11 True Crime Shows That Pop in Winter Darkness
- Joao Nsita
- 2 days ago
- 14 min read
As the nights draw in and a chill settles deep in the bones, our viewing habits often take a turn towards the dark and mysterious. There is a strange, undeniable comfort in curling up under a warm blanket while a storm rages outside, and immersing ourselves in a story that is as chilling as the winter air. This is the paradoxical appeal of the true crime genre, a form of storytelling that has become a global phenomenon. The long, dark evenings of winter provide the perfect, atmospheric backdrop for these often-unsettling tales of mystery, deception, and the complex workings of the human psyche.
The fascination with true crime is more intense than ever, a trend that is constantly evolving on platforms like TikTok and Pinterest. Users are not just consuming these stories; they are engaging with them, sharing theories, and curating "watchlists" of the most compelling and well-produced docuseries. The current trend is moving beyond sensationalism and towards a more nuanced, psychological, and often victim-focused approach to storytelling. Viewers are craving deep dives into the "why" behind a crime, sophisticated investigative journalism, and series that explore the broader societal implications of a case. The "cozy true crime" aesthetic has even emerged, a testament to our desire to engage with these dark narratives from a place of safety and comfort.
This guide is your ultimate curated watchlist for the winter season. We have compiled a definitive list of 11 incredible true crime shows, counted down in descending order, that are perfect for a dark and stormy night. From mind-bending cult documentaries to meticulous cold case investigations, each series on this list offers a gripping, immersive, and thought-provoking viewing experience. So, lock your doors, brew a hot drink, and prepare to be captivated by these chilling tales that pop in the winter darkness.
We are passionate about creating inspiring, in-depth content for you to enjoy for free. If you find value and joy in our articles, please consider supporting our work with a small donation. You can also help us grow by sharing this piece with a friend who loves all things film and television. Your support allows us to continue our mission of spreading love and positivity.
11. The Vow (2020-2022)
The Vibe: Kicking off our list is a docuseries that is a slow-burn, deeply unsettling, and absolutely captivating psychological deep dive. The Vow is not a whodunnit; it’s a "how-dunnit." The series chronicles the experiences of several former members of the self-help organization NXIVM, which was later exposed as a manipulative and abusive sex cult. The show uses a wealth of intimate, real-time footage shot by the members themselves to explore the insidious process of indoctrination and the immense courage it took for them to break free.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: The Vow is the ultimate "cozy up and get completely absorbed" kind of watch. Its deliberate, patient storytelling and complex character studies require your full attention, making it perfect for a long, dark winter's night. The series is a masterful exploration of the psychology of cults, examining how intelligent, well-meaning people can be drawn into a web of coercion and manipulation. It's a chilling and often claustrophobic viewing experience that will have you questioning the very nature of belief and control. It’s a powerful and important story about the resilience of the human spirit in the face of profound betrayal. The complex power dynamics and psychological drama are as gripping as any fictional series, a quality we also praised in our review of Succession. For more on the background of the NXIVM case, you can explore in-depth reporting from sources like The New York Times.
Directors: Jehane Noujaim, Karim Amer
Where to Watch: Stream on NOW TV and Sky Documentaries in the UK.
10. The Staircase (2004; 2013; 2018)
The Vibe: The Staircase is one of the foundational texts of the modern true crime docuseries genre, a sprawling, decade-spanning saga that is as much a character study as it is a murder investigation. The series follows the case of Michael Peterson, a novelist who was accused of murdering his wife, Kathleen, after she was found dead at the bottom of a staircase in their home. The filmmakers were granted incredible access to Peterson, his family, and his legal team, creating an intimate and deeply ambiguous portrait of a man and a case full of shocking twists and turns.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This is a perfect series to get completely lost in over a series of long winter evenings. Its slow, deliberate pacing and deep dive into the legal process are incredibly immersive. The central mystery is endlessly debatable, and the series masterfully presents the evidence without ever giving the viewer an easy answer. It’s a show that will have you and anyone you watch it with playing armchair detective, debating theories long after the credits have rolled. The series raises profound questions about the nature of truth, the fallibility of the justice system, and our ability to ever truly know another person. It’s a complex, thought-provoking, and essential piece of true crime filmmaking. The story's long and twisted legal battle is a fascinating watch, a theme also central to the acclaimed drama series we reviewed, The Sopranos.
Director: Jean-Xavier de Lestrade
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
9. Don't Fk With Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer (2019)
The Vibe: This is a true crime series for the digital age, a gripping and often horrifying story that is propelled by the power of the internet. Don't F**k With Cats tells the story of a group of amateur online sleuths who launch a worldwide manhunt for a man who posted a video of himself killing kittens. Their investigation quickly spirals into a dark and dangerous game of cat and mouse as they track a killer whose cruelty escalates from animals to humans.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This three-part series is a taut, thrilling, and incredibly binge-able watch. It’s a show that will have you on the edge of your seat from the first minute to the last. The "internet sleuth" angle is a fascinating and modern twist on the true crime genre, showcasing the incredible power of online communities to achieve a common goal. However, the series is not for the faint of heart; it deals with disturbing content and raises important questions about the ethics of online vigilantism and the way that the internet can amplify our darkest impulses. It’s a compelling, shocking, and unforgettable series that is a perfect, contained watch for a single winter weekend. For more on the series and its reception, you can visit its Rotten Tomatoes page.
Director: Mark Lewis
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
8. The Keepers (2017)
The Vibe: The Keepers is a powerful, heartbreaking, and deeply important docuseries that investigates the unsolved murder of a beloved nun and Catholic high school teacher in Baltimore in 1969. What begins as a cold case investigation by two of her former students slowly unravels into a dark and sprawling conspiracy of sexual abuse and institutional cover-ups within the Catholic Church.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This is a series that is as much about investigative journalism as it is about true crime. It is a slow-burn, meticulous, and deeply respectful investigation that is driven by the courage and determination of its central figures. The series has a deeply melancholic and atmospheric tone, perfectly suited to the introspective nature of the winter season. It’s a challenging and often enraging watch, but it is also a powerful testament to the bravery of survivors and the importance of speaking truth to power. It's a series that will stay with you, a profound and important story about the search for justice against all odds. The theme of uncovering a vast conspiracy is a gripping one, a quality we also praised in our review of the Star Wars series Andor.
Director: Ryan White
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
7. Wild Wild Country (2018)
The Vibe: Wild Wild Country is a mind-bending, stranger-than-fiction docuseries that tells the story of the controversial Indian guru, Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh, who built a utopian city for his followers in the middle of the Oregon desert in the 1980s. The series chronicles the escalating conflict between the thousands of red-clad Rajneeshees and the local rural community, a conflict that spirals into wiretapping, immigration fraud, assassination plots, and the first bioterror attack in American history.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This series is the definition of a "can't-make-this-up" story. It is a six-part, incredibly binge-able series that is packed with so many unbelievable twists and turns, it will have you glued to your screen. The archival footage is absolutely incredible, and the interviews with key figures from both sides of the conflict provide a fascinating and complex look at the story. It’s a show that explores a multitude of themes: the search for enlightenment, the dark side of devotion, the clash of cultures, and the very definition of an American dream. It’s a wild, fascinating, and utterly unforgettable ride. The complex power dynamics and larger-than-life characters are as compelling as any fictional drama, like the one we reviewed in House of the Dragon.
Directors: Chapman Way, Maclain Way
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
6. I'll Be Gone in the Dark (2020)
The Vibe: Based on the masterful book by the late Michelle McNamara, I'll Be Gone in the Dark is a unique and deeply moving true crime series. It operates on two parallel tracks: it is a meticulous investigation into the case of the Golden State Killer, a serial rapist and murderer who terrorized California in the 70s and 80s, and it is a poignant portrait of McNamara's own obsessive and ultimately tragic quest to find him.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This series is a beautiful and haunting piece of television. It is a slow-burn, atmospheric, and incredibly respectful exploration of a very dark case. The series is particularly notable for its victim-focused approach, giving a powerful voice to the survivors of these horrific crimes. But the true heart of the show is the story of Michelle McNamara. It’s a powerful exploration of obsession, the psychological toll of investigating dark subject matter, and the legacy of a brilliant writer who was taken too soon. It’s a sad but ultimately hopeful story, as McNamara's work was instrumental in the eventual capture of the killer. It is a profound and beautifully crafted series that is a must-watch for any true crime aficionado. The theme of a dangerous, all-consuming quest is one we also explored in our review of the acclaimed series The Last of Us. For more on the original book, you can visit its Goodreads page.
Director: Liz Garbus
Where to Watch: Stream on NOW TV and Sky Documentaries in the UK.
5. The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (2015)
The Vibe: The Jinx is a groundbreaking, six-part docuseries that not only investigates a series of crimes but becomes a part of the story itself. The series examines the bizarre life of the eccentric New York real estate heir, Robert Durst, who has been a suspect in the disappearances and murders of three people over three decades, including his own wife. The series features extensive, candid interviews with Durst himself, leading to one of the most shocking and unforgettable endings in television history.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This series is a masterclass in tension and suspense. It is a gripping, perfectly paced mystery that will have you second-guessing everything you think you know. The access to Robert Durst is unprecedented, and watching him tell his story is a chilling and fascinating experience. The series is famous for its jaw-dropping final moments, which had a real-world impact on the case and led to Durst's arrest. It's a show that completely redefined what a true crime documentary could be. It's an essential, riveting, and deeply unsettling watch. The show’s impact on the actual legal case is well-documented by major news outlets like CNN.
Director: Andrew Jarecki
Where to Watch: Stream on NOW TV and Sky Documentaries in the UK.
4. Making a Murderer (2015-2018)
The Vibe: Making a Murderer was a true cultural phenomenon, a ten-part series that became a global obsession and sparked a worldwide conversation about the American justice system. The series documents the incredible story of Steven Avery, a man who was wrongfully convicted of a crime and served 18 years in prison before being exonerated by DNA evidence. Just two years after his release, he is arrested and convicted for another, even more horrific murder. The series meticulously examines the investigation and trial, raising profound questions about police corruption and a potential second wrongful conviction.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This is the ultimate "armchair detective" series. It is an incredibly detailed, immersive, and often infuriating deep dive into a single, complex case. The rural, wintery setting of Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, provides a bleak and atmospheric backdrop that is perfect for the season. The series will have you poring over evidence, debating with anyone you watch it with, and scouring the internet for more information. It is a powerful and thought-provoking exploration of class, power, and the potential for deep-seated corruption within the justice system. It is a landmark series that is required viewing for any fan of the genre. The complex family dynamics under pressure are as compelling as any fictional drama, like the one we reviewed in Shameless.
Directors: Laura Ricciardi, Moira Demos
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
3. Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes (2019)
The Vibe: This four-part series offers a chilling and direct look into the mind of one of history's most notorious serial killers. Using over 100 hours of previously unreleased audio interviews conducted with Ted Bundy while he was on death row, the series constructs a haunting self-portrait of a charismatic, intelligent, and utterly psychopathic killer. The narrative is a chilling exploration of the dark duality of his life—the charming law student on the surface and the monstrous predator underneath.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This is a series for those who are fascinated by criminal psychology. It is a dark, disturbing, and deeply unsettling watch that is best viewed from the safety of a cozy living room. The use of Bundy's own voice as the primary narrator is an incredibly effective and chilling device. It provides an unprecedented, first-person glimpse into his narcissism, his rationalizations, and his complete lack of empathy. The series is a stark and important reminder of the "banality of evil" and the fact that monsters often wear a very human face. It's a gripping, terrifying, and unforgettable journey into the heart of darkness. For a look at the show's critical reception and viewer ratings, you can visit its IMDb page.
Director: Joe Berlinger
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
2. Wormwood (2017)
The Vibe: Wormwood is a groundbreaking and genre-bending masterpiece from acclaimed documentary filmmaker Errol Morris. The series is a six-part investigation into the mysterious death of a CIA scientist and biological warfare expert, Frank Olson, who fell from a New York City hotel window in 1953. The series follows Olson's son, Eric, on his sixty-year quest to uncover the truth about his father's death. Morris blends traditional documentary interviews with stunning, scripted reenactments starring Peter Sarsgaard, creating a unique and visually stunning narrative hybrid.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: This is a true "prestige" docuseries, a perfect choice for cinephiles and those who appreciate artistic, unconventional storytelling. It has the moody, atmospheric feel of a classic Cold War spy thriller. The series is a labyrinthine, paranoid, and utterly engrossing mystery that delves into the dark history of the CIA's mind-control experiments. It is a deeply moving and personal story about one man's lifelong search for truth and a powerful exploration of the nature of memory, secrets, and governmental conspiracy. It is a stunning, beautiful, and thought-provoking series that will stay with you. The show's complex narrative and themes of loyalty and betrayal are as compelling as any high-stakes drama, a quality we praised in our review of The Sopranos.
Director: Errol Morris
Main Cast: Peter Sarsgaard, Molly Parker, Christian Camargo
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
1. Mindhunter (2017-2019)
The Vibe: Taking the top spot on our list is a show that, while technically a scripted drama, is so deeply rooted in the real-life origins of criminal profiling that it is essential viewing for any true crime fan. Produced by David Fincher, Mindhunter is a slow-burn, atmospheric, and intellectually rigorous series that follows two FBI agents in the late 1970s who travel the country interviewing imprisoned serial killers to try and understand their psychology, a practice that would eventually become the foundation of modern criminal profiling.
Why It's a Perfect Winter Watch: Mindhunter is the ultimate dark and moody winter binge-watch. David Fincher's signature visual style—cool, desaturated colours, meticulous composition, and an overwhelming sense of dread—is perfect for the season. The show is less about the "what" of the crimes and more about the "why." The interview scenes with the killers, based on real-life transcripts, are some of the most chilling and captivating conversations ever put on television. The actors who portray infamous killers like Ed Kemper and Charles Manson are uncannily brilliant. It’s a show that is deeply unsettling but also incredibly intelligent and thought-provoking. It is a masterpiece of psychological drama and a perfect, all-consuming escape for the long winter nights. The show’s intense character studies and focus on psychological drama are a theme we also explored in our review of the powerful series This Is Us. To find your next favourite show, you can browse a world of critically acclaimed series on streaming platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and Apple TV.
Creator: Joe Penhall
Main Cast: Jonathan Groff, Holt McCallany, Anna Torv, Cameron Britton
Where to Watch: Stream on Netflix.
Conclusion
The world of true crime is vast, varied, and endlessly fascinating. In the dark, quiet months of winter, these stories offer more than just a thrilling mystery; they provide a safe, contained space to explore our deepest fears, to marvel at the resilience of the human spirit, and to ponder the complex questions of justice, truth, and the nature of evil. The 11 shows on this list represent the very best of the genre—they are sophisticated, compelling, and ethically crafted stories that will challenge, move, and captivate you. So, as the winter darkness descends, choose your case, settle in, and prepare to be gripped by these unforgettable tales.
We hope this article has helped you find your next true crime obsession! This blog is a labour of love, and we are passionate about providing free, high-quality content. If you enjoyed what you read, please consider supporting our work. A small donation helps us continue to create and share valuable resources. You can also support us by sharing this article with a friend who might find it useful. Your support means the world to us.
Read More From That Love Podcast:
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why are people so fascinated by true crime? Psychologists suggest several reasons, including a desire to understand the criminal mind, a fascination with the puzzle-solving aspect of an investigation, and the sense of relief and safety that comes from engaging with terrifying events from a safe distance.
Are these shows very graphic or violent? The level of graphic content varies. Shows like Mindhunter and Conversations with a Killer discuss disturbing acts in detail, while series like The Vow are more focused on psychological and emotional abuse. It’s always a good idea to check for specific content warnings on sites like IMDb before watching.
What is a "docuseries"? A docuseries is a documentary that is presented in a multi-part, episodic format, similar to a traditional television series. This format allows for a much deeper and more detailed exploration of a topic or case than a single feature-length documentary.
I find some true crime exploitative. How are these shows different? The shows on this list are generally considered to be ethically made and are praised for their in-depth journalism, their focus on the psychological "why" rather than just the gruesome "what," and, in many cases, their respectful, victim-focused approach to storytelling.
I loved Making a Murderer. Which show on this list should I watch next? If you were drawn to the deep dive into the justice system in Making a Murderer, you would likely find The Staircase and The Keepers to be incredibly compelling watches.
Are there any good true crime podcasts I should listen to? Absolutely. The world of true crime podcasts is vast. Some of the most popular and acclaimed include Serial, My Favorite Murder, Casefile, and Criminal.
What if these shows are too scary or intense for me? If you find these shows too unsettling, it’s important to listen to your own comfort level. There are many fantastic "cozy mystery" fictional shows or lighter, feel-good series that can provide a great escape without the intensity. Our list of 14 Feel-Good Series That Feel Like a Warm Blanket is a great place to start.
Is Mindhunter a true story? Mindhunter is a scripted drama, but it is based on the real-life story of FBI agents John E. Douglas and Robert K. Ressler, who pioneered the field of criminal profiling in the 1970s. The killers portrayed in the show and the interview dialogue are based on real-life figures and transcripts.
Where can I find updates on the cases featured in these documentaries? Major news outlets and dedicated true crime websites often provide updates on these high-profile cases as new developments occur. Websites like Oxygen are a great resource for this.
I've seen all of these. What's another great true crime series? If you have exhausted this list, we highly recommend the docuseries The Paradise Lost Trilogy, which is another landmark series that examines a complex case over many years, or the more recent Under the Banner of Heaven, a scripted drama based on a true crime book that explores faith and murder. You can find more recommendations in the What to Watch section of our site.
Comments