top of page

A Cheeky Rom-Com Journey: Exploring The Second You’re Single by Cara Tanamachi | Book Review

A Cheeky Rom-Com Journey: Exploring The Second You’re Single by Cara Tanamachi | Book Review


Cara Tanamachi's The Second You're Single invites readers into the whirlwind world of Sora Reid, a freelance writer navigating the complexities of love, family, and self-discovery. The novel promises a humorous take on the romantic month of February, with a protagonist determined to remain single and explore the joys of solitude. This book review delves into the highs and lows of Tanamachi's rom-com, analyzing its strengths, potential shortcomings, and overall impact on readers.

Overview of the Plot

Sora Reid, the odd one out in her overachieving family, embarks on a Solo February Challenge, pledging to stay single throughout the month. The narrative takes an unexpected turn when Jack Mann, a blast from Sora's elementary school past, reenters her life. As Sora grapples with her commitment to #GoSolo and the sparks flying with Jack, the story promises a delightful exploration of love's unpredictability.

Positive Aspects

  1. Engaging Premise: Tanamachi crafts an engaging premise with Sora's Solo February Challenge, offering a fresh take on the traditional romantic narrative. The initial setup, reminiscent of a Hallmark rom-com, draws readers in with its relatability and humor.

  2. Dynamic Protagonist: Sora Reid emerges as a dynamic and relatable protagonist. Her snarky humor and relatable struggles make her a compelling character. The exploration of her self-image, body positivity, and resistance to societal expectations adds depth to her persona.

  3. Visual Writing Style: Tanamachi's choice of a snappy first-person present writing style enhances the novel's cinematic quality. The reader can vividly imagine the scenes unfolding, contributing to a visually rich reading experience.

  4. Diversity Representation: The inclusion of diverse characters, such as Sora being half Asian and having friends from BIPOC and LGBTQ+ communities, enriches the narrative. Tanamachi seamlessly integrates diversity, making the story more realistic and inclusive.

Concerns and Critiques

  1. Fat Shaming/Body Shaming: One notable drawback is the presence of fat shaming and body shaming elements in the narrative. Sora's mom projecting body image issues onto her daughter and the frequent references to bacon raise concerns about reinforcing harmful stereotypes and attitudes.

  2. Lack of Japanese American Rep Impact: While Sora is hapa (half Japanese American), the Japanese American representation in the story remains minimal. It functions more as an aspect of identity than a substantive element contributing to the plot.

  3. Overemphasis on Bacon: The repetitive references to bacon, amounting to 65 instances, may become excessive and potentially distract from the main narrative. This recurring motif, while initially amusing, risks losing its charm.

  4. Jack's Character Depth: The narration and characterization of Jack Mann, particularly in his own chapters, may lack the depth needed for readers to connect with him. Jack's portrayal as a love interest may require more exploration to make his character more compelling.

Reader Experience and Analysis

The reader's experience with The Second You're Single unfolds through the lens of its strengths and weaknesses. The protagonist's sarcastic and funny voice resonates well, particularly in navigating the challenges of love, family, and career. Sora's representation as an average-sized woman embracing her body adds a positive and refreshing dimension to the narrative.

However, the narration's shift to Jack's perspective raises concerns about its execution and his character's depth. The setting of Chicago, while mentioned, does not significantly impact the story, potentially missing an opportunity to enhance the overall atmosphere.

The Verdict

The Second You're Single by Cara Tanamachi offers readers a cheeky rom-com with an engaging premise and a dynamic protagonist. Despite concerns about fat shaming, the book provides a humorous exploration of love's unpredictability. The narrative's visual writing style and diverse character representation contribute to a compelling reading experience.

While individual preferences may influence readers' reactions, the novel's recognition as a highly anticipated romance suggests its potential to resonate with those seeking a lighthearted and humorous take on love and self-discovery.

In conclusion, The Second You're Single navigates the romantic month of February with wit and charm, leaving readers to reflect on the unexpected twists love can take when least expected.

Buy on Amazon


bottom of page