6 Horror Shows to Watch If You Loved Carrie on Prime Video
Six Horror Shows to Watch If You Loved Carrie
Finding a follow-up to Carrie can be tricky: the story is about more than a frightening power waking up. Stephen King’s premise brings together adolescence, isolation, public humiliation and the terrifying thought that the person everyone has pushed aside might finally push back. If Mike Flanagan’s new Prime Video adaptation has put you in the mood for more horror with a human pulse, these six series offer different routes into that same uneasy territory.
The connection is not that every title features a telekinetic teenager or recreates Carrie’s prom-night catastrophe. That would make for a very short and very repetitive list. Instead, these picks share the ingredients that make the story linger: a vulnerable person caught inside a cruel system, supernatural forces that may or may not be understood, families that can offer shelter and harm at the same time, and communities that look respectable until pressure reveals what they are willing to excuse.
That distinction matters because Carrie is a coming-of-age story wrapped in horror. The school corridors, family home and town are not just backdrops; they are the places where shame and fear gather. The strongest horror shows like Carrie understand that the monster can be a literal demon, an institution, a crowd, a parent, or a power the protagonist cannot yet control. A good recommendation should give you a new kind of scare while keeping that emotional tension intact.
This is a ranked list rather than six interchangeable suggestions. Gen V comes first because it most directly turns young people’s extraordinary abilities into a story about exploitation, status and survival. The Devil’s Hour is the strongest choice if you want a serious supernatural mystery with a troubled mother at its centre. Them is more severe and historically grounded, while The Rig brings its dread to an isolated workplace. The Bondsman and The Boys offer darker, bloodier variations on supernatural and superpowered horror.
All six titles have appeared on Prime Video pages, but streaming libraries and subscription terms change by country. A Prime Video page can sometimes point to a channel, rental or purchase option instead of a title included with membership, so check the listing where you live before settling in. The shows also vary sharply in violence and intensity; the short notes below flag the kind of viewing experience each one offers.
Carrie’s 2026 television adaptation arrived on Prime Video on October 7, making this a particularly good moment to look beyond the obvious comparisons. The official announcement describes it as the first television adaptation of King’s novel and frames it as a coming-of-age reinvention. We’re keeping this guide spoiler-light: the aim is to tell you what each show is about, who it may suit, and why it earns its specific spot, without taking away its reveals.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
If you want to browse Prime Video directly, explore Amazon Prime. Catalogues vary by region, so check the title page and membership details first.
Support That Love Podcast
Enjoying the recommendations? Your support helps That Love Podcast keep independent entertainment coverage and original audio storytelling coming.
6. The Boys
The Boys begins with a terrible collision between ordinary life and celebrity superhero culture. Hughie Campbell is a young electronics-store worker whose girlfriend is killed during a reckless act by A-Train, one of the world’s most famous supes. When the corporation managing the heroes, Vought International, treats the tragedy as a public-relations problem, Hughie is approached by Billy Butcher, a hard-edged man with his own history of loss. Butcher wants to expose and punish the supes; Hughie is pulled into a covert group that includes Mother’s Milk, Frenchie and Kimiko. At the same time, Annie January, newly recruited into the elite Seven as Starlight, discovers that the heroic image sold to the public hides abuse, ego and corporate control.
The show is a sprawling, violent satire, not a coming-of-age horror drama. Its connection to Carrie lies in the contrast between public myth and private cruelty: the people presented as untouchable icons can behave like bullies, while ordinary people are expected to smile, keep quiet and accept the damage. Annie’s attempt to preserve her values inside a rotten institution gives the series one of its clearest moral threads, and Hughie’s uneasy partnership with Butcher keeps the revenge plot personal rather than abstract.
The scale is much larger than Carrie’s small-town tragedy, and the comedy can be deliberately gross. That makes The Boys a less intimate fit than the shows above it. Its strengths are sharp character conflicts, a consistent interest in celebrity worship and a willingness to ask who benefits when power is packaged as entertainment. It earns sixth place because it offers a bracing angle on abuse and spectacle, but its superhero conspiracy plot and anarchic humour sometimes move away from the vulnerable, inward perspective that makes Carrie so affecting.
Why it ranks here: it is the boldest satire on this list, but the least direct emotional match for Carrie. Viewers who want cynical superhero horror, graphic violence and a story about fame weaponised by corporations may find it a strong next watch. It is a poor choice if you want quiet supernatural dread or a gentler teen drama.
Where to watch: The Boys on Prime Video. The official page currently lists five seasons; check your local offer and the content advisory.
🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge?
Discover original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories from That Love Podcast.
5. The Bondsman
Kevin Bacon plays Hub Halloran, a bounty hunter who is murdered and then brought back by the Devil with a grim assignment: track down demons that have escaped from Hell and send them back. The job gives Hub a second shot at walking around the world, but it does not reset the damage he has done to the people closest to him. His estranged family is drawn into the supernatural mess, helping him in some moments and making clear in others that resurrection is not the same thing as forgiveness. Hub must hunt dangerous beings while confronting the choices that left his soul condemned.
The series mixes horror, action, comedy and family drama, so it is a looser, more playful watch than Carrie. Its supernatural setup is clean and instantly legible: Hub has a dangerous task, a narrow chance to do better and a family that remembers the version of him who failed them. Bacon gives the character a worn-down charm that helps the show balance demon-of-the-week danger with the more grounded question of whether someone can change after they have already caused real harm.
That family tension is what makes The Bondsman useful for a Carrie watchlist. Carrie’s mother is a source of control and fear; Hub’s relatives bring a different, messier possibility, because their bonds are damaged but not entirely beyond repair. The comparison stops there: Hub is an adult antihero, and the series is far more interested in supernatural action than adolescence or schoolyard cruelty. The brisk, eight-episode first season is also easier to sample than a long-running horror universe.
Why it ranks at No. 5: its family wounds and supernatural premise make a memorable pairing with Carrie, but the episodic demon-hunting structure gives it less psychological depth than The Rig, Them and the top two picks. Choose it when you want horror with a crooked grin and a central character who has to earn every scrap of redemption.
Where to watch: The Bondsman on Prime Video. Check the local Prime Video page for subscription availability and its current content rating.
You May Also Like
If you want to stay in the mood after Carrie, these related guides move between supernatural horror, suspense and teen-focused stories.
For more options, explore Amazon Prime Student. Eligibility and terms depend on location.
4. The Rig
The Rig opens on the Kinloch Bravo, a Scottish offshore oil platform cut off from the mainland by a strange fog. The crew expects to finish its work and return home, but the loss of communications and the sudden appearance of an unknown environmental threat disrupt that plan. Rig boss Magnus leads a group that includes scientist Rose, medic Cat, and crew members such as Fulmer and Baz. When unsettling incidents begin and the isolation deepens, the crew has to decide what the threat is, whether they can trust one another, and how to get off the platform alive.
The setting does a great deal of the frightening work. A steel platform at sea already has limited exits, harsh weather and a chain of jobs that depend on people following procedure. The mysterious fog turns those everyday constraints into pressure points. The show uses the crew’s different roles and priorities to generate conflict: scientific caution, management responsibility and the instinct to escape do not always point in the same direction. It is a workplace thriller that slowly allows ecological and supernatural unease to seep into the machinery.
The Rig is less about teenage shame than about adults trying to keep their footing when the rules of their world stop making sense. Still, it fits Carrie through the way fear isolates people and makes them look for someone to blame. As the crew fractures, the series asks whether a community can cooperate under pressure or whether suspicion will do the damage before the threat does. The offshore visuals give the story a distinct, cold atmosphere, and the ensemble format means no single character has complete control.
Why it ranks fourth: the claustrophobic setting and group paranoia are strong enough to make this a proper horror-series recommendation, and the premise has a neat slow-burn pull. It stays below Them and The Devil’s Hour because its large ensemble and environmental mystery keep the emotional focus more dispersed than Carrie’s story. It is a good pick for viewers who like isolated-location horror and tense group dynamics.
Where to watch: The Rig on Prime Video. Prime Video lists two seasons on the page checked; availability can vary by country.
This general offer page is not a title-specific deal.
3. Them
Them is an anthology series about terror in America, with its first season, Covenant, set in 1950s Los Angeles. Henry and Lucky Emory move with their daughters from North Carolina into a white neighbourhood during the Great Migration, hoping to build a safer future. The family’s new home is surrounded by hostile neighbours, and the racism they encounter is joined by disturbing forces that seem to come from beyond the ordinary world. Lucky and Henry try to protect their children and hold their family together while the house and the community become increasingly threatening.
The series does not treat supernatural horror as a substitute for historical reality. The Emory family faces deliberate intimidation, exclusion and violence, while the show adds an uncanny layer that makes the home itself feel contaminated. Deborah Ayorinde and Ashley Thomas anchor the story as Lucky and Henry, parents trying to keep their children safe while their own fear and exhaustion mount. That combination makes the horror heavy: the characters cannot simply leave the danger behind because it follows them into the neighbourhood and into the place that should offer refuge.
The direct link to Carrie is the way cruelty becomes a collective act. Carrie is isolated by classmates and controlled at home; Them looks at a family pushed by neighbours and by forces that prey on vulnerability. Both stories make a viewer feel how little protection a community’s polite surface can provide. Them is much more explicit and harrowing about race and racial violence, so it deserves a content note and a viewer’s full attention. It is not a casual background binge.
Why it ranks third: of the six, Them is among the most forceful at showing how public hatred and private terror feed each other. It sits below the top two because its period setting and concentrated, punishing intensity make it a more difficult recommendation for someone seeking Carrie’s blend of teen story and supernatural mystery. For viewers who want socially grounded horror, the first season is one of the most uncompromising choices here.
Where to watch: Them on Prime Video. The official listing describes it as a completed anthology series and rates it TV-MA in the checked market.
Affiliate note: explore more on Amazon. This general offer page is not a title-specific deal.
🎧 Taking a break from the screen?
Listen to original romance, comedy and drama stories from That Love Podcast.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your book, entertainment brand, streaming service, product or business in front of readers who love movies, television, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers sponsorship and advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
Learn more: advertise with That Love Podcast
2. The Devil’s Hour
Lucy Chambers is a social worker who wakes every night at exactly 3:33 a.m., caught in the hour the series gives its name. Her young son Isaac seems detached from the world around him, and Lucy’s home life is full of unsettling details she cannot explain. At work, she is drawn toward a string of brutal murders and the dangerous criminal Gideon, whose case connects to detective Ravi Dhillon. As Lucy tries to understand why her nights are so disturbing and what Gideon knows, the line between a psychological mystery and a supernatural one becomes increasingly hard to see.
Jessica Raine gives Lucy a wary, exhausted focus that suits a character who is asked to trust her instincts while other people doubt what she sees. Peter Capaldi’s Gideon brings a different kind of menace: he is calm enough to make every conversation feel like a trap. The show takes time to set up its mystery, but its details accumulate with purpose. The unsettling domestic scenes involving Isaac give the story its emotional weight; Lucy is not investigating an abstract puzzle, she is trying to make sense of the people she loves and the dangers she fears.
The connection to Carrie is not powers or school life. It is the intimate terror of not being believed, especially when the protagonist is already isolated by circumstances she cannot easily explain. Both stories hold open a question about whether an unusual ability or perception can be a source of danger and whether the people around the central character will help or control them. The Devil’s Hour is a psychological thriller with supernatural horror elements, so it is the best option here if you value an intricate mystery over splatter.
Why it ranks second: its central performances, eerie family story and carefully layered mystery make it the most complete dramatic recommendation after Gen V. It misses first place because it is built around a slower, adult-led crime puzzle rather than the specific teen power-and-bullying combination that defines the Carrie comparison. If you want dread that grows from small details and a mystery that rewards attention, this may be your personal No. 1.
Where to watch: The Devil’s Hour on Prime Video. The page checked lists two seasons; confirm local subscription access before watching.
🎧 Before we reveal our No. 1 pick…
You can also discover original romantic audio dramas and comedies from That Love Podcast.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
1. Gen V
Marie Moreau arrives at Godolkin University carrying grief, ambition and a dangerous ability she has not fully mastered. The elite college trains young supes who hope to rise in Vought International’s superhero world, and its students compete for status, rankings and a possible place among the Seven. Marie’s blood-based power makes her both a potential star and an object of suspicion. As she meets fellow students including Emma Meyer, Andre Anderson and Jordan Li, the polished campus image gives way to secrets about the institution and the people who control it. They have to decide what kind of heroes they want to become while discovering how little the school’s promises can be trusted.
Gen V is a spin-off from The Boys, but it has its own coming-of-age engine. The students are trying to define themselves while adults, corporations and media narratives keep telling them what they should be. The show has the franchise’s graphic violence and cynical humour, yet its most engaging scenes are about friendship, insecurity and the exhausting work of being young in a world where every mistake can become public. Jaz Sinclair’s Marie gives the story a strong emotional centre, and the ensemble’s differing powers make the college feel like a pressure cooker rather than a generic superhero academy.
That is why Gen V is the most direct companion to Carrie. Both stories place a young woman with a frightening, misunderstood power inside a hostile social environment. The details are very different: Marie’s world is an adult-controlled superhero industry, not a small-town high school, and the tone is far more satirical and graphic. But both titles understand how quickly a gift can become a spectacle when other people see a person as useful, frightening or easy to exploit. Gen V lets its characters push against that gaze instead of simply accepting the roles assigned to them.
Why it ranks first: it combines the closest thematic match with a lively ensemble, a clear ongoing conflict and a story about young people being shaped by systems that profit from their abilities. The Devil’s Hour is more restrained and Them is more historically grounded, but neither speaks as directly to Carrie’s mix of adolescent identity, social cruelty and emerging power. The series can be extremely graphic, so it is not the gentlest pick; its #1 spot is about relevance and energy, not family-friendly viewing.
Where to watch: Gen V on Prime Video. The official page lists two seasons and an 18+ advisory in the checked market.
Work With That Love Podcast
If you're a brand, author, publisher, entertainment company or business looking to connect with an audience that loves movies, television, romance, books and pop culture, we'd love to hear from you.
Discover advertising and sponsorship opportunities: Advertise With That Love Podcast
You May Also Like
For more teen, science-fiction and autumn viewing ideas, browse these related guides.
Final Thoughts: Which Show Should You Watch After Carrie?
The best follow-up depends on which part of Carrie stays with you. If it is the sight of a young person trying to understand a frightening gift, Gen V is the clearest match. If it is the sense that reality is slipping sideways around an ordinary family, The Devil’s Hour is the pick. Them connects horror to a community’s real-world cruelty, The Rig traps you with a suspicious crew in a dangerous place, and The Bondsman turns the supernatural into a rough-edged second-chance story. The Boys is the most satirical and the most interested in what happens when power becomes a celebrity brand.
These shows do not repeat Carrie’s plot, and they should not. They share its interest in the social conditions that make fear personal: families, schools, workplaces, neighbourhoods and institutions that decide who gets protection and who becomes a target. Some lean toward supernatural mystery, some toward explicit horror, and others toward violent genre satire. Checking the content advisories is sensible, especially for Them, Gen V and The Boys.
If you have not watched the 2026 Carrie adaptation yet, Prime Video’s official announcement says the eight episodes released together on October 7. Read the verified series details in the official Carrie announcement from Amazon. Tell us which show you would put first, and whether another horror series deserves a place on this list.
Tell us which show you would put first, and whether another horror series deserves a place on this list.
Support That Love Podcast
If you enjoyed this article and want to support more independent entertainment coverage and original audio storytelling:
Looking for something new to listen to?
You May Also Like
Keep exploring scary stories, thrillers and genre television with these related reads.
Before you stream, explore Amazon Prime and check your regional catalogue.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I watch after Carrie?
Start with Gen V if you want a story about young people with extraordinary powers facing an exploitative institution. The Devil’s Hour is a better fit for a slow supernatural mystery, while Them is the most intense choice for viewers interested in horror tied to social cruelty. The Rig gives you an isolated setting and a tense ensemble. All of these offer a different kind of follow-up rather than repeating Carrie’s plot.
What show is most similar to Carrie?
Gen V is the closest thematic match in this ranking because it centres on young people whose unusual abilities make them valuable, feared and vulnerable to institutional control. Its college setting and superhero satire are very different from Carrie’s high-school horror, and it is much more graphic. If you mean psychological unease and a troubled family instead, The Devil’s Hour may feel closer in tone.
Is Gen V a horror show?
Gen V is primarily a superhero drama and dark satire, but it uses body horror, disturbing violence and psychological horror elements. It follows students at Godolkin University as they compete for a place in Vought’s superhero hierarchy and uncover secrets about the school. Its graphic content is much stronger than a typical teen drama, so check the Prime Video advisory before watching.
What is The Devil’s Hour about?
The Devil’s Hour follows Lucy Chambers, who wakes at 3:33 every morning and struggles to understand troubling events in her home and at work. A series of murders and the criminal Gideon draw her into a mystery alongside detective Ravi Dhillon. The show gradually blurs psychological thriller and supernatural horror, using Lucy’s family life and her relationship with her son Isaac as the emotional centre.
Is Them too scary to watch after Carrie?
Them is a much harsher and more explicit series than many viewers expect from a supernatural drama. Its first season follows the Emory family as they move into a white Los Angeles neighbourhood in the 1950s and face racist hostility alongside malevolent forces. It deals with racial terror and violence, so it may be too distressing for viewers looking for a lighter Halloween binge.
How many seasons of The Rig are there?
The Prime Video listing checked for this guide shows two seasons of The Rig. The series begins with the Kinloch Bravo crew cut off from the Scottish mainland by a mysterious fog and facing a series of dangerous events. Streaming catalogues can change, so use the Prime Video page in your region to confirm which seasons are currently included with your membership.
What is The Bondsman about?
The Bondsman stars Kevin Bacon as Hub Halloran, a murdered bounty hunter brought back by the Devil to capture demons that escaped from Hell. His estranged family becomes part of the story as Hub confronts the harm his past choices caused. The show combines supernatural action, horror and dark comedy, making it a more playful recommendation than Carrie.
Are these shows included with Prime Video?
The Prime Video pages checked during research display these titles, but the exact offer can vary by country and over time. A listing may be available with Prime membership in one region and offered through a channel, rental or purchase in another. Check the playback options and the terms on your local Prime Video page before subscribing or making a purchase.
Which show on this list is the easiest binge?
The Bondsman has a compact first season of eight episodes and a straightforward demon-hunting premise, so it is the easiest to start and finish quickly. The Devil’s Hour also has a manageable two-season run, but its mystery asks for more attention. The Boys and Gen V have broader franchise connections, while Them and The Rig are better approached when you are in the mood for sustained tension.
Are any of these shows suitable for younger teens?
Several are intended for mature audiences. The official listings include strong advisories for violence or other adult content on titles such as Gen V, The Boys and Them. Carrie itself is also a horror story with disturbing themes. Check the rating and content advisory in your country and choose according to the viewer’s age and sensitivity; this list is aimed at adult horror fans.
More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows
For verified premise and availability details, start with each show’s official Prime Video page linked above. Amazon’s entertainment coverage also has useful release information and updates, while the streaming page for each title gives the most practical check on regional playback options. For further criticism and film context, readers can also consult established entertainment publications and databases such as Collider, IMDb and Rotten Tomatoes.
Read the official Prime Video guide to Carrie for the adaptation’s release information.
Enjoyed What You Read?
Subscribe to That Love Podcast's newsletter for the latest articles, entertainment recommendations, podcast updates and exclusive giveaways. And if you know someone who loves movies, television, books or pop culture, share the article with them too. Let’s spread the love together!
Looking for something new to listen to? Listen to That Love Podcast for original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories.
Want to help keep independent entertainment coverage coming? Support That Love Podcast.
Discover more with this Amazon offer.
.jpg)
.jpg)
