A Very Good Bad Idea by Emma Chase Review

What is A Very Good Bad Idea about?

A Very Good Bad Idea is Emma Chase’s enemies-to-lovers romantic comedy about rival real-estate developers Jade Buchanan and Damon Burke. The two inherit an unusually lucrative property and discover that the inheritance comes with a condition: they must live in the same house for four months, and neither can leave. The arrangement is already an inconvenience for two people whose work puts them in competition; the house’s odd hazards make it harder to keep their distance.

That forced-proximity device gives the novel a clear rom-com engine. Jade and Damon have practical reasons to fight over the property, personal reasons to distrust each other, and no easy exit from the same roof. The central question is whether their rivalry is only professional or whether the antagonism is masking attraction—and whether either of them can risk turning a business contest into something more vulnerable.

How the premise works

The inheritance condition creates a contained setting and a deadline. Four months is long enough for resentment to become routine, for small habits to show, and for a couple to move from strategic politeness to genuine intimacy. It also creates a useful structural challenge: the book needs to keep the shared house lively without making the leads seem foolish for staying. The official setup suggests that the property itself supplies complications, which can give each stage of the forced proximity a fresh comic problem.

The real-estate rivalry helps the conflict feel more specific than “two attractive people argue.” Jade and Damon are not strangers who can simply walk away after an awkward first meeting. Their careers and the inherited property place them in direct competition, so choosing each other may require a shift in how they understand success. That gives the romance a potential emotional payoff beyond the familiar pleasure of watching two stubborn people flirt through an argument.

What looks promising

Chase has built the hook around recognizable romance tropes but gives them a clear practical frame: enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity, a shared house, inheritance and a fixed cohabitation period. Readers know the basic shape, then get to see what character-specific choices make it feel fresh. The title also captures the central contradiction—an idea that looks disastrous on paper but may become tempting in practice.

The property’s eccentric problems could help the comedy land through action rather than endless banter. A house that actively disrupts the leads’ plans can force cooperation and reveal how they behave when they cannot control the situation. That is often where a workplace rivalry romance becomes more than verbal sparring: one character sees the other being competent, considerate or unexpectedly generous.

What may be a risk

The setup is deliberately heightened. A four-month no-leaving stipulation is a romance-novel contrivance, so its success depends on the book establishing why the characters accept it and why the legal or financial stakes matter. If those details feel thin, the reader may start asking practical questions instead of enjoying the farce. The house’s “hazards” also need variation; repeating the same kind of mishap could flatten the comedy.

The release is split by format. Emma Chase’s official page lists the audio version as available and the e-book and print editions for October 13, 2026. Readers searching for the paperback may therefore see a different status from audiobook listeners. Early reader comments are not yet broad enough to support a confident claim about critical consensus or a final review score.

Themes and ideal reader

Under the comic circumstances, the story can explore competition, control, trust and the difference between being professionally formidable and emotionally open. Jade and Damon’s shared house is a pressure cooker: they cannot avoid seeing each other’s unpolished side, and each may have to reconsider the assumptions that made the rivalry easy. The romance should be most satisfying if attraction changes their respect for each other rather than simply dissolving the conflict.

This is likely to suit readers who enjoy contemporary rom-coms with sharp-tongued rivals, forced proximity, workplace tension and a contained setting. It may be a fun pick for fans of Emma Chase’s contemporary romance voice. Readers who prefer quiet realism or dislike plot devices that rely on inheritance rules may want to sample before committing.

Is A Very Good Bad Idea worth reading?

The hook is strong and easy to pitch: two competing developers, one valuable inherited house, four months under the same roof, and enough property trouble to keep the arrangement from staying comfortable. That combination gives the book a clear lane in the enemies-to-lovers romance market. The most important test is whether Jade and Damon feel like people with credible motives once the comic rules are in place.

Because this is release week and I have not read a complete copy, this review cannot honestly award a score or declare the execution a success. Based on the official premise, it belongs on the TBR for readers who actively seek forced-proximity romantic comedies. The recommendation is “promising for the right trope reader,” with the final verdict dependent on the book’s pacing, character development and payoff.

Where to get A Very Good Bad Idea

Emma Chase’s official page lists the book and current format availability. The e-book and print release date is October 13, 2026; the audiobook is listed as available. Confirm your region’s format and delivery date on the official book page.

About the author

Emma Chase writes contemporary romance and romantic comedy. A Very Good Bad Idea brings her to a new enemies-to-lovers setup built around rival developers and an inherited property. This early review is based on official book information and the limited reader discussion available around publication; it avoids presenting promotional copy as personal experience.

You may also enjoy

Explore our romance book recommendations, second-chance romance novels, October romance releases, holiday rom-com books, and the wider That Love Podcast book guide.

Frequently asked questions

Who wrote A Very Good Bad Idea?

Emma Chase wrote A Very Good Bad Idea. It was not verified as a Josie Silver title; the correct book associated with the supplied description is Emma Chase’s A Very Good Bad Idea.

What is A Very Good Bad Idea about?

Rival real-estate developers Jade Buchanan and Damon Burke inherit the same valuable property. Its conditions require them to live in the house together for four months, creating forced proximity and romantic tension.

Is A Very Good Bad Idea out yet?

The audiobook is listed as available. The e-book and print editions are dated October 13, 2026, so format availability depends on the retailer and region.

Is A Very Good Bad Idea an enemies-to-lovers romance?

Yes. The central couple are competing developers, and the story’s setup places their professional rivalry in close quarters.

What does forced proximity mean in the book?

Jade and Damon are required to share the inherited house for four months. They cannot simply avoid one another when conflict arises, which creates opportunities for comedy and closeness.

Who are the main characters?

Jade Buchanan and Damon Burke are the rival developers at the center of the story.

Is the book a romantic comedy?

The author presents it as a romantic comedy built around rivals, cohabitation and the complications of the inherited property.

How long is the cohabitation arrangement?

The official premise states that Jade and Damon must stay in the house for four months.

Can I listen to the audiobook?

The official author listing says the audiobook is available. Check your local audiobook service for narrator and territory details.

Who should read A Very Good Bad Idea?

Readers who enjoy enemies-to-lovers romance, forced proximity, workplace rivalry and comic domestic chaos are the most obvious audience.

Support independent storytelling

If this review helped you choose a book, support That Love Podcast or listen to our original audio stories.