10 Best Shows Like Lanterns
HBO’s Lanterns sits at an appealing crossroads: a mystery-driven drama, a story about a veteran and a rookie learning to trust each other, and a superhero premise with cosmic weight. If you finished an episode and want a similar show, you do not have to settle for another generic capes-and-quips adventure. The best companions keep some combination of investigation, character friction, strange science, moral uncertainty and a world that feels larger than the case in front of the heroes.
The Green Lantern story follows John Stewart and Hal Jordan as two intergalactic cops pulled into an earthbound murder investigation in the American heartland. That contrast is the hook. The mystery feels close enough to touch, but the mythology surrounding the Lanterns hints at consequences far beyond one town. This ranking looks for shows that understand the same balance: grounded characters at the centre, speculative ideas around them, and enough suspense to make the next episode feel necessary.
You supplied the order, so the countdown preserves it: True Detective is our No. 1, Watchmen follows at No. 2, and the rest descend to Foundation at No. 10. Some are close matches in tone; others make the list because they capture one part of Lanterns especially well. If you want a dark superhero mystery, start near the top. If you are after a space mystery, an alien investigation or a clever binge, there is a different entry for that.
A quick note for UK readers: streaming rights move frequently. The services listed here are the shows’ official or best-known homes, not a guarantee that every season is included in a particular subscription today. Check the linked service’s catalogue or your preferred UK availability guide before signing up. For broader genre ideas, see 10 DC Movies and Shows for Dark Knight Trilogy Fans and Marvel vs. DC: The Best Superhero TV Shows Ranked and Compared. HBO’s own publisher has the current Lanterns press and series information. Let’s get into it 👇
SUPPORT THAT LOVE PODCAST
Enjoying the recommendations? Help keep independent entertainment writing and original audio stories coming by supporting That Love Podcast.
If you love this, check out: 10 Batman Movies and Shows Every Fan Should Watch.
ADVERTISE WITH THAT LOVE PODCAST
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans? If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business, or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast, and newsletter. Find out more.
10. Foundation (2021– )
Foundation is the broadest and most epic entry on this list, which makes it a useful counterpoint to Lanterns’ intimate casework. The series adapts Isaac Asimov’s science-fiction saga, following mathematician Hari Seldon as he predicts the fall of the Galactic Empire and tries to preserve human knowledge through the upheaval ahead. Jared Harris brings measured warmth to Hari, while Lee Pace gives Brother Day the unnerving certainty of a ruler who believes he can personally outwit history.
The mysteries here unfold over decades and across planets. The show asks viewers to track political shifts, family legacies and competing ideas about whether the future can be changed. Its scale is immense, but its most memorable scenes are often small: a private conversation, a decision made under pressure, or an old belief suddenly revealed as a useful lie. That combination of grand design and personal stakes gives Lanterns fans a route into a different kind of cosmic story.
Foundation ranks tenth because it is not a detective series and the time jumps make it less immediately accessible than the other choices. It belongs on the list for viewers who love ambitious world-building, space politics and stories where one clue can alter an entire civilisation. Watch it when you want science fiction at full scale. Where to watch: Apple TV in supported regions; see Apple’s official Foundation page.
9. Counterpart (2017–2019)
Counterpart uses a parallel-world premise to make a spy thriller feel personal. J.K. Simmons plays Howard Silk, a quiet employee at a Berlin agency who discovers that his workplace hides a crossing into another version of Earth. The alternate world has developed along a different path, and Howard meets a counterpart who is more confident, more guarded and much better equipped for the danger ahead. A secret investigation becomes a story about identity and the compromises people make in the name of loyalty.
This is the kind of science-fiction mystery where a glance or withheld detail can matter as much as a chase. Simmons distinguishes the two Howards without turning the contrast into a gimmick. The supporting cast gives the world its own motives and histories, so each revelation alters relationships as well as the plot. Its cold, administrative atmosphere is a clever choice: the extraordinary is hidden behind routines, badges and corridors.
Counterpart is ninth because the espionage mechanics can take a little while to settle, and it has less of the warmth of an odd-couple detective pairing. Still, it is a strong pick for viewers who like speculative thrillers, moral grey areas and characters who have to confront the person they might have become. Where to watch: current UK streaming and rental rights vary; check a live catalogue listing before starting.
8. Silo (2023– )
Silo turns a community’s most basic rules into clues. Rebecca Ferguson plays Juliette Nichols, an engineer living in an underground structure where thousands of people believe the outside air is deadly. When deaths and disappearances raise questions, Juliette follows the evidence through a society designed to keep curiosity in check. The central mystery is not only what happened, but why so many residents accept the official explanation.
The show has a strong detective engine because Juliette thinks like an engineer. She notices what does not fit, tests assumptions and understands that a small physical detail can expose a larger lie. Ferguson plays her as sharp but recognisably human, and the supporting cast makes the silo feel like a lived-in town rather than a science-fiction set. The production design builds a vertical world of workshops, farms, offices and stairwells, each layer carrying its own sense of power.
Silo earns eighth place because it is more of a dystopian conspiracy than a partner-led procedural. Its slow-burn structure is also a feature and a test: if you need every mystery resolved immediately, the waiting may frustrate you. For viewers who enjoy a contained world, a tenacious investigator and a question that keeps growing, it is one of the best sci-fi shows to binge after Lanterns. Where to watch: Apple TV; consult the official series page for the UK catalogue.
7. Legion (2017–2019)
Legion is what happens when superhero television decides the audience should feel as uncertain as the main character. Dan Stevens stars as David Haller, a young man who has spent years being told that his perceptions are symptoms. He discovers that his unusual experiences may also be connected to powerful abilities. That premise makes every memory and revelation unstable: David may be uncovering the truth, but the way he sees it is always part of the question.
The series is visually daring, changing texture and rhythm to make its subjectivity tangible. Music, colour, dance and surreal transitions can make a scene funny, frightening or both before you have time to label it. Stevens anchors the show with a performance that moves between vulnerability and menace. Rachel Keller, Aubrey Plaza and Jean Smart make the surrounding cast feel like people with their own emotional stakes, not just guides through David’s mind.
Legion takes seventh because it is a less direct Lanterns match than Watchmen or The X-Files. It is also much more experimental, so it suits viewers who enjoy unconventional storytelling and psychological science fiction. But the overlap is real: superhero lore, mystery, power that changes how people relate to one another, and the danger of trusting a simple account of events. Choose Legion when you want a comic-book series that is dreamlike, funny and unsettling. Where to watch: availability changes across UK services; check current listings.
6. Dark Matter (2024– )
Apple TV’s Dark Matter takes a multiverse concept and keeps its attention on one family. Joel Edgerton plays Jason Dessen, a physicist who is taken from the ordinary life he shares with Daniela (Jennifer Connelly) and their son into a reality where another version of Jason made very different choices. Finding his way home becomes an urgent search through parallel worlds, but the real tension comes from what each alternate life reveals about the person he might have been.
The adaptation understands that high-concept science fiction needs a human compass. Jason’s fear and determination are easy to follow, while Connelly’s Daniela is a character with her own perspective rather than just a destination for the story. The show creates suspense through variation: familiar streets and faces can become threatening when a single decision has changed. It is a propulsive mystery, but it also pauses to ask whether a person is the sum of their choices or the choices they still make.
Dark Matter lands at six because it does not have Lanterns’ detective partnership, and it is more intimate than its multiverse premise first suggests. That closeness is why it works. It is a great series for viewers who want a fast, emotional science-fiction thriller about identity, family and alternative realities. Where to watch: stream on Apple TV in supported regions; confirm access through Apple’s official Dark Matter page.
🎧 Taking a break from the screen? Listen to original romance and drama stories from That Love Podcast. Explore the latest episodes.
You’ll also love
5. The Expanse (2015–2022)
The Expanse starts with a missing-person case and gradually opens into a solar-system-wide political thriller. Detective Joe Miller (Thomas Jane) is asked to find Julie Mao, while the crew of the ice hauler Canterbury, including James Holden (Steven Strait), become caught in a crisis that pits Earth, Mars and the Belt against one another. Their separate storylines converge, making the original investigation a doorway into questions about power, survival and who gets to control humanity’s future.
The show is one of the most convincing space mysteries because the setting changes the characters’ lives in practical ways. Gravity, travel time, oxygen and water matter. Political identity shapes how people speak and what they fear. That world-building never feels like an instruction manual because it is carried by an ensemble of flawed, recognisable people. Miller’s weary instincts and Holden’s sincere, sometimes irritating idealism make a fascinating contrast; neither has a complete view of the system they are trying to understand.
The Expanse takes fifth because it is more interested in a broad political landscape than in the detective partnership itself. But if Lanterns’ cosmic implications make you want an expansive sci-fi series, this is one of the finest choices. It rewards close attention, builds momentum across seasons and gives space-opera spectacle a solid human foundation. Where to watch: Prime Video has been a major home for the series; check Prime Video’s UK catalogue for current availability.
4. The X-Files (1993–2018)
The X-Files built an enduring science-fiction detective partnership out of one sharp contrast. FBI agent Fox Mulder is convinced that unexplained phenomena deserve serious investigation; Dana Scully is a medical doctor and agent who wants evidence before she accepts a theory. David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson make their disagreements feel like the start of a friendship rather than a debate the show needs to win.
Many episodes are self-contained investigations into strange disappearances, creatures, conspiracies and possible alien activity. That makes the series easy to sample, while the longer mythology gives dedicated viewers a continuing puzzle. Its tone can shift from eerie to funny, and the best episodes understand that the difference between belief and scepticism is not as simple as it sounds. Mulder can be wrong; Scully can be unsettled; both can learn from the case.
The X-Files ranks fourth because it is the blueprint for this kind of show and its leads remain magnetic. A long run naturally has uneven stretches, but the stand-alone stories make the journey manageable. Choose it if you want a classic sci-fi procedural with a slow-building partnership, supernatural cases, government secrets and plenty of stories to binge. Where to watch: UK rights can move between streamers and digital stores; check the current episode catalogue before choosing a service.
3. The Leftovers (2014–2017)
Three years after two per cent of the world’s population disappear, The Leftovers follows the people trying to build lives around an event no one can explain. Justin Theroux plays Kevin Garvey, a police chief whose job demands steadiness as his own family and sense of normality begin to fray. Carrie Coon’s Nora Durst has suffered a devastating personal loss, and the Guilty Remnant turns grief into a silent public protest.
Unlike a conventional mystery, the show does not promise to reveal a single answer that will settle everything. It is interested in what uncertainty does to a community: which beliefs people adopt, how families change, and what kind of comfort a ritual can offer when logic has failed. The performances give its big questions weight. The soundtrack and careful visual choices make the world feel strange without insisting that every strange thing has a supernatural explanation.
The Leftovers ranks third for viewers who value emotional mystery over a neat solution. It is less like a detective procedural than Lanterns, but both series set extraordinary events against recognisable people and places. The question is not only “What happened?” but “How do we keep living after it?” Pick it when you want a demanding, memorable drama about grief, faith and community. Where to watch: HBO rights vary by country; check the current UK service listing.
2. Watchmen (2019)
Watchmen is the clearest match for anyone looking for a superhero show with a dark mystery. Regina King stars as Angela Abar, a police officer in Tulsa who lives in a society still shaped by masked vigilantes, political violence and the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre. When a colleague is attacked, Angela investigates a case that gradually connects her personal history to a much wider account of power and memory.
This is a continuation of the Watchmen graphic novel, not a simple retelling. It uses the original work’s interest in masked identity and political myth to ask its own urgent questions. King’s performance is controlled and commanding, while the supporting cast—including Jeremy Irons, Jean Smart and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II—helps the story move between satire, family drama and science fiction. Clues appear in different eras and forms, and the show trusts you to notice how history is being repeated, edited or concealed.
Watchmen earns second place because it combines an investigation and superhero mythology with unusual ambition. It is the best choice if you want something closest to Lanterns’ grounded mystery and extraordinary stakes, even though its political focus and nonlinear structure set it apart. For more in that tradition, read The Boys Season 3 Review and 12 Shows to Watch If You Love Stranger Things. Where to watch: HBO catalogue availability depends on territory; UK viewers can check NOW’s HBO selection.
1. True Detective (2014– )
True Detective is the best show like Lanterns because it knows that a case becomes compelling when the people investigating it cannot leave it at work. The anthology series gives each season a new crime, setting and cast. Its first season follows Louisiana detectives Rust Cohle (Matthew McConaughey) and Marty Hart (Woody Harrelson), who revisit a murder investigation over many years. Later seasons and Night Country tell their own stories, so you can start with the pairing that interests you.
Season one makes the landscape part of the mystery. Louisiana’s empty roads, humid air and decaying buildings create a setting that feels spiritually charged, even when the police work remains grounded in evidence. McConaughey and Harrelson make Rust and Marty funny, frustrating and damaged in different ways. Their partnership is not an easy friendship; it is a long negotiation between people who need each other and do not always like what they see.
True Detective takes No. 1 because its atmosphere, performances and investigation work in balance. It is an ideal follow-up if Lanterns’ mystery and character conflict mattered most to you. Begin with season one for an engrossing case and a memorable duo; continue with the later seasons when you want a fresh setting and fresh detectives. 🎧 Before we reveal our No. 1 pick, discover original romantic audio dramas from That Love Podcast. Listen here.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your book, entertainment brand, streaming service, product, or business in front of readers who love movies, television, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers sponsorship and advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter. Learn more.
Choosing your next watch after Lanterns
Choosing your next series is easier if you first decide which part of Lanterns you want more of. If the attraction is the detective partnership, start with True Detective or The X-Files. If the superhero mythology is the draw, Watchmen gives you an ambitious case with a larger civic history attached. If the cosmic scale matters most, The Expanse provides the broadest world on this list.
Your appetite for answers should also shape the pick. Silo and Counterpart are built around secrets that take time to unfold, while Dark Matter makes its central objective clear early and keeps the family stakes visible. The Leftovers is the boldest choice if you are happy for a story to leave some questions unresolved. That difference is not a measure of quality; it is a question of what kind of viewing experience you want tonight.
Consider the pace before you press play. A long series such as The X-Files gives you standalone cases and room to dip in, while Watchmen is a shorter, more concentrated experience. The Expanse asks for a longer commitment but pays it back with a complete-feeling universe. True Detective’s anthology structure lets you sample one season and stop there if that is the story you needed.
The strongest shows on this list share one habit: they keep the human consequences in view. A clue matters because of whom it implicates, a power matters because of who can use it, and a cosmic event matters because people still have to live with the result. That is the quality that connects such different picks as Legion, Foundation, Jessica Jones and Lanterns.
Conclusion
The best Lanterns follow-ups are united by curiosity. True Detective and The X-Files make the investigation central; Watchmen and Legion use superhero stories to question power and identity; The Expanse and Foundation let a case stretch into a political universe. Counterpart, Dark Matter, Silo and The Leftovers each take a different route into uncertainty, asking what people do when their most familiar explanations stop working.
Start with Watchmen for a dark superhero mystery, The Expanse for expansive space opera, or True Detective for grounded character-driven crime. My No. 1 is True Detective because the story never lets the puzzle eclipse the people carrying it. That balance is exactly what makes Lanterns more than a Green Lantern show.
Which show would you rank first, and what would you add? Share your list with us. If you enjoyed the recommendations, support independent coverage with a donation, then listen to That Love Podcast for original audio dramas and stories.
💡 YOU MAY ALSO LOVE
Work With That Love Podcast
If you're a brand, author, publisher, entertainment company or business looking to connect with an audience that loves movies, television, romance, books and pop culture, we'd love to hear from you. Discover advertising and sponsorship opportunities here.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best shows like Lanterns?
Watchmen is the closest match for a superhero mystery with political and cosmic ideas. True Detective is best if you want the detective partnership and atmosphere, while The X-Files brings classic paranormal casework. For science fiction at a larger scale, try The Expanse; for a more personal multiverse thriller, choose Dark Matter.
What should I watch after HBO’s Lanterns?
If you want another HBO-style mystery, start with Watchmen or True Detective. The X-Files is a great choice for weekly investigations involving unexplained events. If Lanterns’ cosmic mythology is what you loved, The Expanse and Foundation both offer expansive science-fiction worlds, though their stories are more political than procedural.
Is Watchmen similar to Lanterns?
Watchmen shares a grounded investigation, superhero history and questions about power with Lanterns. It is not a direct continuation and has a more politically focused story, but both shows use a mystery to open into a larger world. It is a strong next watch for viewers who want superhero drama with more texture than action alone.
Which sci-fi detective show is the best?
The X-Files is the most classic sci-fi detective procedural, with Mulder and Scully investigating strange cases. Counterpart is a good pick for espionage and parallel worlds, while The Expanse begins with a missing-person investigation and expands into space politics. Choose based on whether you want episodic cases or one long mystery.
What is the best space mystery show?
The Expanse is the strongest all-round space mystery, balancing a missing-person case with realistic political science fiction. Foundation is better for viewers who want a vast, multi-generation empire story. Silo offers a different kind of contained science-fiction puzzle for anyone who prefers one closed community and a determined investigator.
Is True Detective a supernatural series?
True Detective is a crime anthology, not a supernatural show. Its first season uses eerie imagery and philosophical dialogue, but the central work is grounded investigation. The supernatural feeling comes from atmosphere and character perspective rather than a confirmed paranormal explanation, which makes it especially effective for fans of dark mysteries.
Is The X-Files worth starting now?
Yes. Its standalone episodes are easy to sample, and the Mulder-Scully partnership remains one of television’s most memorable. The conspiracy plot is uneven across the full run, so new viewers can start with acclaimed monster-of-the-week episodes before deciding whether to follow the larger mythology.
Which superhero series has the darkest mystery?
Watchmen is the strongest choice for a mystery connected to superhero culture, history and political power. Legion is more psychological and surreal, while Daredevil and Jessica Jones take a street-level approach. If you want a cynical satire rather than a detective story, The Boys is another option.
Where can I stream shows like Lanterns in the UK?
UK streaming catalogues change frequently. Apple TV carries originals such as Silo, Foundation and Dark Matter; other shows may move between NOW, Prime Video and digital rental services. Check the current catalogue for each title before subscribing, because a service’s US listing may differ from its UK availability.
What should I watch after The Expanse?
Try Foundation for another space-opera scale, or True Detective if you want to return to grounded investigators. Watchmen has some of the same interest in power and systems, while Dark Matter offers a faster, more intimate science-fiction mystery. Each gives you a different way back into the genre.
External resource
For current regional catalogues, begin with NOW’s HBO shows and verify availability on the streaming service itself.
More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows
Use these resources to keep exploring new releases, underrated series and familiar favourites:
ScreenRant – Entertainment news, reviews and features.
CBR – Comic, film and television coverage.
Collider – Interviews, reviews, trailers and entertainment news.
IMDb – Cast, episode and production information.
Rotten Tomatoes – Critic and audience review listings.
MovieWeb – Film and TV news, trailers and reviews.
Slash Film – Film and television analysis.
ComicBook.com – News about comics and adaptations.
Newsletter
Enjoyed what you read? Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest blogs, entertainment recommendations, updates and exclusive giveaways. Share this article with someone who loves movies, television, books or pop culture. Let’s spread the love together!
.jpg)
.jpg)
