Back Where We Started by Becca Freeman Review

What is Back Where We Started about?

Becca Freeman’s Back Where We Started follows Katie, an actress whose career has taken her far from the Pennsylvania hometown where she grew up. At Christmas, she returns to Dutch Ridge and runs into Drew Callahan, her first love. Drew’s life has moved on too: he is involved in politics and has a new girlfriend. Their reunion pulls the past into the present, forcing both to consider whether the people they were still have anything useful to say about the people they have become.

The book is the second novel connected to Freeman’s The Christmas Orphans Club. The story moves between present-day events and flashbacks, tracing Katie and Drew from childhood into adulthood. That structure makes the title’s question more than a romantic tease. Returning to where a relationship began can reveal what remains, but it can also show why the couple separated and why a familiar place may no longer fit.

How the story is structured

The Hollywood-to-hometown contrast gives Katie an external change of scale. She has built a public career, while Dutch Ridge carries private memories and the version of herself that existed before success. The returning-home setup can make the town both comfort and challenge: people remember her, but they may remember an earlier Katie who no longer exists. That friction is especially useful in a second-chance romance because it prevents nostalgia from doing all the emotional work.

Drew’s present life gives the reunion a real complication. He is not waiting in an empty story for Katie to return; he has a girlfriend and a political life of his own. That detail raises the stakes and asks the book to treat the existing relationship seriously. The flashbacks can then show readers how the first love formed, while the present timeline tests whether those old feelings deserve a new beginning.

What sounds strongest

Second-chance stories are most affecting when they balance memory with accountability. A shared childhood can create tenderness, but it should not erase the choices that ended the relationship. Freeman’s setup has room for both: the reader can see Katie and Drew before adulthood complicated things, then compare that history with their current ambitions, obligations and romantic lives.

The seasonal setting can support the emotional tension without making the novel depend on holiday decoration alone. Christmas brings Katie back to a place full of familiar rituals, while the career and relationship conflicts keep the story moving beyond cozy nostalgia. The book may appeal to readers who like a festive backdrop with adult questions about timing, ambition and whether home is a place or a person.

What readers should know before starting

The book uses a dual timeline, so readers who prefer a strictly linear romance may need a little patience as childhood and present-day scenes alternate. That structure is doing important work: the flashbacks provide emotional context, while the present asks whether the connection still functions. Its success depends on how well the transitions build rather than repeat information.

The story also involves a love triangle in the broad sense: Drew has a current girlfriend when Katie returns. Readers should expect that the romance has ethical and emotional complications. The book’s strongest version will give that character dimension and avoid treating her as merely an obstacle to the central couple. Early reviews describe the characters and obstacles as grounded, but a full reading is needed to judge the balance.

Who should read it?

Pick up Back Where We Started if you enjoy second-chance romance, childhood friends who meet again as adults, holiday settings, small-town returns and stories that let past and present speak to each other. It may also suit readers interested in the tension between a public career and a private sense of belonging.

Readers who want a fast, low-conflict Christmas rom-com may find the setup more reflective and emotionally complicated than expected. The story’s appeal rests on the couple’s history and the question of whether love can survive changing ambitions. If that is your favourite part of a romance, the premise has a lot to work with.

Is Back Where We Started worth reading?

The setup offers a clear emotional hook: a successful actress returns home at Christmas and encounters the first love she left behind, now in a different relationship and a different life. The childhood-to-present structure gives the reader a way to measure what changed, while the hometown setting brings old identity into conflict with adult choice.

Because the US release date is October 13 and the book is just arriving in several markets, I cannot claim a personal reading or assign a fair score. Publisher details and early reviews make it a promising choice for readers of second-chance holiday romance, especially those who like characters with history and complications. Its decisive test is whether Katie and Drew’s present-day choices feel as compelling as the memories that connect them.

Publication and buying information

The novel is published by Penguin. Becca Freeman’s official site lists the US release on October 13, 2026; editions in other territories appeared earlier, including a UK listing in September. Check your local bookstore for format and date. See the official Penguin Random House listing or Becca Freeman’s website.

About the author

Becca Freeman is a novelist and co-host of the Bad on Paper podcast. Her first novel, The Christmas Orphans Club, introduced readers to her warm, contemporary approach to friendship and holiday storytelling. Back Where We Started is a connected second novel centered on Katie and Drew’s history. This article uses official publisher information and published early reviews without presenting a fabricated personal response.

You may also enjoy

For more love stories, see our romance book recommendations, second-chance romance novels, Christmas love stories, October romance releases, and holiday rom-com books.

Frequently asked questions

Who wrote Back Where We Started?

Becca Freeman wrote Back Where We Started. It was incorrectly attributed to Natasha Madison in the initial list.

What is Back Where We Started about?

Actress Katie returns to Dutch Ridge, Pennsylvania, for Christmas and reconnects with her childhood first love, Drew Callahan, whose life and romantic situation have changed.

Is Back Where We Started a sequel?

It is connected to Becca Freeman’s The Christmas Orphans Club and is her second novel. It focuses on a new central story.

When is Back Where We Started released?

The US edition is dated October 13, 2026. Some international editions were published earlier, so check local listings.

Is Back Where We Started a Christmas book?

Yes. Katie’s return to her hometown happens over Christmas, and the holiday setting shapes the reunion.

Is this a second-chance romance?

Yes. Katie and Drew share a romantic history and must decide what that past means in their adult lives.

Does the book use flashbacks?

Yes. The story moves between childhood memories and the present-day reunion.

Who is Drew Callahan?

Drew is Katie’s first love from Dutch Ridge. In the present timeline, he is involved in politics and has a girlfriend.

Do I need to read The Christmas Orphans Club first?

The books are connected, but Back Where We Started centers on Katie and Drew. Reading the first novel may provide extra series context.

Where can I buy Back Where We Started?

Penguin Random House provides the official title page and retailer availability. Regional publication dates and formats vary.

Support independent storytelling

If this review helped you choose a book, support That Love Podcast or listen to our original audio stories.