Clayface Arrives This Week as DC’s Mike Flanagan Horror Gamble Wins Strong Early Reviews
Clayface is finally here, and DC Studios may have quietly delivered one of the strangest superhero movies of the year.
The project began as one of the most unexpected announcements in James Gunn and Peter Safran’s new DC Universe: a standalone body-horror movie about a shape-shifting Batman villain, based on a story by Mike Flanagan and directed by James Watkins. Collider originally highlighted the film’s October 2026 release plans, but as of 22 October the story has moved well beyond a release-date update.
Clayface is now opening internationally, with its North American theatrical release set for 23 October 2026, and the first full reviews are already arriving. The early response is broadly positive, with critics praising the film’s gruesome practical effects, stripped-back villain origin story and surprisingly confident decision to behave like a horror film first and a superhero movie second.
Variety describes Clayface as good, gross fun with no franchise homework required, while Time Out gives the film four stars and compares its body horror to The Substance and the work of David Cronenberg. That is not the sort of language usually attached to a DC movie, which may be exactly why this one suddenly feels so interesting.
The film stars Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, a rising actor whose career collapses after a brutal disfiguring attack. Desperate to restore his face, he agrees to an experimental treatment from scientist Dr. Caitlyn Corr, played by Naomi Ackie. The procedure works—until it begins changing his body into something unstable, malleable and increasingly monstrous.
Support That Love Podcast
Enjoying our entertainment coverage? You can help support That Love Podcast and keep independent reviews, news and original storytelling going.
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans?
If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
Clayface Is a Very Different Kind of DC Movie
The most important thing to know about Clayface is that DC Studios has not tried to turn Matt Hagen into another conventional superhero lead. The official film site describes the movie as a horror thriller, and the early reviews support that label.
Matt begins as a rising Hollywood star whose face is destroyed after crossing a dangerous Gotham crime boss. He seeks out a cutting-edge medical treatment that initially appears to restore what he lost, but the same procedure begins affecting his body and his grip on reality.
That setup gives the movie a familiar tragic-monster structure. The clearest comparison is The Fly, which director James Watkins has openly cited as an influence alongside David Cronenberg, John Carpenter and An American Werewolf in London.
Watkins is an interesting choice because his previous work, including Eden Lake and Speak No Evil, shows he is comfortable with cruelty, discomfort and characters trapped in increasingly ugly situations. Clayface gives him superhero resources but does not appear to ask him to soften those instincts.
That may be the film’s greatest advantage. A shape-shifting villain whose body can melt, stretch and reform should be horrifying. Treating those powers mainly as colourful action effects would waste half the character’s potential.
Mike Flanagan’s Pitch Is the Reason This Movie Exists
Clayface was not originally a character Gunn and Safran were actively trying to build a movie around. Peter Safran recently explained that Mike Flanagan came to DC with the idea, and his passion for the concept convinced the studio that it fit the broader range of genres they wanted the DCU to explore.
That detail matters because it helps explain why the film feels more specific than a franchise obligation. Flanagan is best known for emotionally heavy horror including The Haunting of Hill House, Midnight Mass and Doctor Sleep. His work often uses supernatural or monstrous material to explore grief, identity, addiction and self-destruction.
Clayface fits naturally into that territory. Matt Hagen’s horror is not simply that he becomes physically grotesque. His entire sense of worth has been built around a face that Hollywood rewarded, and once that face is taken from him, the desperation to restore it becomes the doorway to something much worse.
Flanagan receives story credit and co-wrote the screenplay with Hossein Amini. James Watkins then directs the final film, so this is not a Flanagan-directed project, but his fingerprints are still all over the central tragedy.
Tom Rhys Harries Plays Matt Hagen Instead of Basil Karlo
One of the more interesting choices is the decision to build the movie around Matt Hagen rather than Basil Karlo, the version of Clayface many comic readers associate with the name first.
The film casts Welsh actor Tom Rhys Harries as Hagen. The official synopsis describes him as a Gotham street kid who rises all the way to Hollywood leading-man status before a crime boss destroys his face and his career.
Harries is still relatively unfamiliar to mainstream audiences, which works in the film’s favour. Variety notes that the role benefits from an actor whose face audiences do not already know too well because the story is literally about fame, beauty and the destruction of a recognisable identity.
Early reactions have been especially positive about him. Several critics and journalists singled out Harries as a breakout performer, praising the mix of charm, desperation and menace he brings to Matt.
That matters because Clayface can easily become a special-effects character. If audiences stop seeing the wounded actor underneath the transformations, the tragedy disappears.
Naomi Ackie Gives the Science-Fiction Horror a Human Counterweight
Naomi Ackie plays Dr. Caitlyn Corr, the scientist whose experimental treatment gives Matt a chance to restore his appearance. On paper, that role could easily become a generic exposition machine: scientist explains impossible technology, experiment goes wrong, monster escapes.
The early reviews suggest Ackie gets more to work with. Variety praises the curiosity and conscience she brings to Caitlyn, while the film also develops a gothic-romantic connection between her and Matt.
That relationship gives the body horror emotional stakes. Caitlyn is not simply responsible for an accident; she becomes connected to the person being transformed by it. The best versions of Frankenstein-style stories work because creator and creation are tied together long after the experiment stops being controllable.
The supporting cast includes David Dencik, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan, Nancy Carroll and Joshua James. Matt Reeves, James Gunn and Peter Safran are among the producers, giving the project an unusual combination of DCU oversight and Batman-world creative experience.
The Early Clayface Reviews Are Better Than Many Expected
The first full reviews suggest DC’s gamble has paid off creatively. Variety’s review calls the movie a nasty, gnarly body-horror film that works because it feels less constrained by superhero-franchise expectations.
Time Out is even more enthusiastic, awarding the film four stars and calling it one of the best DC films in years if viewers can handle the gore. The review praises the noir atmosphere, the practical effects and the decision to make Matt Hagen genuinely sympathetic before pushing him towards monstrosity.
The social-media reactions that arrived before the review embargo were similarly positive. Collider editor-in-chief Steven Weintraub called the film fantastic and highlighted how brutal the R-rated material becomes, while other early viewers praised the creativity of Clayface’s powers and Harries’ performance.
The caution is that early social reactions often skew enthusiastic, and a superhero film this unusual will almost certainly divide some audiences. Viewers expecting a conventional Batman-adjacent action movie may be surprised by how much time Clayface spends being a grotesque horror film.
But that division may be healthier than another safe superhero release. DC needs individual projects to feel different if its shared universe is going to avoid the sameness that eventually hurt other franchise models.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your movie, series, book, entertainment brand, product or business in front of readers who love television, movies, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers advertising and sponsorship opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
Clayface Does Not Require DCU Homework
One of the most encouraging points in the early reviews is that Clayface appears to stand on its own. Variety specifically notes that viewers do not need knowledge of the wider DC Universe to understand the film.
That is important because shared universes increasingly risk turning entertainment into homework. Audiences should not need to remember eight television episodes and two post-credit scenes to understand why a man is horrified that his body is melting.
Clayface appears to use Gotham and the DCU as context rather than as the entire reason for existing. The film introduces its own Matt Hagen, its own supporting cast and its own horror problem, then lets the larger universe sit mostly in the background.
Peter Safran has described the movie as the first step into the DCU’s live-action Gotham, which gives it franchise significance without forcing Batman himself to dominate the story.
That is probably the right approach. Gotham should be interesting enough to sustain stories where Batman is not physically standing in the room.
This Is the DCU’s First Real Step Into Gotham
The new DC Universe has already moved through Superman’s Metropolis, Supergirl’s cosmic side of the mythology and Lanterns’ Green Lantern mystery. Clayface is significant because it brings the shared universe into Gotham territory through a villain rather than through the new Batman.
That immediately raises questions about what kind of Gotham James Gunn and Peter Safran want to build. Matt Reeves’ The Batman universe remains separate, so the city seen in Clayface belongs to the main DCU rather than Robert Pattinson’s continuity.
Early reviews describe the film’s Gotham material as noirish, grimy and visually distinct. That suggests the eventual DCU Batman may enter a city that already has its own monsters, criminals and scientific horrors before Bruce Wayne becomes the centre of the conversation.
It also supports the Gods and Monsters promise Gunn made when unveiling Chapter One. Superman represents the hopeful godlike side of DC. Clayface gives the franchise a literal monster whose tragedy is rooted in very human vanity, ambition and fear.
Why Clayface Could Matter More Than Its Box Office
Clayface is reportedly a comparatively modest production by superhero standards, and that makes it an important test for DC Studios. Not every comic-book movie needs to cost hundreds of millions of dollars or threaten the destruction of a city.
A lower-cost horror film can succeed on a different scale. Horror audiences are accustomed to genre-first projects, while superhero fans get a character they have rarely seen treated seriously in live action.
If Clayface performs well, it gives DC permission to keep experimenting. Characters such as Swamp Thing, Etrigan, Deadman or other Gotham monsters suddenly become easier to imagine as genre films rather than standard superhero spectacles.
That may be more valuable than forcing every DC property into the same tonal box. The early DCU has already shown signs of embracing different formats and genres, and Clayface may be the clearest demonstration yet that the shared universe does not need a single house style.
When Does Clayface Come Out?
Clayface opens in North American cinemas on 23 October 2026. Warner Bros. says international rollout began on 21 October, with release dates varying by market.
The UK release is also set for 23 October. The film runs approximately 108 minutes and carries an adult rating in several markets because of its strong body horror, violence and disturbing imagery.
That Halloween timing is no accident. Clayface is arriving when horror audiences are actively looking for something theatrical, grotesque and seasonal, while superhero fans get one of the strangest DC adaptations ever attempted.
For UK viewers, that means the movie is effectively arriving now rather than sitting somewhere on a distant DC slate.
Final Thoughts
Clayface started as one of the oddest projects on DC Studios’ announcement board. A relatively obscure Batman villain, a horror-first approach, a script born from Mike Flanagan’s pitch and a director better known for unsettling thrillers hardly sounded like the safest way to expand a new superhero universe.
That may be exactly why it works. Everything about the early response suggests the film understands that Clayface should not feel safe. His powers are disgusting, his origin is tragic, and the story appears more interested in identity, beauty and physical decay than in setting up the next crossover.
Tom Rhys Harries looks like a strong discovery, Naomi Ackie gives the science-fiction side emotional weight, and James Watkins appears to have been allowed to make an actual horror film rather than a superhero movie wearing a horror costume.
The full audience response and box office will tell us whether this experiment becomes a wider model for DC Studios. Creatively, though, Clayface already looks like one of the more interesting choices James Gunn and Peter Safran have made.
If DC really wants a universe of gods and monsters, this is the sort of monster it needs.
You May Also Love
Support That Love Podcast
Enjoyed What You Read?
Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest reviews, recommendations, entertainment news, updates and exclusive giveaways. And if you know someone who loves movies, television, books or pop culture, share this article with them too. Let’s spread the love together!
.jpg)
.jpg)
