YAGA Review – A Sexy, Strange Baba Yaga Mystery for Halloween
YAGA Review: Is This Baba Yaga Mystery the Perfect Halloween Binge?
The biggest question surrounding YAGA is whether a television series can take Baba Yaga—one of folklore’s strangest, oldest and most contradictory figures—and turn her into something that feels genuinely modern rather than simply fashionable. Based on Kat Sandler’s stage play, this eight-part mystery thriller arrives with Carrie-Anne Moss, Noah Reid, Clark Backo and Hudson Williams, a foggy coastal town, a missing heir and enough witchcraft, seduction and suspicion to make its late-October release feel almost suspiciously well timed.
Based on the first two episodes made available to critics, YAGA is a confident, slippery opening rather than a conventional supernatural procedural. It begins with a missing-person investigation, but almost immediately starts asking who gets to tell stories about dangerous women, why folklore turns female anger into monstrosity, and whether the people investigating Henry Park’s disappearance are any more reliable than the suspects they question.
That sounds heavy, but the show is not solemn. Its best early quality is tonal uncertainty. Noah Reid’s private investigator Rapp can be funny, irritating and perceptive within the same exchange, while Clark Backo’s local detective Carson gives him exactly enough resistance to turn procedural dialogue into a kind of verbal fencing match. Carrie-Anne Moss, meanwhile, walks into the story as Katherine and makes every scene feel as though somebody forgot to tell the other characters they are already in danger.
The first two episodes are only around half an hour each, which helps enormously. Mystery television often mistakes length for atmosphere, stretching a simple question across fifty-five minutes because streaming viewers have somehow agreed to suffer for prestige. YAGA moves. It has enough time to establish Whittock, introduce several suspicious people and plant supernatural ideas, then leaves before the mood turns into homework.
Early critical reaction is encouraging but divided. Radio Times awarded the series four stars and praised its playful-dark balance, while ScreenRant’s early Rotten Tomatoes excerpt gave it 7/10 and liked the fast half-hour pacing. TV Guide was much harsher, arguing that the series adds witchcraft to a familiar small-town detective setup without distinguishing itself strongly enough in either mode. With only a handful of reviews available before launch, any claim that critics have reached a consensus would be premature.
That uncertainty actually suits the show. YAGA is selling mystery rather than answers, and the opening episodes work because they are difficult to categorise. It is part police story, part folk horror, part erotic thriller, part feminist revision and part small-town oddity. Some viewers will find that combination deliciously strange. Others may wonder when the actual investigation is going to stop flirting with everyone in the room.
So, is YAGA worth watching? Based on the opening two episodes, yes. This is an early review rather than a verdict on all eight episodes, but the atmosphere, performances and sharply modernised Baba Yaga framing give the series one of the strongest Halloween-season hooks of 2026.
Support That Love Podcast
Enjoying the reviews and recommendations? You can help support That Love Podcast and keep independent entertainment coverage and original storytelling going.
Want to Reach Entertainment Fans?
If you're a brand, author, publisher, streaming company, entertainment business or creator looking to reach an engaged audience, That Love Podcast offers advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
What Is YAGA About?
YAGA follows Rapp, a private investigator played by Noah Reid, who arrives in the coastal town of Whittock to investigate the disappearance of Henry Park, the young heir to a powerful fishery. The case immediately puts him at odds with Carson, a local detective played by Clark Backo, whose approach is more cautious, procedural and understandably suspicious of an outsider who treats boundaries as flexible suggestions.
Henry, played by Hudson Williams, sits at the centre of a widening circle of questions. His disappearance points towards secret relationships, family power, local resentments and a university world that becomes increasingly important once Rapp and Carson encounter Katherine, an anthropology professor played by Carrie-Anne Moss. Katherine is intelligent, sexual, difficult to read and clearly connected to more than one version of the truth.
The series also introduces Logan, another character played by Williams, which immediately creates a question the show is in no hurry to explain. That doubling adds a surreal edge to a mystery already flirting with folklore. Rather than reveal whether the connection is literal, symbolic or supernatural, the opening episodes let uncertainty become part of the atmosphere.
Behind the missing-person plot sits the mythology of Baba Yaga. Kat Sandler’s version is interested in the stories told about the witch figure across generations—ugly, old, dangerous, hungry, monstrous—and in what those descriptions reveal about cultural fear of female power. The series does not begin by asking whether Baba Yaga exists. It begins by asking who benefits from defining her as a monster.
A Missing-Person Mystery That Refuses to Stay Procedural
The first episode gives viewers enough procedural structure to feel secure. There is a missing man, an investigator from outside town, a local detective with jurisdiction and a group of people whose relationships to Henry need to be clarified. If YAGA stayed there, it could still be a perfectly watchable small-town mystery.
The interesting choice is how quickly the series destabilises that structure. Interviews become flirtations, folklore begins intruding on evidence, and characters seem aware of information that does not fit neatly inside a police timeline. The investigation becomes less about assembling clues in the correct order and more about deciding which version of events deserves belief.
That is where the stage-play origins remain visible in a good way. Dialogue carries enormous weight. Characters rarely speak only to provide information; they test one another, perform confidence, change subjects and use humour as a weapon. Radio Times noted that much of the play’s dialogue survives in the series, and the sharpness of those exchanges is one of the clearest reasons the adaptation feels authored rather than generic.
The half-hour format keeps the mystery from becoming self-important. Episodes end while the story still feels active, which is especially useful when the plot begins layering witchcraft and sexuality onto the detective material. TV Goodness described the series as an easy binge because the mystery and constant redirection keep pulling the viewer forward, and that quality is already visible in the opening chapters.
The risk is that misdirection can become a substitute for progression. If every character is mysterious, every clue ambiguous and every answer another question, a thriller eventually stops feeling deep and starts feeling evasive. The first two episodes have not crossed that line, but the remaining six will need to convert atmosphere into meaningful revelation.
Carrie-Anne Moss, Noah Reid and Clark Backo Give the Mystery Its Shape
Carrie-Anne Moss is the obvious casting coup. Katherine needs to be seductive without becoming a cliché, intimidating without behaving like a cartoon villain and intellectually confident enough that every conversation feels slightly tilted in her favour. Moss does all of that with remarkable economy.
Her strongest quality is unpredictability. Katherine can appear amused, bored or dangerous without changing volume, and Moss understands that mystery is more effective when a performer seems to know exactly what everyone else is missing. Radio Times called her mesmerising and unpredictable, which is accurate even in the limited material available so far.
Noah Reid brings a very different energy as Rapp. Viewers who know him primarily from Schitt’s Creek may be surprised by how comfortably he plays somebody messier and more morally flexible. Rapp enjoys pushing people, and Reid lets that curiosity slide between charm and intrusion without making the character impossible to watch.
Clark Backo’s Carson may be even more important because she prevents Rapp from dominating the tone. Carson has a reason to distrust his methods and does not exist merely to be impressed by his instincts. Their early chemistry is one of the show’s clearest strengths because disagreement, professional irritation and flirtatious energy all occupy the same space.
Hudson Williams has the most structurally unusual role because he plays Henry and Logan. Early critics have been careful not to spoil how that doubling develops, and the opening episodes wisely refuse to explain it quickly. Williams uses small shifts in behaviour and presence to make the two roles feel connected but not interchangeable.
The wider cast includes Sheila McCarthy, Megan Follows, Ezra Franky, Patrick Gilmore, Katharine Isabelle, Hiro Kanagawa, Emilija Baranac, Georgia Acken, Anisa Harris and Sam Krochmal. The challenge for a thirty-minute mystery is giving that many people enough personality to matter, and the first episodes are more successful with some than others.
Need Something to Listen to After Watching?
That Love Podcast creates original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories you can listen to anytime.
What Works Best in YAGA
The first major strength is tone. YAGA is dark without becoming humourless, sexy without becoming campy and supernatural without immediately abandoning the detective story. That balance is difficult because each genre is constantly threatening to overpower the others.
The second strength is the setting. British Columbia gives the series fog, water, trees, grey skies and the kind of coastal isolation that makes a town feel cut off even when roads technically still exist. Directors David Frazee and Rachael Talalay use the landscape as part of the mystery rather than simply photographing beautiful scenery.
The third strength is the feminist reinterpretation of Baba Yaga. The show does not pretend it invented the idea that folklore reflects social fear, but it gives that idea a sharp dramatic frame. Hearing Baba Yaga comment on the stories told about her creates a tension between myth and testimony: who gets to decide what an old woman with power means?
The dialogue is another pleasure. Rapp and Carson’s exchanges move quickly enough to create humour while still communicating professional disagreement. Katherine’s conversations are slower and more controlled, which gives Moss room to turn pauses into threats.
Finally, the short episodes are a genuine structural advantage. Eight half-hours mean the season can theoretically tell a complete supernatural mystery in roughly four hours. In an era when too many streaming thrillers stretch six hours of story into eight, that discipline is refreshing.
What Doesn’t Quite Work Yet
The biggest concern is familiarity underneath the folklore. Strip away Baba Yaga and the setup is still an outsider investigator arriving in a strange town where a young person has disappeared and everyone appears to be hiding something. Twin Peaks, Broadchurch, The Outsider and dozens of other mysteries have walked some version of that road.
TV Guide’s negative early review focuses on exactly that problem, arguing that YAGA does not yet distinguish itself enough as either witch story or detective drama. I think the first two episodes are more distinctive than that assessment suggests, but the criticism is useful. Atmosphere cannot permanently cover familiar structure.
The supporting characters are another open question. Several suspects are introduced quickly, and not all of them have enough screen time to become emotionally specific. TV Goodness similarly noted that some revelations may lack impact if viewers have not spent enough time with the people involved.
The sexual energy will also divide viewers. YAGA deliberately uses desire as part of its power dynamics, and the show is not shy about making characters uncomfortable, curious or attracted at inconvenient moments. Some audiences will find that sensuality essential to the folklore revision; others may feel it distracts from the missing-person case.
Most importantly, this is still an early review. Critics have not been given all eight episodes universally, and only four Rotten Tomatoes reviews were visible at the time of writing. The opening is promising, but mysteries live or die on payoff. A brilliant setup cannot guarantee a brilliant answer.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your movie, series, book, entertainment brand, product or business in front of readers who love television, movies, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers advertising and sponsorship opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter.
Rapp, Carson, Katherine and the Relationships Driving YAGA
Rapp is the disruptive force. He arrives believing that unconventional methods make him more perceptive, but the show does not automatically agree with him. His charm works because it is paired with the possibility that he is crossing lines other people have good reason to defend.
Carson provides resistance without becoming a humourless rulebook. Her frustration with Rapp feels professional before it feels personal, and Backo makes her competence visible through observation rather than speeches. The potential chemistry between them is interesting precisely because it grows out of disagreement.
Katherine exists on a different level of power. She is not simply another suspect; she appears to understand how attraction can alter an interrogation before the investigators do. Moss plays her as someone who knows the cultural stories attached to women like her and may be perfectly willing to weaponise those expectations.
Henry’s absence shapes every relationship even when he is not onscreen. The people around him describe versions of the same man that do not fully match, which is classic mystery material but also thematically useful in a story about myth. A missing person, like a folkloric figure, can become whatever other people need him to be.
Visuals, Music and Halloween Atmosphere
YAGA may be one of the best-timed releases of the autumn simply because it looks like October. The coastal British Columbia locations are damp, wooded and permanently capable of hiding something unpleasant just beyond the frame. There is enough natural beauty to make Whittock appealing and enough isolation to make staying there feel questionable.
The cinematography favours muted light, interiors with pockets of shadow and landscapes that seem slightly too still. Frazee and Talalay do not overdecorate the supernatural material. That restraint matters because Baba Yaga imagery can become kitsch very quickly if every room contains antlers, candles and suspiciously photogenic ravens.
The trailer’s use of Alanis Morissette’s cover of Season of the Witch captures the intended mood almost too perfectly: familiar, seductive and slightly wrong. Music in the opening episodes supports that atmosphere rather than overwhelming it, giving scenes a sense that something old is moving underneath modern behaviour.
The thirty-minute runtime also changes the rhythm of dread. There is less time for long slow-burn sequences, so the show relies on quick tonal shifts and strong scene endings. That gives YAGA a pulpy quality that keeps the folklore accessible even when the ideas become darker.
What YAGA Is Really About
The series is clearly interested in who gets labelled dangerous. Baba Yaga has been depicted across folklore as witch, monster, helper, cannibal, guardian and threat. YAGA uses that instability to ask why powerful women are so often described through disgust, age, sexuality and fear.
Female anger is central to that revision. The opening commentary from Baba Yaga immediately challenges the stories told about her, and TV Goodness highlighted a later line from Katherine about women being angry about everything. The point is not simply that women are angry; it is that culture often becomes frightened when that anger stops being apologetic.
Power and seduction are intertwined too. Characters use attractiveness, authority, knowledge and social status in different ways, making desire part of the investigation rather than a separate romantic subplot. That creates discomfort because attraction can make people misread danger or imagine control where none exists.
The missing-person story also explores narrative ownership. Henry cannot explain himself, so everyone else constructs him. That mirrors the series’ treatment of Baba Yaga: once someone becomes a story, the people telling it gain enormous power over what the audience believes.
Explore More Original Stories
If you love character-driven mystery, romance, comedy and drama, you can find original audio stories from That Love Podcast here.
Is YAGA Worth Watching?
Based on the first two episodes, yes. Viewers who like Twin Peaks, The X-Files, folk horror, small-town mysteries and supernatural dramas with adult sexuality should find plenty to enjoy. The opening is strange enough to create its own identity even though the missing-person framework is familiar.
The short episodes make YAGA particularly easy to try. Two episodes amount to roughly an hour, so the premiere asks for less time than a single episode of many prestige dramas. If the tone does not work for you by then, the series is unlikely to become a completely different show.
Viewers looking for a straightforward police procedural may be less satisfied. The series enjoys ambiguity, flirtation and folklore, and it is clearly more interested in unsettling certainty than in rapidly proving who did what. That is a strength if you enjoy mystery as atmosphere and a frustration if you mainly want clues and solutions.
I would watch it during Halloween week rather than save it. The release timing, foggy setting, witch mythology and compact runtime are almost engineered for late-October viewing. Just remember that this early review cannot judge whether the final mystery pays off across all eight episodes.
Where to Watch YAGA
YAGA premieres with two episodes on Crave in Canada and AMC+ in the United States on Friday, 23 October 2026. New episodes then arrive weekly on Fridays, with a two-episode finale scheduled for 27 November.
In the UK and Ireland, YAGA premieres exclusively on Sky and NOW on 31 October 2026. Sky has confirmed all eight half-hour episodes as part of the series.
Work With That Love Podcast
If you're a brand, author, publisher, studio, entertainment business or creator looking to reach people who love movies, television, books and pop culture, we'd love to hear from you.
Final Verdict
YAGA opens with enough confidence to make its familiar ingredients feel freshly arranged. A missing heir, a coastal town full of secrets and two investigators with incompatible methods could belong to dozens of mysteries. Add Baba Yaga, feminist anger, erotic power games and Carrie-Anne Moss behaving as though every conversation is already three moves behind her, and the mixture becomes far stranger.
The performances are the strongest reason to continue. Noah Reid and Clark Backo create an immediately watchable investigative pairing, while Moss gives Katherine exactly the level of control and uncertainty the story needs. Hudson Williams’ double role adds another layer of unease without explaining itself too early.
The weaknesses are mostly questions rather than failures. Will the folklore become central rather than decorative? Will the supporting suspects become people rather than pieces? Will the final reveal justify the constant misdirection? Two episodes cannot answer those questions, and pretending otherwise would be unfair.
But as an opening statement, YAGA works. It is funny in uncomfortable places, stylish without becoming glossy, and willing to make female power feel threatening without automatically agreeing that threat equals evil. For a Halloween mystery, that is a very promising spell to cast.
⭐ Early Review Score: 8/10
8/10 — A sharp, seductive and atmospheric opening with excellent performances and real folkloric bite, though the full season still has to prove its mystery can deliver a satisfying payoff.
You May Also Love
Final Thoughts
The thing that stays with me from YAGA’s opening is not a plot twist but a mood: everybody seems to know that the story they are telling is incomplete. Rapp thinks he is investigating a disappearance. Carson thinks she is managing an outsider. Katherine appears to understand a much older game, and Baba Yaga herself keeps reminding us that stories about women with power are rarely neutral.
That gives the series more thematic weight than a normal Halloween mystery, but it never completely abandons entertainment. Reid and Backo are funny together, Moss is magnetic and the episodes move too quickly to become self-serious. The balance could still collapse later, but right now it is one of the show’s most appealing qualities.
If you want a complete mystery immediately, waiting until the November finale may be sensible. If you enjoy weekly speculation and want something atmospheric for Halloween, the two-episode premiere is exactly the right entry point. YAGA already gives viewers enough oddness to start arguing about what is really happening.
Did YAGA’s opening cast a spell on you, or does the supernatural material get in the way of the detective story? Let me know what you thought and what score you would give the premiere.
Frequently Asked Questions About YAGA
What is YAGA about?
YAGA follows private investigator Rapp and local detective Carson as they investigate the disappearance of Henry Park in the coastal town of Whittock. The case pulls them towards professor Katherine, secret relationships, ancient magic and a contemporary reimagining of Baba Yaga folklore.
When does YAGA premiere?
YAGA premieres with two episodes on 23 October 2026 on Crave in Canada and AMC+ in the United States. In the UK and Ireland, it premieres on Sky and NOW on 31 October 2026.
How many episodes are in YAGA?
The first season contains eight episodes, each running for roughly thirty minutes. After the two-episode premiere, new episodes arrive weekly, with a two-episode finale scheduled for 27 November in North America.
Who stars in YAGA?
The main cast includes Carrie-Anne Moss as Katherine, Noah Reid as Rapp, Clark Backo as Carson and Hudson Williams as Henry Park and Logan. The supporting cast includes Sheila McCarthy, Megan Follows, Ezra Franky, Patrick Gilmore, Katharine Isabelle and others.
Is YAGA based on a book?
No. YAGA is based on Kat Sandler’s stage play of the same name. Sandler adapted the material for television and serves as showrunner, writer and executive producer.
Is YAGA based on Baba Yaga folklore?
Yes. The series reimagines the Slavic folklore figure Baba Yaga through a contemporary mystery involving witchcraft, power, sexuality and the stories society tells about dangerous women.
Is YAGA scary?
The opening episodes are more eerie and unsettling than constantly frightening. The show combines supernatural mystery, adult themes and folk-horror atmosphere rather than relying entirely on jump scares.
Is YAGA suitable for families?
No. AMC+ lists the series as TV-MA, and the story includes adult sexuality, disturbing themes, murder, witchcraft and psychological material. It is aimed at mature viewers.
Is YAGA worth watching?
Based on the first two episodes, yes. The performances, half-hour pacing and modern Baba Yaga framing make it a strong Halloween-season mystery, although the final judgement depends on whether the remaining episodes deliver on the setup.
Will there be a YAGA Season 2?
There were no confirmed plans for a second season at the time this early review was prepared. The current series is an eight-episode adaptation, so any continuation would need to be announced by the broadcasters or producers.
More Places to Find Movie and TV Information
If you're on the hunt for your next favourite TV show or movie, there is no shortage of resources to help you discover something worth watching. These platforms are useful places to continue your search for new releases, reviews and entertainment news.
Enjoyed What You Read?
Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest reviews, recommendations, entertainment news, updates and exclusive giveaways. And if you know someone who loves movies, television, books or pop culture, share this article with them too. Let’s spread the love together!
.jpg)
.jpg)
