Peacemaker Season 2 Review: James Gunn's Brilliant Superhero Series Is Reborn in a New DC Universe

It’s a Friday morning in late August, and a palpable, electric energy is buzzing through the pop culture landscape of London. The long, languid days of summer are giving way to the focused, anticipatory excitement of the autumn television season. In this new golden age of streaming, where cinematic universes are born, rebooted, and reborn, no project has arrived with more baggage, more expectation, and more brilliantly chaotic energy than the second season of James Gunn’s Peacemaker. This is not just the return of a beloved, R-rated superhero comedy; it is the first true test of a new DC Universe, a bold and audacious recalibration of an entire mythology.

The journey of James Gunn from a divisive, cult-favourite director to the co-chairman of DC Studios is a saga in itself. His unique, irreverent, and often juvenile style, a hallmark of his work from Slither to The Suicide Squad, has become a brand. This brand is all over social media; on TikTok and Pinterest, the iconic, deadpan dance sequence from Peacemaker's first season became a viral sensation, a testament to the show's quirky, infectious charm. Fans create aesthetic mood boards dedicated to its colourful, comic-book visuals and share clips of its most outrageously funny, often deeply offensive, jokes. The trend is clear: audiences are hungry for superhero content that is not afraid to be weird, violent, and surprisingly full of heart.

Peacemaker Season 1 was Gunn unleashed. It took John Cena’s alt-right-coded, man-child antihero from The Suicide Squad and, against all odds, transformed him into a deeply empathetic and strangely lovable character. The show was a perfect storm of R-rated comedy, explosive action, and a surprising, almost shocking, emotional depth. Now, after Gunn's creative rebirth with the critically acclaimed Superman, which laid the foundational tone for his new DCU, Peacemaker returns as a fascinating, essential, and slightly complicated next chapter. It is a show that must not only build upon its own success but also retroactively fit into a brand-new cinematic universe.

This in-depth review will serve as your guide to this ambitious and essential new season. We will explore how Gunn navigates the tricky waters of a soft reboot, how the characters have evolved, and whether the show's signature blend of chaos and heart remains intact. This is a deep dive into the show's emotional maturity, its killer soundtrack, its brilliant ensemble, and the growing pains of a series being reborn.

A New Universe, A New Peacemaker: The Art of the Soft Reboot

The biggest and most immediate challenge facing Peacemaker Season 2 is a logistical one. The first season was a product of the old, now-defunct DC Extended Universe (DCEU). The new season must exist in James Gunn’s new, rebooted DC Universe (DCU). This is a potentially confusing, canon-breaking problem, and the show addresses it with Gunn’s signature, fourth-wall-winking audacity.

The season premiere opens with a cheeky, revised "previously on..." segment that essentially gaslights the audience into accepting the new status quo. The now-infamous Justice League cameo from the Season 1 finale, which featured Jason Momoa’s Aquaman and Ezra Miller’s Flash, has been replaced. In its place, we now see members of the new DCU’s "Justice Gang," including Nathan Fillion’s wonderfully scurvy Guy Gardner and Isabela Merced’s Hawkgirl, who were introduced in Superman. It’s a bold and hilarious move that doesn't try to explain the change so much as it simply wills it into existence. This is Gunn, as the new steward of the DCU, playfully cherry-picking the elements he wants to keep and discarding the rest.

While this might be jarring for continuity purists, the show wisely doesn't get bogged down in the multiverse-level details. It trusts the audience to go along for the ride. And thankfully, the show gives us plenty of other, more interesting things to focus on. While existing in a new world, the emotional continuity of the characters remains firmly rooted in their past experiences. The events of The Suicide Squad are more central than ever, serving as the primary catalyst for the season's central conflict. The show’s ability to navigate this reboot is a testament to its confidence, a quality shared by other universe-defining films like The Avengers. For a deep dive into the complexities of the new DCU, DC Comics' official website is the best source for news and updates.

A Smaller Story, Bigger Emotions: The Heart of Season 2

While the universe around him has expanded, the story of Christopher Smith, aka Peacemaker, has become smaller, more intimate, and significantly more introspective. The first season was about a bad man learning to be good. The second season is about a man who is trying to be good but is constantly haunted by the ghosts of his past and the temptations of an easier life.

The season’s primary antagonist is not an alien invasion, but a man seeking vengeance: Rick Flag Sr. (a brilliant and menacing Frank Grillo). He is the father of Rick Flag Jr., the man Peacemaker brutally killed on Corto Maltese. Now in charge of A.R.G.U.S., Flag Sr. is using the full force of the government agency to hunt down and destroy the man who killed his son. This creates a powerful, personal, and morally complex conflict. Peacemaker has genuinely grown as a person; he has confronted the hypocrisy of his old mantra of "achieving peace at any cost." But his past actions have real, unavoidable consequences, and Rick Flag Sr. is the living embodiment of them.

The season's most brilliant and surprising storyline, however, comes from a classic sci-fi trope. While using his father’s old dimensional storage closet, Peacemaker discovers a portal to a parallel world. In this alternate reality, his life is perfect. His abusive, white-supremacist father is not just alive, but is a kind, progressive, and loving superhero who fights crime alongside him. The Harcourt of this universe is not emotionally guarded but is open and eager to explore their connection. This "greener pastures" temptation becomes the emotional core of the season. It’s a powerful exploration of regret and the fantasy of a fresh start. Why do the hard work of atoning for your past in a world that seems determined to punish you, when a perfect, ready-made life is just one step away? This storyline allows John Cena to showcase his incredible, and often underrated, dramatic range, delivering a performance that is both hilarious and deeply moving. The show's exploration of a complex father-son dynamic is a key to its success, a theme you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Movies About Fathers.

Growing Pains: The Evolution of Gunn's Signature Style

One of the most notable shifts in Season 2 is its tone. While the show is still outrageously funny and action-packed, there is a clear and welcome sense of emotional maturity. Much of the juvenile, shock-value humour that defined parts of the first season (and some of Gunn’s earlier work) has been toned down. In its place are more articulate and heartfelt conversations about emotions, trauma, and regret. It feels like the work of a filmmaker who is himself in a new, more mature phase of his career.

This evolution is aided by the addition of seasoned comedic actors like Tim Meadows, who brings a brilliant, deadpan energy that elevates every scene he is in. While there are still a few sexual gags that feel like they belong in a lost season of The Boys, the overall comedic sensibility is sharper and more character-driven. The show is finally growing up, and it’s all the better for it.

However, this tonal shift does come with some growing pains. Gunn is a master of the ensemble, but the season's focus on Peacemaker's introspective journey naturally splinters the beloved "11th Street Kids." In the first half of the season, key characters like Adebayo and Vigilante are left on the back burner, often relegated to the role of a listening ear for Peacemaker's problems. While their loyalty is a testament to the found-family dynamic that was so powerful in Season 1, they are left in a state of arrested development while the rest of the show is evolving. It’s a classic challenge of a second season, and the show hasn't quite figured out how to give every character a compelling and evolving arc. The show's focus on a found family is a huge part of its appeal, a dynamic explored in our list of The Top 5 Best Movies With An Ensemble Cast.

The Unchanged Masterstrokes: Action, Music, and That Dance

While the show has emotionally matured, the elements that made the first season a cultural phenomenon are back and better than ever.

The Action: The action sequences in Peacemaker remain some of the best on television. They are brutal, inventive, and perfectly choreographed. Gunn has a unique ability to blend visceral, R-rated violence with a comedic, almost slapstick, sensibility. The fights are always gruesome and engrossing, a perfect, chaotic expression of the show's world.

The Soundtrack: Gunn is one of the best curators of the modern movie and TV soundtrack, and Season 2 continues this tradition. The show is packed with deep cuts from the world of 80s glam metal and hair bands, a genre of music that is both ridiculously over-the-top and surprisingly heartfelt—a perfect musical metaphor for the show itself. For a taste of the show's musical style, this Spotify playlist of Hair Metal Classics is a great place to start.

The Opening Credits: In a move of pure, confident audacity, the show replaces the iconic opening dance sequence from Season 1 with a brand-new one. Choreographer Charissa Barton returns with fresh, quirky-jerky steps, set to a different, equally brilliant power ballad. It’s a fantastic risk that pays off, a signal to the audience that this is a new season with a new energy, but the same, wonderfully weird soul.

The show's blend of action and comedy is a winning formula, and for more on that, check out our list of the Top 5 Best Action Comedy Movies of All Time. The show’s complex hero is a fascinating character study, a theme you can explore in our list of the Top 5 Favorite Movie Anti-Heroes of All Time. For more on the creator's unique vision, James Gunn's interview with The Hollywood Reporter about the new DCU is a must-read.

The show's exploration of what it means to be a hero is a classic theme, which you can explore in our list of the Top 7 Best Superhero Movies of All Time. This kind of bold, genre-defining work is always exciting, a quality it shares with the films on our list of The Top 5 Best Sci-Fi Movies of All Time. The show is also a masterclass in building suspense, a quality shared by the films on our list of 6 Gripping Suspense Thriller Movies You Can't Miss. And, at its heart, it's a show about a powerful team, a dynamic you can explore in our list of The Top 5 Best Movies About Teamwork. Finally, the show's dark humour is a key to its success, a genre you can explore further in our list of 6 Must-See Dark Comedy Movies. For more on the cast, the official IMDb page for Peacemaker is a fantastic resource.

Conclusion: A Messy, Brilliant, and Essential New Chapter

Peacemaker Season 2 is a fascinating and brilliant piece of television. It is a show that is actively going through growing pains, attempting to reconcile its past with its future, both narratively and meta-textually. It’s messy, it’s ambitious, it's occasionally overindulgent, but it is never, ever boring. In moving on from the juvenile humour of its past and embracing a more earnest emotional journey, the series has become something richer, more complex, and ultimately more rewarding.

With James Gunn now at the helm of the entire DC Universe, we can’t expect a perfect, polished product every time. His style is one of beautiful, chaotic, and heartfelt imperfection. Peacemaker Season 2 is a perfect embodiment of that. It is a show that is not afraid to be vulnerable, to be weird, and to wear its massive heart on its bloody sleeve. It is a stirring, studied, and spectacular pivot that proves that even in the world of superheroes, the most compelling journey is the one towards becoming a better person.

Enjoyed what you read? If you found this review insightful, please consider supporting our work. Your generosity allows us to continue creating and sharing in-depth cultural commentary. You can make a donation by moving your cursor to the top of the article or scrolling down to the bottom. Every little bit helps us spread the love, one article at a time!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Do I need to have seen Superman (2025) to understand Peacemaker Season 2? While it's not strictly necessary, having seen Superman will help you understand the new status quo of the DCU and recognize the new Justice Gang characters who cameo in the recap.

2. Is Season 2 as funny as Season 1? The show is still hilarious, but the style of humour has matured slightly. There is less of the juvenile, shock-value humour and more sharp, character-driven comedy.

3. What is the "DCU" and how is it different from the "DCEU"? The DCEU (DC Extended Universe) was the name for the interconnected universe of films that began with Man of Steel. The DCU (DC Universe) is the name for the new, rebooted universe that is being masterminded by James Gunn and Peter Safran, which officially began with the film Superman.

4. Can I watch this show if I haven't seen The Suicide Squad (2021)? You can, but it is highly recommended that you watch The Suicide Squad first. The events of that film, particularly the death of Rick Flag Jr., are the primary motivation for the main villain in Season 2.

5. Is the opening dance sequence really different? Yes! The show created a brand new, choreographed dance sequence with a new song for Season 2, which is a fantastic and fun surprise. You can watch the new sequence on YouTube.

6. Where can I watch the show in the UK? As an HBO Max Original, Peacemaker is available to stream in the UK through Sky and its streaming service, NOW.

7. Is this show suitable for teenagers? No. Peacemaker is strictly for a mature, adult audience. It contains graphic violence, strong and persistent profanity, and explicit sexual content.

8. Who is Rick Flag Sr.? Rick Flag Sr. is a character from the DC Comics and the father of Rick Flag Jr. (who was played by Joel Kinnaman). In the show, he is a government agent who takes over A.R.G.U.S. and is seeking revenge on Peacemaker.

9. How many episodes are in Season 2? Season 2 consists of eight episodes, released weekly.

10. What is A.R.G.U.S.? A.R.G.U.S. (Advanced Research Group Uniting Super-Humans) is a secret U.S. government agency in the DC Universe that is responsible for dealing with superhuman threats. In the show, it was run by Amanda Waller.