8 Dark Teen Shows to Watch If You Love Carrie

Introduction

If Carrie left you shaken, you are probably looking for something with the same pressure, the same anger and the same sense that the world is pushing a teenager past breaking point. Stephen King’s story about bullying, isolation and telekinetic rage has lasted for decades because it shows how quickly private pain can become public. Finding a series that matches that intensity is harder than it sounds.

This list does the searching for you. It brings together eight dark teen series that deal with rage, toxic friendships, revenge, secrets and psychological strain, and it explains why each one earned its place. For every show you will get a clear premise, the central conflict, what fans and critics value and who will enjoy it most.

Some of these shows are famous and some are easier to miss. Several are intense enough that you may want a serious night in before you press play, so each entry includes a note on its tone. The ranking reflects how closely each show matches the cruelty, pressure and emotional danger that makes Carrie so hard to forget.

It helps to remember why Carrie still matters before you choose. The 1974 novel and the 1976 film follow a shy student who is humiliated in front of her classmates and then discovers a power she cannot control. Modern dark teen series often ask the same question: what happens when pressure, cruelty and secrets build up with nowhere safe to go?

Before we begin, a quick note on streaming. Catalogues change often, and shows move between platforms and regions, so the where-to-watch line for each entry points you to JustWatch for current UK options rather than promising one particular service. Treat those lines as a starting point and check before you commit to a subscription. Ready to start? Let’s start 👇

Enjoying these recommendations? Donate to That Love Podcast to help us keep independent entertainment coverage and original audio stories coming.

Want to reach TV fans? Advertise with That Love Podcast and put your brand in front of a loyal audience.

Want to watch these shows in one place? Try Amazon Prime.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

8. Control Z

Control Z

Control Z is a Mexican teen thriller that premiered on Netflix in May 2020. It is set at Colegio Nacional, where an unknown hacker exposes a transgender student’s secret during a school assembly. The hacker then keeps revealing other students’ private lives, turning classmates against one another.

Sofía Herrera, an introverted student, tries to identify the hacker before her own secrets come out. She is joined by Javier Williams, a newly transferred student, and the two investigate a growing web of lies. The series ran for three seasons and 24 episodes, with the final season released in July 2022.

Why it ranks here: Control Z ranks eighth because its mystery is driven more by exposure than by deep character study. Even so, the anonymous hacker turns private humiliation into a school-wide event, which echoes the public cruelty at the heart of Carrie. It is a strong choice for viewers who want a fast, modern take on how secrets can destroy a community.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value the constant tension, the quick pace and the way the show captures how fast a rumour can spread online. The series also takes teen pressure seriously rather than treating it as a side plot. Its modern setting gives the story a sharp, contemporary edge that many viewers find hard to put down.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy teen thrillers about secrets, technology and public shaming.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge? Explore the That Love Podcast episodes.

Students can get Amazon Prime for less. Check the Prime Student offer.

7. I Am Not Okay With This

I Am Not Okay With This is an American teen comedy drama that premiered on Netflix in February 2020. It is based on Charles Forsman’s comic and created by Jonathan Entwistle and Christy Hall. The story follows Sydney Novak, a 17-year-old coping with her father’s death and constant arguments with her mother.

Sydney discovers that she has psychokinetic powers that are triggered by strong emotions. As she tries to learn control, her outbursts cause serious problems for her and the people around her. Sophia Lillis plays Sydney, with Wyatt Oleff as her friend Stan, and the series balances dark humour with real grief.

Why it ranks here: I Am Not Okay With This ranks seventh because its story of telekinetic power and simmering anger feels closest to Carrie’s central premise. It is shorter and lighter in tone than several entries above it, which is why it sits lower on the list. Still, its link to Carrie’s unstable power makes it a natural recommendation for fans of the book and film.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its sharp humour, its honest teen voice and the way it treats grief without turning it into a cliché. On Rotten Tomatoes the series holds an 87 percent approval rating from 67 reviews. The mix of comedy and danger gives it a distinctive tone that few teen shows manage.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy teen dramas with a supernatural edge and a dark sense of humour.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

6. Tell Me Lies

Tell Me Lies is an American drama that premiered on Hulu in September 2022 and was released internationally on Disney+. It is based on Carola Lovering’s 2018 novel and created by Meaghan Oppenheimer. Grace Van Patten and Jackson White play Lucy Albright and Stephen DeMarco, a student and a charming junior whose relationship becomes toxic.

The story is set at the fictional Baird College in upstate New York in the late 2000s. Lucy and Stephen’s romance is shaped by their circle of friends, a series of secrets and a tragedy that haunts the group. The show moves between college years and later adult life, and it ended with its third season in February 2026.

Why it ranks here: Tell Me Lies ranks sixth because its cruelty is quiet and psychological rather than physical. The toxic relationship and emotional control at its centre echo the pressure Carrie builds around a teenager with nowhere safe to go. It is less direct than some entries, but its honesty about manipulation gives it real weight.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its intensity, its strong performances and its uncomfortable look at toxic love. The third season scored 100 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from six reviews, while the first season scored 75 percent from 12. The series refuses to make its central relationship easy to root for, which is a large part of its appeal.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy intense relationship dramas. This series deals with mature themes, so check the guidance before you start.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

5. Dare Me

Dare Me

Dare Me premiered on USA Network in December 2019 and ran for one season. It is based on Megan Abbott’s 2012 novel and developed for television by Abbott and Gina Fattore. Willa Fitzgerald and Herizen Guardiola lead the cast in a story about competitive high school cheerleaders in a small Midwestern town.

When a new coach, Colette French, takes over the squad, the cheerleaders are drawn into a series of dark secrets and power games. The captain must protect her place and her friendships while the coach’s agenda becomes clear. USA Network cancelled the series in April 2020, so viewers get one complete season.

Why it ranks here: Dare Me ranks fifth because its rivalry and manipulation feel close to the pressure that builds in Carrie. Its focus on control and reputation gives the story a clear, dangerous spine. It is a tense, stylish series that rewards viewers who like teen thrillers built on power.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its tension, its performances and its sharp focus on control, loyalty and betrayal. On Rotten Tomatoes the series holds an 85 percent approval rating from 27 reviews, and Metacritic gives it 73 from 12 critics. The show feels like a thriller first and a teen drama second, which is what keeps viewers hooked.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy tense teen thrillers and stories about rivalry and power.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

4. Grand Army

Grand Army

Grand Army premiered on Netflix in October 2020 and was created by Katie Cappiello, who based the series loosely on her play. It follows five teenagers at Grand Army High School, the largest high school in Brooklyn. Odessa A’zion and Odley Jean lead a cast navigating school, relationships, social media and personal identity.

The storylines address racism, poverty, sexual assault, drugs, LGBT identity and mental health. Cappiello drew on real-life accounts from her students, which gives the show a grounded feel. Netflix cancelled the series in June 2021 after one season, leaving a raw portrait of modern teen life.

Why it ranks here: Grand Army ranks fourth because its honest look at peer pressure and public humiliation feels close to Carrie’s themes. The show deals with real-world pressures that can be harder to watch than many supernatural stories. It is less stylised than several entries above it, but its grounded approach gives it a strong emotional punch.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its honesty, its performances and its modern take on teen pressure. On Rotten Tomatoes the series scored 71 percent from 14 reviews, and Metacritic gave it 68 from 12 reviews. Its willingness to address difficult subjects head-on is what sets it apart from more polished teen dramas.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy realistic teen dramas that do not shy away from hard subjects.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

A quick note on the middle of this list: the next entries move from psychological thrillers toward the sharper, more grounded teen dramas. Listen to our original audio stories while you decide.

Want to reach TV fans? Advertise with That Love Podcast and put your brand in front of a loyal audience.

3. The Society

The Society premiered on Netflix in May 2019 and runs for one season of ten episodes. Christopher Keyser created the series, and Marc Webb directed it. Kathryn Newton and Rachel Keller lead the cast in a story about a town where the adults suddenly vanish.

After the adults of West Ham, Connecticut, disappear, the students at the local high school must govern themselves. A dense forest cuts the town off from phone and internet contact, so the teens must create their own rules with limited resources. The story explores how the inequalities of the old world reappear in their new society.

Why it ranks here: The Society ranks third because its teens turning on each other under pressure echoes the cruelty at the heart of Carrie. The power struggles feel close to the group dynamics that make Carrie’s school so frightening. It is a strong pick for viewers who want a survival story driven by teenage politics rather than monsters.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its tension, its teen politics and its survival story. On Rotten Tomatoes the single season scored 86 percent from 36 reviews, and Metacritic gave it 66 from nine critics. The show’s focus on how fairness and power break down under pressure gives it a lasting hook.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy teen survival dramas and stories about power and fear.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

Looking for more to watch? Explore this Amazon offer.

2. Cruel Summer

Cruel Summer premiered on Freeform in April 2021 and ran for two seasons before its cancellation in December 2023. Bert V. Royal created the series, with Olivia Holt and Chiara Aurelia in the lead roles. The first season is set between 1993 and 1995 in the fictional town of Skylin, Texas.

Jeanette Turner takes over the life of the popular Kate Wallis after Kate disappears. When Kate is found alive, she accuses Jeanette of staying silent about her abduction, and the rivalry between the two girls becomes a dangerous power struggle. The second season moves to a later storyline in a different town and follows a new group of characters.

Why it ranks here: Cruel Summer ranks second because its bullying, rivalry and secrets make the pressure of teen life feel as dangerous as Carrie’s. The first season’s shifting timeline keeps the mystery tense, and the central relationship drives every twist. It falls just behind the top three because its second season received much weaker reviews.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value the tense timeline structure, the twists and the strong performances. The first season scored 94 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 33 reviews, while the second scored 69 percent from nine reviews. Its slow-burn mystery rewards viewers who pay attention to small details.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy dark teen mysteries with twisting timelines.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

1. Yellowjackets

Yellowjackets premiered on Showtime in November 2021 and has released three seasons, with a fourth and final season due in 2026. Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson created the series. Sophie Nélisse plays the teenage Shauna Shipman, and Melanie Lynskey plays her adult version.

In 1996, a high school girls’ soccer team flying to a national tournament crashes in the Canadian wilderness. The survivors are stranded for nineteen months, and some of them turn to cannibalism to stay alive. The series also follows the survivors in 2021, showing how the ordeal continues to shape their lives and relationships.

Why it ranks here: Yellowjackets ranks first because its survival story is the most brutal on the list, and its pressure builds across both timelines. The teenage girls are driven by fear, rivalry and guilt, which mirrors the rage and fallout at the heart of Carrie. It is the darkest and most psychologically ambitious pick, and that is why it earns the top spot.

Why fans and critics value it: Fans value its tension, its layered mystery and its strong cast across both time periods. The first season scored 100 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, the second 94 percent and the third 84 percent. Its blend of survival horror and a study of trauma is what sets it apart from other teen shows.

Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy dark psychological thrillers and are comfortable with violence and intense themes.

Where to watch in the UK: Check current streaming, rental and purchase options on JustWatch.

🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge? Explore the That Love Podcast episodes.

Why Dark Teen Dramas Hit So Hard

Dark teen dramas work because they show how pressure builds in adolescence. Bullying, rivalry and secrets can feel as dangerous as any supernatural force, which is why stories like Carrie still resonate with readers and viewers. The school corridor, the group chat and the party can all become a place where reputation is won or lost in seconds.

Many of these series also explore loneliness, revenge and the cost of trying to fit in. That honesty is what makes them so compelling, even when they are hard to watch. Watching them can feel uncomfortable, but it also gives viewers a way to think about the pressures they once felt themselves.

How to Choose Your First Watch

Start with the mood you want. For a brutal, twisty survival story, Yellowjackets is the place to begin. For a sharper teen thriller, Dare Me or Control Z are strong choices, and for a shorter binge, I Am Not Okay With This and The Society suit a single weekend.

Think about how long you have. Yellowjackets and Tell Me Lies offer longer runs, while Dare Me and Grand Army are complete single-season stories. If you want a full story without a long commitment, choose a show that ended on its own terms.

Check the reviews before you commit. Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes give critic scores for most of these series, and Wikipedia gives background on the cast, creators and production history before you start.

Advertise With That Love Podcast

If your brand wants to reach people who love TV and audio drama, advertise with That Love Podcast. We work with brands, authors and streaming businesses that want a warm, loyal audience. Find out how to advertise.

Final Thoughts

The best dark teen shows for Carrie fans combine tension, psychology and emotional honesty. Whichever you choose, you will have a story about the pressures of growing up, and most of these series show how those pressures can change a life.

Which one will you start with? Tell us in the comments which show you would most like to see reviewed next, and let us know what we missed. Your suggestions help shape future guides.

Want to keep your watchlist going? Try Amazon Prime.

Support That Love Podcast

If you enjoyed this guide and want to support more independent entertainment coverage and original audio storytelling, donate to That Love Podcast. Looking for something new to listen to? Listen to That Love Podcast.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which show is the darkest?

Yellowjackets is the darkest pick here, with brutal survival scenes and a story that stays grim across both timelines.

Is Cruel Summer a complete story?

It ran for two seasons, and the second season moves to a different town and storyline, so check the details before you start.

Is The Society a survival story?

Yes. The adults of a town vanish, and the teenagers left behind must govern themselves while cut off from the outside world.

Is Dare Me based on a book?

Yes. It is based on Megan Abbott’s 2012 novel.

Is Tell Me Lies suitable for every viewer?

No. It deals with mature themes and intense relationships, so check the guidance before you watch.

Is I Am Not Okay With This based on a comic?

Yes. It is based on Charles Forsman’s comic.

Is Control Z a Mexican series?

Yes. It is set at Colegio Nacional, a school in Mexico.

Is Grand Army realistic?

It is a grounded teen drama that tackles real issues, and its storylines draw on accounts from the creator’s students.

Which show is closest to Carrie?

I Am Not Okay With This shares Carrie’s telekinetic powers and simmering anger, while Control Z echoes its public humiliation.

Where can I find more dark teen shows?

IMDb and Wikipedia list shows by genre, and JustWatch shows where each title is available in the UK.

Find cast details on IMDb for the wider list of dark teen dramas.

Want to watch the full list? Try Amazon Prime.

More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows

If you want to keep exploring, these trusted sites cover reviews, news and streaming guides: IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Wikipedia, TV Guide, Entertainment Weekly, Deadline and The Hollywood Reporter.

Enjoyed What You Read?

Enjoyed what you read? Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest articles, entertainment recommendations, podcast updates and exclusive giveaways. If you know someone who loves this genre, share the guide with them too. Visit That Love Podcast.

Watch more with Amazon Prime. Try Amazon Prime.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply