascinated by the Victorian era. For more on the real Jack Whicher, the original book by Kate Summerscale is a masterpiece of historical non-fiction.

Where to Watch: Stream The Suspicions of Mr Whicher on services like BritBox or Amazon Prime Video with a relevant subscription.

12. Dalziel and Pascoe (1996–2007)

The Vibe: A classic, character-driven police procedural built on the brilliant "odd couple" dynamic of its two lead detectives.

Synopsis: Based on the acclaimed novels by Reginald Hill, the series follows the partnership of two Yorkshire detectives who are polar opposites. Detective Superintendent Andy Dalziel is a gruff, politically incorrect, old-school copper who relies on his instincts. Detective Inspector Peter Pascoe is a university-educated, sensitive, and modern policeman who prefers to go by the book. Despite their clashing personalities and methods, they form a formidable and deeply loyal partnership.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Dalziel and Pascoe is a classic of the genre. The mysteries are clever and well-plotted, but the heart of the show is the incredible chemistry between its two leads, Warren Clarke (Dalziel) and Colin Buchanan (Pascoe). Their relationship is the perfect blend of conflict, humour, and a deep, unspoken affection. It’s a show that is as much about the friendship between these two men as it is about the crimes they solve.

What Makes It a Classic: The show was a long-running and beloved staple of the BBC for over a decade. It’s a perfect example of a character-driven procedural, a show that you watch as much for the characters as you do for the mystery. The show’s focus on a powerful partnership is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of 5 Must-Watch Movies About Unlikely Friendships.

Where to Watch: Stream Dalziel and Pascoe on services like BritBox or UKTV Play.

11. The Inspector Lynley Mysteries (2001–2008)

The Vibe: A sophisticated and elegant detective series that explores the British class system through the partnership of its two aristocratic and working-class leads.

Synopsis: Based on the novels by Elizabeth George, the series follows the partnership of two very different Scotland Yard detectives. Detective Inspector Thomas Lynley is the 8th Earl of Asherton, a polished, charming, and immensely wealthy aristocrat who drives a vintage Bentley. His partner is the prickly, fiercely independent, and working-class Detective Sergeant Barbara Havers. Together, they tackle a series of complex and often tragic murders, their different backgrounds and perspectives often providing the key to solving the case.

Why It's Binge-worthy: This show is a brilliant blend of classic, clever mystery and sharp social commentary. The "odd couple" dynamic between the suave Lynley and the down-to-earth Havers is fantastic, and their evolving friendship is the heart of the series. The mysteries are intricate and often set against the beautiful backdrop of the English countryside and the grand estates of the aristocracy.

What Makes It a Classic: The series was a huge international success, praised for its intelligent scripts, its beautiful locations, and the brilliant chemistry of its leads. It’s a show that is both a satisfying, traditional detective drama and a fascinating exploration of the enduring complexities of the British class system. For more on the author, the official Elizabeth George website is a great resource.

Where to Watch: Stream The Inspector Lynley Mysteries on BritBox.

10. Jonathan Creek (1997–2016)

The Vibe: A quirky, charming, and incredibly clever mystery series that turns the classic "whodunit" into a "howdunit."

Synopsis: The series follows Jonathan Creek, a cynical but brilliant creative consultant to a famous stage magician. He lives in a converted windmill and spends his days designing illusions. He has a unique, logical mind that allows him to solve seemingly impossible "locked-room" mysteries. He is frequently roped into solving these bizarre crimes by the investigative journalist Maddy Magellan (and later, other female foils). The crimes are never straightforward; they involve things like a man who can walk through walls or a murder committed inside a sealed bunker.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Jonathan Creek is a pure, intellectual delight. It is one of the most original and cleverly written mystery series of all time. The mysteries are brilliant, logical puzzles that play fair with the audience. The joy of the show is in trying to figure out the "trick" before Creek does. Alan Davies is perfect as the scruffy, duffle-coat-wearing genius, and his chemistry with his various female partners is always fantastic.

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a beloved cult classic, a testament to the brilliant writing of its creator, David Renwick. It’s a show that celebrates logic, ingenuity, and the power of a well-constructed puzzle. It’s a must-watch for anyone who loves a mystery that is truly baffling. The show’s unique hero is a fascinating character study, a theme you can explore in our list of the Top 5 Most Intelligent Characters in TV History.

Where to Watch: Stream Jonathan Creek on BBC iPlayer or BritBox.

9. Vera (2011–present, ITV production, BBC in UK distribution)

The Vibe: A classic, character-driven detective drama led by one of the most iconic and beloved female detectives in modern television.

Synopsis: The series is set in the beautiful, bleak, and atmospheric landscape of Northumberland. It follows the brilliant but cantankerous Detective Chief Inspector Vera Stanhope. Dressed in her signature scruffy raincoat and bucket hat, Vera is often underestimated, but she possesses a sharp, forensic mind and a deep, if often hidden, empathy for the victims. Each feature-length episode sees her and her loyal team unravel a complex and often tragic murder.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Vera is a television institution. The show's enduring popularity is a testament to the incredible, BAFTA-winning performance of Brenda Blethyn. She has created a truly unforgettable character in Vera Stanhope. The mysteries are always compelling and intelligently plotted, but the show's true strength is in its powerful sense of place and its deep, compassionate exploration of the human condition.

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a global success, praised for its brilliant central performance and its beautiful, atmospheric cinematography. It’s a perfect example of a classic, character-driven British detective drama. The show's focus on a powerful female lead is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Female-Led Action Movies of All Time.

Where to Watch: Stream Vera on ITVX, with some seasons available on BritBox.

8. Broadchurch (2013–2017, ITV production, BBC in international distribution)

The Vibe: A heartbreaking, emotionally gripping, and beautifully cinematic mystery that is as much about the devastating impact of a crime on a small community as it is about solving it.

Synopsis: The series begins with the tragic death of an 11-year-old boy, Danny Latimer, in the small, picturesque Dorset coastal town of Broadchurch. The investigation is led by two detectives: the cynical, haunted outsider, DI Alec Hardy, and the compassionate, local DS Ellie Miller, who was a close friend of the victim's family. The show follows their investigation, but it also delves deep into the grief of the Latimer family and the paranoia and suspicion that rips through the tight-knit community as the media descends.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Broadchurch was a cultural phenomenon. It is one of the most emotionally powerful and beautifully crafted television dramas of the 21st century. The performances from its ensemble cast, particularly Olivia Colman as Ellie Miller and David Tennant as Alec Hardy, are simply breathtaking. The cinematography is stunning, capturing the haunting beauty of the Dorset coast. The first season is a perfect, self-contained mystery that will have you sobbing one minute and on the edge of your seat the next.

What Makes It a Classic: The show was a global critical success, winning multiple BAFTAs and redefining the modern crime drama. It’s a show that proves that a detective story can be a profound and moving exploration of grief, community, and the human heart. The show’s intense drama is gripping, a quality it shares with the films on our list of 6 Gripping Suspense Thriller Movies You Can't Miss.

Where to Watch: Stream Broadchurch on ITVX or BritBox.

7. Life on Mars (2006–2007)

The Vibe: A brilliantly inventive, mind-bending, and surprisingly poignant fusion of a classic police procedural with a high-concept science fiction premise.

Synopsis: The series follows DCI Sam Tyler, a modern-day detective from Manchester who, after being hit by a car in 2006, inexplicably wakes up in the year 1973. He finds himself working as a Detective Inspector in the same police station, but it's a world he doesn't recognize—a world of brutal, politically incorrect policing, rampant sexism, and clunky, analogue technology. He is forced to navigate this strange and often hostile new environment under the command of the swaggering, chauvinistic, and completely brilliant DCI Gene Hunt, all while desperately trying to figure out if he is mad, in a coma, or if he has actually travelled through time.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Life on Mars is one of the most original and beloved British dramas of all time. The central mystery of Sam's situation is incredibly compelling, creating a layer of surreal, psychological tension that elevates the entire series. The "fish-out-of-water" dynamic is a source of both fantastic drama and brilliant comedy, as Sam’s modern, by-the-book policing methods constantly clash with the brutish, instinct-driven tactics of Gene Hunt’s 1970s squad. The show’s recreation of the 1970s is flawless, from the fashion and the cars to the incredible glam rock soundtrack, featuring artists like David Bowie (whose song gives the show its title), T. Rex, and The Sweet.

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a masterpiece of character and concept. The relationship between the thoughtful, modern Sam Tyler (John Simm) and the iconic, hard-drinking DCI Gene Hunt (Philip Glenister) is one of the greatest partnerships in television history. Hunt, with his famous catchphrase "Fire up the Quattro!", is a legendary creation—a character who is both a dinosaur and a hero. The series is more than just a detective show; it's a powerful exploration of identity, memory, and the idea of home. The ambiguous and deeply moving finale is still hotly debated by fans to this day. For a deep dive into the show's cultural impact and its brilliant spin-off, Ashes to Ashes, the BBC's official cult TV page often has retrospective articles. This kind of bold, genre-defining work is always exciting, a quality it shares with the films on our list of The Top 5 Best Sci-Fi Movies of All Time.

Where to Watch: Stream Life on Mars on BBC iPlayer.

6. Happy Valley (2014–2023)

The Vibe: A dark, gritty, and breathtakingly brilliant crime drama that is a powerful and unflinching portrait of a tough, resilient police sergeant and the community she protects.

Synopsis: The series stars the magnificent Sarah Lancashire as Catherine Cawood, a police sergeant in the Calder Valley of West Yorkshire. Catherine is a brilliant police officer, a loving grandmother, and a woman who is still dealing with the immense trauma of her daughter’s suicide years earlier, a suicide she blames on the man who brutally assaulted her daughter, the psychopathic Tommy Lee Royce. When Royce is released from prison, Catherine becomes obsessed with finding him, a quest that puts her and her family in terrible danger.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Happy Valley is, without a doubt, one of the greatest television dramas ever made. The writing, from creator Sally Wainwright, is flawless. The plotting is incredibly tense, and the dialogue is so authentic it feels like you're listening to real people. But the show belongs to Sarah Lancashire. Her performance as Catherine Cawood is a tour de force, a perfect portrayal of a woman who is both incredibly strong and incredibly vulnerable.

What Makes It a Classic: The show has received universal critical acclaim, winning a shelf-full of BAFTAs. It is a show that is both a gripping, edge-of-your-seat thriller and a profound and moving exploration of grief, trauma, and family. It is a true masterpiece of television. The show's complex and terrifying villain is a fascinating character study, a theme you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Villains of All Time.

Where to Watch: Stream Happy Valley on BBC iPlayer.

5. Wallander (2008–2016)

The Vibe: A moody, melancholic, and beautifully cinematic British adaptation of the classic Swedish noir novels.

Synopsis: The series stars Sir Kenneth Branagh as Inspector Kurt Wallander, a brilliant but deeply troubled police detective in the small, picturesque town of Ystad, Sweden. Wallander is a man who is haunted by the darkness he confronts every day. He is a philosophical and deeply empathetic detective, and the horrific crimes he investigates take a profound personal and psychological toll on him.

Why It's Binge-worthy: The BBC's adaptation of Henning Mankell's novels is a masterpiece of mood and atmosphere. The show is stunningly beautiful, with cinematography that perfectly captures the bleak, melancholic beauty of the Swedish landscape. Kenneth Branagh is absolutely magnificent as Wallander, delivering a powerful and moving performance of a good man struggling to stay afloat in a sea of darkness. The mysteries are dark, complex, and often deeply unsettling.

What Makes It a Classic: The series was a huge international success, winning multiple BAFTAs and introducing a whole new audience to the world of "Scandi-noir." It is a show that is both a brilliant detective series and a profound and moving exploration of existential angst. The show’s complex hero is a fascinating character study, a theme you can explore in our list of 6 Must-Watch Psychological Thriller Movies.

Where to Watch: Stream Wallander on BBC iPlayer or BritBox.

4. The Missing (2014–2016)

The Vibe: A heartbreaking, gripping, and masterfully constructed anthology series that is an unflinching and powerful exploration of a parent's worst nightmare.

Synopsis: Each of the two series of The Missing follows a single, complex case of a missing child, told across multiple timelines. The first series follows Tony and Emily Hughes, whose five-year-old son, Oliver, vanishes while they are on holiday in France. The story jumps between the initial investigation in 2006 and the present day, where Tony is still obsessively searching for his son. The investigation is led by the brilliant and deeply empathetic French detective, Julien Baptiste.

Why It's Binge-worthy: The Missing is one of the most emotionally devastating and brilliantly plotted mystery series ever made. The performances are absolutely phenomenal, particularly from James Nesbitt as the grief-stricken Tony in the first series. The non-linear storytelling is masterfully handled, slowly and painstakingly revealing the clues and the devastating emotional toll the case takes on everyone involved. It is a show that will have you on the edge of your seat and will stay with you long after it’s over.

What Makes It a Classic: The series was a global critical success, winning BAFTAs and receiving Emmy and Golden Globe nominations. It is a powerful and unflinching look at grief, obsession, and the slimmest glimmers of hope in the face of unimaginable tragedy. The character of Julien Baptiste, played by Tchéky Karyo, was so popular that he received his own spin-off series, Baptiste. The show’s intricate plot will keep you guessing, a quality it shares with the films on our list of 6 Gripping Suspense Thriller Movies You Can't Miss.

Where to Watch: Stream The Missing on BBC iPlayer.

3. Sherlock (2010–2017)

The Vibe: A fast, funny, and incredibly stylish modern reinvention of the world's most famous detective.

Synopsis: This is the Sherlock Holmes for the 21st century. The series brings the iconic characters of Holmes and Watson into modern-day London, a world of smartphones, blogs, and GPS. Benedict Cumberbatch plays Sherlock as a brilliant, high-functioning sociopath, and Martin Freeman is the perfect, grounded, and deeply loyal Dr. John Watson. Together, they solve a series of bizarre and ingenious crimes, all while facing off against Sherlock's arch-nemesis, the brilliant and unhinged Moriarty.

Why It's Binge-worthy: Sherlock was a global cultural phenomenon. It is one of the most inventive, visually dynamic, and brilliantly written television shows of all time. The ninety-minute, feature-length episode format allows for incredibly complex and cinematic storytelling. The chemistry between Cumberbatch and Freeman is legendary, and their updated take on the Holmes and Watson partnership is the heart and soul of the show. The show’s use of on-screen text and graphics to visualize Sherlock’s thought process was revolutionary and has been widely imitated.

What Makes It a Classic: The show was a massive international success, winning a shelf-full of BAFTAs and Emmys and turning its two leads into global superstars. It is a show that is both a loving tribute to Arthur Conan Doyle's original stories and a brilliantly modern reinvention. It is, quite simply, a work of genius. For more on the original stories, the official Conan Doyle Estate website is a fantastic resource. The show’s focus on a powerful partnership is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of 5 Must-Watch Movies About Unlikely Friendships.

Where to Watch: Stream Sherlock on BBC iPlayer.

2. Prime Suspect (1991–2006)

The Vibe: A groundbreaking, gritty, and fiercely feminist police procedural that is one of the most important and influential television shows of all time.

Synopsis: As detailed earlier in this list, the series stars the legendary Dame Helen Mirren as the brilliant, tenacious, and deeply flawed Detective Chief Inspector Jane Tennison. Set in the deeply sexist and hostile world of the London Metropolitan Police in the 1990s, the show follows Tennison as she battles not only to solve a series of brutal, high-profile murders, but also to earn the respect of her male colleagues who are determined to see her fail.

Why It's at This Rank: Placing Prime Suspect this high on the list is a recognition of its monumental, game-changing impact. Before Jane Tennison, there were very few complex, flawed, and powerful female protagonists in television crime drama. The show was revolutionary in its unflinching portrayal of institutional sexism and its creation of a truly realistic and three-dimensional female hero. The mysteries are dark and compelling, but the true, enduring power of the show is in Tennison's relentless fight for her place in a man's world.

What Makes It a Classic: The show was a global critical sensation, winning a huge number of BAFTAs and Emmys. It had a profound and lasting impact on the television landscape, paving the way for a generation of complex female-led dramas like The Fall and Happy Valley. It is absolutely essential viewing for anyone interested in the history of television. The show's powerful female lead is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Female-Led Action Movies of All Time.

Where to Watch: Stream Prime Suspect on BritBox.

1. Luther (2010–2019)

The Vibe: A dark, gritty, and psychologically intense thriller led by one of the most charismatic and iconic performances in modern television.

Synopsis: The series stars the magnificent Idris Elba as Detective Chief Inspector John Luther, a brilliant but deeply tormented and self-destructive detective working for the Serious and Serial Crime Unit. Luther is a man who is haunted by the darkness he confronts every day. He is a genius at catching killers, but his methods are often unorthodox and on the very edge of the law. His life is further complicated by his strange, symbiotic relationship with Alice Morgan, a brilliant, psychopathic narcissist and killer whom he can’t quite bring himself to arrest.

Why It's at the Top: Luther is the perfect synthesis of everything that makes the British detective drama great. It has the brilliant, tortured, Holmes-ian anti-hero at its centre. It has a dark, atmospheric, and cinematic vision of London. It has a series of genuinely terrifying and memorable villains. And it has, in the character of John Luther, one of the most charismatic and compelling protagonists in television history. Idris Elba’s performance is a tour de force; he is a force of nature, a perfect blend of intimidating physicality, brilliant intellect, and deep, soul-crushing pain.

What Makes It a Classic: The show is a global phenomenon. It is a show that is as much a psychological thriller as it is a detective procedural. The cat-and-mouse relationship between Luther and Alice is one of the most fascinating and twisted dynamics on television. The show is dark, it is violent, and it is utterly, completely addictive. In 2025, with a successful feature film having recently been released, Luther stands as the undisputed king of modern BBC detective drama, a perfect, iconic, and unforgettable series. For more on the show's dark and complex world, the BBC's official Luther page is a great resource.

Where to Watch: Stream Luther on BBC iPlayer.

Conclusion: A Proud Tradition of Brilliant Television

From the cozy villages of the Cotswolds to the dark, rain-slicked streets of London, the BBC has given the world a rich and enduring legacy of detective drama. The twenty shows on this list represent the very best of that tradition. They are a testament to the power of a well-told mystery, the allure of a brilliant, eccentric detective, and the unique, atmospheric charm of British television.

These are shows that do more than just entertain; they are intelligent, character-driven dramas that explore the complexities of the human condition. They are a celebration of a genre that continues to evolve, to surprise, and to captivate audiences around the world. As the autumn evenings draw in, there is no better time to immerse yourself in these brilliant, binge-worthy worlds. Your next great obsession is just a click away.

Enjoyed what you read? If you found this article insightful and it helps you discover your next great binge-watch, please consider supporting our work. Your generosity allows us to continue creating and sharing in-depth cultural commentary. You can make a donation by moving your cursor to the top of the article or scrolling down to the bottom. Every little bit helps us spread the love, one article at a time!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is BBC iPlayer? BBC iPlayer is the BBC's free-to-use video on demand service. If you have a TV Licence in the UK, you can stream a huge catalogue of shows, including many on this list, for free.

2. Are all these shows available on BBC iPlayer? While most of the BBC-produced shows are available on iPlayer, some of the older titles or co-productions (like Vera or Broadchurch) may be found on other UK-based streaming services like BritBox or ITVX.

3. I don't live in the UK. How can I watch these shows? Many of these shows have been huge international successes and are available on various streaming platforms around the world. Services like BritBox (a joint venture between the BBC and ITV) are available in many countries and are the best place to find a large collection of British television.

4. What is a "procedural" drama? A procedural is a type of television show that focuses on the process or procedure of a particular profession. A police procedural, for example, focuses on the step-by-step process of solving a crime, from the discovery of the body to the final arrest.

5. What is a "cozy mystery"? A cozy mystery, like Father Brown, is a subgenre of crime fiction where the violence and sex are downplayed or happen off-screen. The detective is often an amateur sleuth, and the setting is usually a small, charming community.

6. What does "anthology series" mean? An anthology series, like The Missing, is a show where each season (or sometimes each episode) tells a different, self-contained story with a new set of characters and a new plot.

7. Why are so many of these shows based on books? The UK has a rich literary tradition of crime and mystery writing, from Arthur Conan Doyle to P.D. James. These novels provide a fantastic source of well-plotted stories and beloved characters for television adaptations.

8. What is "Scandi-noir"? "Scandi-noir" is a genre of crime fiction from the Nordic countries that is characterized by its bleak, moody atmosphere, its complex and often tortured detectives, and its focus on dark social and political themes. The BBC's adaptation of Wallander is a British take on this genre.

9. Are there any true crime stories on this list? Yes, The Suspicions of Mr Whicher is based on the real-life story of one of Scotland Yard's first detectives and a real, infamous murder case from 1860.

10. I've watched all of these! What should I watch next? The BBC has a vast back catalogue of incredible detective dramas. You could explore other classics like Inspector Morse, A Touch of Frost, or the modern hit Bodyguard. The recommendation features on BBC iPlayer are a great way to discover your next favourite.