15 Best Crime and Mystery Shows to Binge This Winter
A cold winter evening is made for a crime story with enough atmosphere to pull you in and enough unanswered questions to keep you pressing “next episode.” The best crime and mystery shows do more than scatter clues: they give us detectives worth following, communities full of secrets and people whose private choices make the case matter. This list brings together British investigations, American character studies, Nordic noir and stylish international thrillers, so you can choose the kind of binge that suits your mood.
The ranking runs from brisk, twist-led mysteries to series with richer character arcs and a lasting sense of place. Some titles are compact miniseries that can be finished over a weekend; others build their worlds across multiple seasons. The countdown follows your supplied order, with True Detective at number one. I’ve kept plot descriptions spoiler-light and added UK viewing notes, but streaming catalogues move around, so the linked listings are useful to check on the night.
If you’re after a puzzle, start with The Chestnut Man or The Missing. For an investigation shaped by one remarkable detective, try Mare of Easttown, Happy Valley or Unforgotten. And if your ideal winter watch has an intelligence operation, a flawed team and a little dark humour, Slow Horses is the one to queue up. There is no single right way to watch: begin with a complete miniseries if you want a tidy finish, or settle into a longer show if you want company for several evenings.
Our top three reward different appetites. Happy Valley is intimate and character-led; Broadchurch makes a whole town feel implicated in one tragedy; True Detective uses its anthology format to explore distinct worlds and partnerships. The order weighs the strength of the central mystery, the performances, the atmosphere, and whether the series earns its ending or keeps its momentum across seasons. If a title has a particularly bleak tone, I’ll flag that too—because winter viewing can be cosy, but crime drama rarely promises comfort.
A note on newer entries: The Night Manager and The Chestnut Man have additional seasons in the current catalogue, and Dept. Q is included as a recent adaptation. This guide describes each show’s premise without spoiling the major turns. Streaming notes refer to the UK and were checked in November 2026; confirm the individual season listings before you settle in.
Support That Love Podcast
If you enjoy our entertainment coverage, you can help support That Love Podcast and keep independent articles and original audio stories coming. Donate to That Love Podcast. That Love Podcast also features original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories—browse the episodes here.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
15. The Stranger (2020)
Adam Price seems to have the settled life he wanted: a marriage to Corinne, two sons, a comfortable home and a place in his community. Then a woman he has never met approaches him with an explosive claim about Corinne. Adam’s attempt to find out whether the stranger is telling the truth draws him into a widening network of secrets, blackmail and disappearances. At the same time, the story follows police officers investigating a separate case that gradually connects to the same uneasy web. The central pleasure is watching ordinary people discover how little they know about those closest to them.
Richard Armitage gives Adam a credible mix of hurt, suspicion and panic, while Hannah John-Kamen makes the Stranger unsettling because she remains so composed. The eight-part structure keeps introducing new questions, and the show is good at turning a small domestic doubt into a town-wide crisis. The occasional coincidence is part of the heightened Harlan Coben machinery, so viewers who prefer tightly realistic police work may find the plotting a little too busy. Still, it is an efficient cold-weather binge: every answer nudges the story toward a fresh complication.
Why it ranks here: It opens the countdown because it is brisk, accessible and consistently twisty, but it puts shock reveals ahead of the deeper character work found higher up this list. If you want a weekend mystery that moves quickly, this is an inviting starting point.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: streaming on Netflix, according to JustWatch UK (checked November 2026).
🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge?
Discover original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories from That Love Podcast. Listen to That Love Podcast
14. Marcella (2016–2021)
Marcella Backland is a London detective who returns to the Metropolitan Police’s Murder Squad after her marriage collapses. She is still trying to reconnect with her children and make sense of the life she thought she had, while a series of killings recalls an old case she could not solve. The investigation demands that Marcella read patterns in evidence and in people, but her own memory and episodes of lost time make her an unreliable witness to her actions. The result is a crime story in which the question is not only who is responsible, but how much Marcella can trust herself.
Anna Friel anchors the series with a performance that makes Marcella’s volatility feel both alarming and human. The show’s fractured visual style reflects her disorientation, and its London setting keeps the investigation moving through very different social worlds. It can be deliberately disorienting, and its later turns become more heightened, but the character’s damaged determination gives the mystery an emotional centre. The supporting cast adds useful tension rather than merely standing around to deliver clues.
Why it ranks here: Marcella ranks above The Stranger for its more distinctive lead and more psychologically unsettled point of view. It remains below the titles ahead because its plotting can become less controlled as the seasons go on.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: available on Netflix and ITVX; the latter has ad-supported and paid options. Check the current listings on JustWatch UK.
13. The Sinner (2017–2021)
Each season begins with a crime whose perpetrator is already known, then asks what buried history made the act possible. In the first story, young mother Cora Tannetti suddenly attacks a stranger at a public beach, shocking witnesses and herself. Detective Harry Ambrose takes the case and becomes convinced that the apparent motive is only the surface of a much older wound. Later seasons give Ambrose new communities and new crimes to investigate, while retaining the same interest in memory, shame and the stories people tell themselves.
Bill Pullman’s Ambrose is an unusual television detective: clever, but also personally bruised and sometimes too willing to cross professional lines. Jessica Biel gives the first season a painful stillness, and subsequent guest leads bring their own distinct emotional temperature. The inverted-mystery format shifts attention from clue-hunting to interviews, flashbacks and psychological excavation. That can make the pace feel patient, and not every season lands with the force of the first, but the series is rewarding when you want to understand the damage behind a crime rather than simply identify a culprit.
Why it ranks here: It beats the earlier entries through its clear season-by-season concept and strong central performances. Its uneven later chapters keep it in the lower half, while the best picks here sustain more momentum across their complete stories.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: all four seasons are listed on Netflix and available to buy digitally; check JustWatch UK for current options.
12. The Night Manager (2016–)
Jonathan Pine, a former British soldier working as a hotel night manager, is drawn into an intelligence operation after a guest entrusts him with evidence about arms dealer Richard Roper. An undercover team wants Pine to infiltrate Roper’s circle and gather proof, but the assignment requires him to perform a convincing new identity among people who are rich, dangerous and alert to weakness. The danger comes from the gap between Pine’s official mission and the personal relationships he has to fake or risk. Season one adapts John le Carré’s novel; later episodes continue the story beyond that original book.
Tom Hiddleston gives Pine a controlled, watchful presence, while Hugh Laurie makes Roper charming enough to be frightening. The production uses luxury settings as a contrast to the violence beneath the polished surface, and the suspense often comes from a pause or a glance rather than a gunfight. Its spy mechanics are more glamorous than documentary-realistic, but that sleekness is part of its appeal. The later continuation expands the world and gives the story a fresh chapter; newcomers should begin with the first season to understand Pine’s original mission.
Why it ranks here: Its quality of performance and atmosphere lift it above The Sinner, though its polished spy-thriller mode feels less intimate than the crime dramas in the upper tier. It is also a satisfying choice for viewers who want espionage rather than a conventional murder investigation.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: JustWatch lists the series on Sky Go, Prime Video and Disney+ as of November 2026. See current UK listings.
11. The Chestnut Man (2021–)
In Copenhagen, detectives Naia Thulin and Mark Hess are assigned to a brutal murder scene where a small figure made from chestnuts has been left behind. A fingerprint on the figure appears to connect the killing with the disappearance of a politician’s young daughter years earlier, a case officially considered closed. Thulin and Hess have to revisit the old investigation while the killer appears to be staging new crimes around the same symbolic clue. The story’s winter-dark palette is more than decoration: its chilly streets and quiet suburbia make the violence feel close to home.
The series makes its central pairing engaging through friction rather than instant friendship. Thulin is ambitious and sharp; Hess is newly returned from an international posting and reluctant to settle. Their contrasting approaches give the procedural scenes texture, while the chestnut figures offer a simple, memorable image to hold the mystery together. It is grim and sometimes graphic, so this is not cozy crime. What keeps it compelling is the way the old disappearance changes the meaning of each new discovery, with the investigators forced to question what the earlier case left unresolved.
Why it ranks here: It rises above the previous entries for its strong visual identity and carefully linked cold case, but its relentless bleakness and familiar serial-killer framework stop it climbing further.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: seasons one and two are listed on Netflix. Confirm the current catalogue at JustWatch UK.
10. The Night Of (2016)
New York college student Nasir “Naz” Khan borrows his father’s taxi for a night out, meets a woman named Andrea, and wakes to find her dead. With his memory clouded and physical evidence pointing toward him, Naz is arrested and pushed into a criminal justice system he barely understands. Defence lawyer John Stone takes his case, while police, prosecutors, jail staff and Naz’s family each confront different parts of the same crisis. The eight-part miniseries follows the investigation and its consequences, asking how an accusation changes a person even before a jury reaches a verdict.
Riz Ahmed’s performance charts Naz’s transformation without turning it into a simple before-and-after portrait. John Turturro gives Stone a weary, resourceful humanity, and the series makes courtroom procedure feel inseparable from the city, the jail and the people who have to survive both. Its patient pace gives small decisions real weight; the mystery is only one strand of a broader look at class, prejudice and institutional pressure. Some subplots are more vivid than others, but the series rarely treats the accused, the victim or the process as a puzzle piece.
Why it ranks here: This is the first entry that moves beyond a crime hook into a sustained examination of what the system does to people. It sits at ten because its measured approach is demanding and its final stretch is less tightly focused than the strongest titles above it.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: JustWatch lists it on Prime Video and HBO Max, with digital purchase also available; see current listings.
🎧 Taking a break from the screen?
Listen to original romance, comedy and drama stories from That Love Podcast. Explore the latest episodes
9. The Fall (2013–2016)
When a series of murders in Belfast appears to share a pattern, Detective Superintendent Stella Gibson is sent from London to review the investigation. The audience also sees the private life of Paul Spector, a family man whose public respectability hides a predatory double life. That dramatic irony changes the usual police procedural: the question is not simply who committed the crimes, but whether Gibson’s team can identify and stop him before he chooses another victim. The series tracks the investigators’ methodical work alongside the psychological space in which Spector operates.
Gillian Anderson plays Gibson with a calm authority that refuses the familiar stereotype of the emotionally consumed detective. Jamie Dornan is chilling precisely because Spector can seem ordinary in a domestic setting. Belfast gives the show a lived-in atmosphere, and its deliberate pacing lets tension build through surveillance, interviews and routine. The subject matter is disturbing and the series can feel stark, but it treats the victims’ humanity seriously rather than making the killer’s psychology the only story. Its most gripping scenes often come from professional restraint: people trying to stay composed while danger gets closer.
Why it ranks here: The dual perspective and controlled performances make it a step up from the procedural and psychological entries below. It does not rank higher because its bleakness is substantial, and later episodes do not always match the concentrated tension of its opening.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: listed on Prime Video and Disney+ with free-with-ads availability also indicated on JustWatch UK.
Advertise With That Love Podcast
Want to put your book, entertainment brand, streaming service, product or business in front of readers who love movies, television, books and pop culture? That Love Podcast offers sponsorship and advertising opportunities across the website, podcast and newsletter. Learn about advertising.
8. The Missing (2014–2016)
The first season begins during a family holiday in France, where the young Oliver Hughes disappears from a crowded street. Years later, his father Tony is still searching, while a detective reopens the case and the family tries to live with an absence that has never become an answer. The series moves between the original investigation and its later consequences, showing how time alters the evidence, the relationships and the people who refuse to stop looking. The second season tells a separate missing-person story, retaining the show’s interest in how a disappearance reshapes everyone left behind.
James Nesbitt makes Tony’s grief volatile and exhausting, while Tchéky Karyo’s detective Julien Baptiste provides a patient, observant counterweight. The timelines are handled with clarity, and the shifts across years create genuine suspense without treating the family’s pain as a cheap trick. It is emotionally heavy viewing: the mystery matters, but so do the choices and silences that accumulate while the case remains open. The anthology approach gives the show room to reset, and Baptiste’s thoughtful presence helps connect its seasons without reducing them to the same plot.
Why it ranks here: It reaches the top eight for emotional ambition and for making the long-term impact of a cold case central to the mystery. The best dramas above it have a more distinctive voice or even tighter overall construction.
Who should watch it: Anyone looking for a strong winter mystery with a clear hook, especially viewers who like character-led investigations and slow reveals.
Where to watch: UK: currently listed on Disney+, Sky Go and Prime Video. Verify season-by-season options through JustWatch UK.
7. Slow Horses (2022–)
After botching assignments or becoming inconvenient to their bosses, MI5 agents are sent to Slough House, a shabby London office where they are expected to waste away under the supervision of Jackson Lamb. River Cartwright arrives after a public training disaster and finds a team of misfits who are more capable than their workplace suggests. When real intelligence threats surface, the so-called slow horses have to act, often while their own agency obstructs them. The series follows different operations across seasons, with Lamb’s team repeatedly pulled into dangerous situations that the polished headquarters would rather keep quiet.
Gary Oldman makes Lamb a marvellous contradiction: slovenly and rude, yet frequently the most alert person in the room. The ensemble gives each agent a comic flaw and a credible skill, so banter never erases the real stakes. The plots move briskly, but the writing allows institutional pettiness and personal failure to be just as entertaining as surveillance and danger. Its London is deliberately unglamorous, a city of offices, buses and badly maintained buildings that suits the agency’s cast-offs. The mix of dry comedy and sharp espionage makes it unusually rewatchable.
Why it ranks here: It earns a top-seven place for combining a propulsive case-of-the-season structure with one of television’s richest ensembles. It stays below the top six because it leans more into spy comedy and less into the emotional gravity of the best mysteries.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: streaming on Apple TV; confirm the latest season count on JustWatch UK.
6. Mare of Easttown (2021)
Mare Sheehan is a detective in a small Pennsylvania town where everyone knows her family history and expects her to solve the local cases. A teenage mother’s murder pulls Mare into an investigation that touches several families, while she is still carrying the unresolved disappearance of a local girl and the consequences of her own grief. Her work and private life collide as the town watches, gossips and demands answers. The series builds its central mystery from relationships and social pressures, asking who had the opportunity to commit the crime and what the community has chosen not to see.
Kate Winslet’s performance is full of regional detail without turning Mare into a collection of mannerisms. Evan Peters brings warmth and energy as a younger detective temporarily assigned to help, and the ensemble makes the town feel inhabited even when everyone has something to hide. The investigation is compelling, but the domestic scenes are what give it staying power: family members argue, reconcile and carry on in the same rooms where grief has settled. It is careful with its red herrings and does not let the solution erase the human cost of the case.
Why it ranks here: Mare makes the top six because it balances a satisfying investigation with exceptional character writing. It ranks just below the top five because its single-season scope offers less breadth than the best ongoing worlds on this list.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: HBO Max/Sky options are subject to change; check the title’s current status via JustWatch UK.
5. Unforgotten (2015–)
A routine discovery—human remains hidden in a building site, a suitcase or another place no one expected to become a crime scene—can reopen a case decades after the victim vanished. In Unforgotten, detectives DCI Cassie Stuart and DI Sunny Khan identify the dead, then trace the people whose lives intersected with the victim. Each season introduces a new case and a fresh set of suspects, many of whom have built respectable lives around memories they would rather leave buried. The investigation unfolds through interviews and patient reconstruction rather than a race from one spectacular clue to another.
Nicola Walker and Sanjeev Bhaskar create a warm, unshowy partnership that makes long conversations feel like the drama’s main event. The suspects are given their own daily pressures and contradictions, so the past is never an abstract timeline. That quiet method is a strength: the show observes how secrets survive inside ordinary households. Its series-by-series format makes it easy to start, though the emotional consequences can be sobering. The later seasons refresh the central team while preserving the procedural rhythm, allowing the show to evolve without abandoning the patience that made it distinctive.
Why it ranks here: Unforgotten takes fifth place for its humane treatment of victims and its reliable cold-case structure. It edges Mare by offering repeated, carefully built mysteries, while the higher four have even stronger atmosphere, character arcs or cumulative impact.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: ITVX is the natural place to check first; listings vary by season and subscription. See JustWatch UK.
You May Also Like
Want another mystery for your watchlist? These published guides are worth a look.
- 10 Best Black-Led Police and Detective Shows to Watch Right Now
- 10 Best Female Detective TV Shows of All Time
- 10 Best Small-Town Murder Mystery Shows
- 10 Best Detective Shows for a Cold Winter Weekend
- 10 Best Female Detectives in British Crime Dramas
- 10 Best Police Procedurals of the 2020s
4. Dept. Q (2025–)
Carl Mørck is a gifted Copenhagen detective whose abrasive manner has left him isolated after a violent incident devastates his team. His superiors assign him to Department Q, a new unit meant to review cold cases, and pair him with Assad, an assistant whose insight and patience quickly prove more valuable than the label suggests. Their first investigation centres on a woman who vanished years earlier, a disappearance that appears to have been abandoned by everyone with the power to reopen it. Mørck and Assad follow the old evidence and discover that the case still has dangerous consequences in the present.
The series gives its detective partnership room to take shape: Mørck’s bluntness is not treated as a charming superpower, and Assad’s competence changes the balance of the room. Edinburgh provides a damp, shadowed setting that distinguishes this adaptation from the Danish novels and films that inspired it. The cold-case format offers a strong weekly engine, while the central mystery builds toward a more personal emotional register. Its first season is still establishing the larger ensemble, but the chemistry between its leads makes the unit feel like a place worth returning to.
Why it ranks here: Dept. Q claims fourth for its fresh setting, appealing partnership and a mystery with both procedural and personal stakes. It sits below the top three because one season has not yet built the long-term payoff of a finished classic.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: available on Netflix. Check Netflix’s official title page for availability and current details.
3. Happy Valley (2014–2023)
Sergeant Catherine Cawood patrols a West Yorkshire valley while carrying private grief that has shaped her family and her work. When the man responsible for the crime that changed her life returns to the area, Catherine becomes caught in a case involving a kidnapping, a local businessman and a web of people who underestimate how much she can endure. The investigation drives the drama, but the central stakes are also intimate: Catherine must protect her family and community without allowing anger to become the only force steering her. Across three series, the story gives those consequences room to unfold.
Sarah Lancashire’s performance is formidable because Catherine can be funny, compassionate and frightening without changing into a different person between scenes. The Yorkshire setting feels specific rather than postcard-pretty, and Sally Wainwright’s writing lets working people speak with humour even when the subject matter is severe. James Norton makes the antagonist unsettling, but the show stays focused on Catherine and the wider community rather than glamorising him. The three-season arc rewards a full binge: later chapters deepen relationships and revisit earlier wounds with more purpose than a simple return of the villain.
Why it ranks here: The combination of a commanding lead, vivid regional voice and complete character arc puts Happy Valley above the excellent procedural at number four. It ranks third because the top two deliver mysteries with an even broader cultural and emotional reach.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: check BBC iPlayer for current availability; the BBC programme page is the authoritative starting point: Happy Valley on the BBC.
2. Broadchurch (2013–2017)
When an eleven-year-old boy is found dead on the shore of a Dorset town, Detective Sergeant Ellie Miller expects to lead the case—until Detective Inspector Alec Hardy arrives and takes the role she wanted. Their investigation becomes a public ordeal as journalists descend, neighbours look at one another differently and the boy’s family tries to survive an unbearable loss. The first series follows the murder inquiry; later series widen the world to other investigations while keeping the town and its detectives at the centre. The mystery is powerful because the suspects are not strangers on a board: they are part of the same community.
Olivia Colman and David Tennant make Ellie and Hardy’s partnership the show’s beating heart. Their differing instincts create friction, but their performances also reveal how the case changes each of them. The seaside setting provides striking images without softening the story’s emotional weight, and the ensemble gives the town enough life to make every accusation hurt. Broadchurch understands that a solved crime does not restore what was lost. Its first season is the most concentrated, while the later chapters explore the consequences and public scrutiny that follow.
Why it ranks here: Broadchurch takes second for its memorable partnership, community-wide storytelling and emotional force. It narrowly loses the top spot because one entry here builds a more expansive anthology, with new places and detectives while retaining a singular, haunting identity.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: currently on ITVX and Netflix according to JustWatch UK. For the show’s official platform page, see ITVX.
🎧 Before we reveal our No. 1 pick…
You can also discover original romantic audio dramas from That Love Podcast. Listen here
1. True Detective (2014–)
True Detective is an anthology, so each season follows a new investigation, setting and cast. Its first season remains the show’s defining chapter: Louisiana detectives Rust Cohle and Marty Hart are asked to revisit a ritualised murder years after they first worked the case. As the investigation moves between past and present, the two men’s partnership strains under their conflicting temperaments, private lives and different ideas about what justice requires. Later seasons and the Alaska-set fourth chapter create their own versions of the series’ mix of crime and character drama, but the central appeal is the way a case becomes a portrait of the people trying to solve it.
Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson give the original season a compelling push and pull: Cohle’s bleak intelligence meets Hart’s more conventional confidence, and neither man is reduced to a single trait. The Louisiana landscape feels atmospheric without being mere scenery, while the time shifts steadily change how viewers understand the detectives and their investigation. The anthology format makes it possible to move between distinct stories rather than stretch one central mystery past its natural end. Seasons vary in tone and reception, but the show’s best chapters combine strong performances, ambitious visual direction and an investigation that lingers after the final episode.
Why it ranks here: True Detective earns number one because it brings together the qualities that make a winter crime binge satisfying: a gripping case, an unforgettable central partnership, a strong sense of place and a format that lets each season tell a complete new story. Broadchurch is more intimate and Happy Valley’s lead character is richer over time, but True Detective has the widest range of mood and setting, with a first season that remains the most haunting single arc on this list. Its uneven seasons are a real caveat, yet the anthology’s strongest chapters make it the most rewarding overall destination for viewers who want mystery with ambition.
Who should watch it: Viewers who enjoy layered crime drama, memorable detectives and stories that take their characters seriously.
Where to watch: UK: seasons are currently listed through HBO Max, Sky Go and related channels; availability can vary by season. Check JustWatch UK before subscribing.
Work With That Love Podcast
That Love Podcast works with brands, authors, publishers, entertainment companies and businesses interested in reaching readers who enjoy pop culture. Explore sponsorship and advertising opportunities.
Conclusion
A good winter crime binge can be a tightly wound mystery, a patient cold-case investigation or a sprawling story about the people living beside the crime. The Stranger and The Sinner are quick to hook you; The Missing and Unforgotten give the past room to reshape the present. Slow Horses brings welcome wit to espionage, while Mare of Easttown and Happy Valley place their detectives inside communities they cannot simply leave behind.
If you want one complete season, Mare of Easttown is an excellent choice. For a full character arc, Happy Valley rewards watching from the start. Broadchurch is the pick when you want the community itself to feel like a character. True Detective wins the ranking because its anthology format lets each story build its own world and partnership, and its strongest season remains both a gripping investigation and a character study. Its seasons vary, but the best of them leave a mood that stays after the credits.
Which show would you put at number one? Tell us whether you prefer a clever detective, an atmospheric setting or a mystery that keeps changing shape—and let us know if a favourite was missed. A winter watchlist is always better with one more recommendation.
You May Also Like
If you want more detective stories, British mysteries and cold-weather viewing ideas, try these published guides.
- 10 Near-Perfect British Crime Shows
- 10 Near-Perfect British Mystery Shows
- 10 Near-Perfect Mystery Shows on Netflix
- 10 Near-Perfect Murder Mystery Shows
- 10 Netflix Mystery Shows Perfect for a Cold Winter Night
- 10 Cosy Murder Mysteries to Binge This Winter
Support independent entertainment coverage
Enjoy That Love Podcast’s articles? Support the site on Ko-fi, then listen to our original romantic audio stories when you’re ready for something different.
You May Also Like
Keep your watchlist growing with these related guides.
- 10 Mystery Shows Perfect for a Cold and Rainy Weekend
- 10 Best British Detective Shows Based on Books
- 8 Brilliant British TV Detectives to Watch After Ludwig
- 10 Best Spy Thriller Shows to Binge-Watch
- 10 Best Spy Thrillers Like Slow Horses That Redefine Espionage
- 10 Best Small-Town Mystery Shows Like Below
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best crime and mystery show to binge this winter?
True Detective is our number-one pick because its anthology format combines compelling investigations with distinctive settings and character partnerships. Season one is the strongest starting point if you want a complete story with a particularly memorable atmosphere. For a more intimate British mystery, Broadchurch is an excellent alternative; for a lead detective with a longer personal arc, try Happy Valley. The best choice depends on whether you want a single-season binge, a multi-season story or an anthology you can sample season by season.
Which British crime drama on this list should I watch first?
Broadchurch is a strong first choice if you want an emotionally accessible mystery with a clear central case and a memorable detective pairing. Happy Valley is ideal if you prefer a fiercer, more character-driven story, while Unforgotten offers a patient cold-case format that resets with each season. The Fall is much darker and focuses on a serial investigation, so it suits viewers comfortable with disturbing subject matter. All four are distinctly different in pace and tone, despite sharing British settings.
What is the best short crime series for a weekend binge?
The Night Of is an eight-part miniseries, while Mare of Easttown is a single-season story that can also be watched over a few evenings. The Stranger has eight episodes and a faster, twist-led style. For a Nordic noir option, the first season of The Chestnut Man is a compact six-episode mystery. Check the current UK streaming listings before starting, as services and season availability change; the links in the article point to catalogue pages that can help confirm where each show is available.
Is The Chestnut Man a standalone series?
The Chestnut Man is based on Søren Sveistrup’s crime novel and follows detectives investigating murders linked to a distinctive chestnut figure and an older missing-child case. It began as a six-episode series, and a follow-up season is now listed in current streaming catalogues. The seasons expand the story with new investigations, so you can begin with the first season and then continue if you want more of the detectives’ world. Expect a grim Nordic crime drama rather than a cosy puzzle.
Does The Night Manager have a second season?
Yes. The Night Manager has continued beyond its original 2016 season, and current UK listings show a second season. The first season adapts John le Carré’s novel and introduces Jonathan Pine’s undercover mission against arms dealer Richard Roper. It is best to start there to understand Pine’s history and relationships before moving to the later story. The series is a spy thriller rather than a conventional detective show, with a glossy international style and a focus on infiltration, loyalty and danger.
Are the seasons of True Detective connected?
True Detective is an anthology series: its seasons feature different cases, locations and main casts. That means viewers can generally start with the season that appeals to them, although the fourth season includes connections to earlier material. Season one is the most widely recognised entry point and follows Louisiana detectives Rust Cohle and Marty Hart across two timelines. The show’s overall tone is dark and atmospheric, but the specific mystery and style vary considerably from one season to another.
Which shows on the list are cold-case mysteries?
Unforgotten is the clearest cold-case procedural: each season begins with newly discovered remains and follows detectives as they identify the victim and revisit the lives connected to the case. Dept. Q also centres on reopened investigations, while The Missing explores disappearances and their effects over time. The Chestnut Man connects a current murder investigation to an older missing-child case. Each approaches the past differently, from patient interviews to darker serial-crime plotting.
Is Mare of Easttown based on a true story?
Mare of Easttown is a fictional crime drama. Its small-town setting, regional speech and family relationships give it a grounded feel, but Mare Sheehan and the central murder investigation are invented. The series uses that realism to explore how a detective’s work intersects with community expectations, family grief and unresolved local cases. Kate Winslet’s performance and the ensemble’s lived-in characters are major reasons the show feels convincing without being a documentary or a direct retelling of a real case.
Which crime show is the darkest on this list?
The Fall is among the darkest entries because it follows a serial investigation and gives viewers access to the killer’s private life. The Chestnut Man is also bleak and graphic, while The Night Of examines the severe consequences of incarceration and accusation. Happy Valley deals with painful family history and violence but balances its severity with sharp humour and warmth. If you want a gentler mystery, try a different list or choose a less graphic title; these are crime dramas, not all-purpose comfort viewing.
Where can I check which of these shows are streaming in the UK?
Streaming rights change often, and availability can differ by season. The article includes a UK JustWatch page beside most entries so you can check the latest services, rental options and season listings before watching. Official platforms such as Netflix, Apple TV, ITVX and BBC iPlayer also show current catalogue availability directly. If a show is not currently included with a subscription, it may still be available to buy digitally or may return later; check the exact season rather than relying on an old listing.
More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows
For official series details and streaming access, start with the platforms themselves: Netflix’s page for The Stranger, Apple TV’s Slow Horses page, and ITVX’s Broadchurch page. For UK catalogue checks across services, use JustWatch UK’s TV guide.
For more coverage, explore the entertainment sections at The Guardian and Radio Times; both publish reviews, interviews and television recommendations.
Enjoyed What You Read?
Subscribe to That Love Podcast’s newsletter for the latest articles, entertainment recommendations, and podcast updates.
If you know someone who loves movies, television, books, or pop culture, share the article with them too. Let’s spread the love together!
