top of page

Book Review: My Favourite Mistake by Marian Keyes

Book Review: My Favourite Mistake by Marian Keyes

Every now and then, a book comes along that not only meets your expectations but wildly exceeds them, dancing merrily on the remnants of what you thought you knew about storytelling. My Favourite Mistake by Marian Keyes is precisely that book. As someone who has always enjoyed Keyes' ability to weave humor with the hard-hitting realities of life, I approached this novel with high hopes. And oh, did it deliver!

Storytelling at Its Finest

Set against the vibrant backdrop of both bustling New York and the idyllic Irish town of Maumtully, Marian Keyes crafts a tale as enchanting as it is profound. Our protagonist, Anna, is a character crafted with such depth and relatability that it's hard not to see a bit of ourselves in her struggles and triumphs. She leaves behind a seemingly perfect life in Manhattan—a great job in beauty PR, a cozy apartment, and a well-meaning partner—to return to her roots in Ireland. Here, amidst old friends and quaint town dynamics, Anna finds herself at the heart of a luxury coastal retreat project that promises new beginnings but also resurrects old conflicts and faces local opposition.

The Return of Anna Walsh

Fans of Keyes will remember Anna Walsh from her earlier books, and in My Favourite Mistake, she shines brighter than ever. This story is a beautifully detailed exploration of life's second acts, the roads not taken, and the paths that beckon us back. Through Anna's eyes, we experience the complexities of returning home, the pain of old wounds, and the healing power of confronting our pasts.

Character Depth and Humor

Keyes' signature blend of humor and depth is on full display here. Anna’s journey is peppered with laugh-out-loud moments that Keyes fans adore, balanced perfectly with moments of sincere reflection. The secondary characters are equally compelling, from the charming yet mysterious Joey Armstrong, Anna's old flame and current wingman, to the vibrant community members of Maumtully whose resistance to change sparks both conflict and comedy.

Romance, Redemption, and Resolution

At its heart, My Favourite Mistake is a story about redemption. It’s about the mistakes we make, the people we hurt, and the attempts we make at mending broken ties. The romantic elements of the story, particularly Anna's rekindling relationship with Joey, are handled with a deft touch—romantic but realistic, offering a mature look at love the second time around.

The subplot involving the local resistance to the retreat project adds a layer of suspense and intrigue to the narrative, making the book impossible to put down. Each chapter builds on the last, weaving a complex tapestry of human emotions and motivations that culminates in a deeply satisfying conclusion.

A Literary Escape

Keyes transports readers with her vivid descriptions of both New York and Maumtully. The contrast between the two locations mirrors Anna’s internal conflict—the push and pull between a high-octane life in the city and the slow, meaningful existence she craves. Keyes’ descriptions of the Irish coastline are particularly evocative, painting a picture so vivid it’s almost like you can smell the sea air.

Enjoying this article? If you love exploring love stories, check out That Love Podcast! We bring you original, bite-sized audio rom-coms. Discover your next favorite here:

If you want to buy this book, you can buy it on amazon here.


My Favourite Mistake is more than just a novel; it's an experience. It's a journey through the complexities of life, love, and the pursuit of happiness. Marian Keyes has outdone herself, delivering a story that not only entertains but resonates deeply, reminding us that it's never too late to correct our mistakes and maybe, just maybe, make the right choices when they matter most.

If you're looking for a book that combines wit, wisdom, and warmth with a dash of whimsy, look no further than My Favourite Mistake. It's a standout in Marian Keyes' already impressive repertoire, and undoubtedly, a book that will stay with you long after you turn the final page. Get ready to laugh, cry, and fall in love with Anna’s story as she navigates the messy, beautiful journey of finding herself again. This isn't just a recommended read; it's a must-experience masterpiece.


bottom of page