Charlie Vickers as Sauron in The Rings of Power Season 3.
|

10 Biggest Changes Between The Rings of Power Season 3 and Tolkien’s Books

Spoiler warning: This article compares major developments through Season 3 Episode 6 with Tolkien’s published books and related writings. It does not cover Episodes 7–8, which have not yet aired.

The Rings of Power adapts Middle-earth’s Second Age, a period Tolkien sketched across The Lord of the Rings appendices, The Silmarillion and posthumously published materials such as Unfinished Tales. Those sources do not form one complete television-ready chronicle. Some events are described briefly, some characters appear only in a few lines, and some of Tolkien’s working notes offer differing versions of a character’s movements or history. That creates room for the series to invent, compress and connect storylines—but it also makes it important to say precisely what has changed.

Season 3 makes those choices especially visible. The show places Gandalf in the Second Age, gives Galadriel a prolonged psychological connection with Sauron, introduces an Orc named Marnûkh, and imagines a family challenge between Durin IV and Thráin. Other changes develop gaps rather than contradicting a detailed account: Khamûl has a known later identity but little personal history, while Tolkien’s Blue Wizards are described in incomplete and sometimes varying ways. Númenor’s long timeline also has to be compressed for a continuous cast and serial drama.

This ranking distinguishes outright inventions, expansions of sparse source material and changes that reorganise chronology. It focuses on Episodes 1–6, available by 21 November 2026. Some descriptions refer to material outside The Lord of the Rings itself, including the appendices and posthumous texts, because those are essential to the Second Age. For the show’s version of events, consult Amazon’s official Season 3 guide and the Prime Video episode summaries.

The aim is not to declare every adaptation choice a mistake. A television series has different limits and priorities from a collection of appendices, histories and drafts. The useful distinction is whether Tolkien directly established an event, left space for interpretation, or did not write that specific character or relationship at all. Our Season 3 review looks at how the changes work on screen; this guide explains how they relate to the source material.

If you enjoy fantasy and book-to-screen coverage, support That Love Podcast on Ko-fi, explore our audio drama episodes or find advertising information.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an affiliate link. That Love Podcast may earn a commission if you use it, at no extra cost to you. Explore Amazon Prime Video.

You May Also Like

10. Marnûkh Is an Original Character Created for the Series

Adam Young as Marnûkh, an Orc warrior, in The Rings of Power Season 3.

Marnûkh is a Season 3 creation rather than a character drawn from Tolkien’s published narratives. Adam Young plays the Orc who becomes an uneasy guide for Galadriel and Arondir as they travel toward Gundabad. The series gives him a history, relationships and a position inside Sauron’s shifting hierarchy, allowing the story to ask what an Orc might choose when the power above him threatens the people he knows. That premise belongs to the television adaptation, not to a named figure in The Lord of the Rings appendices, The Silmarillion or Unfinished Tales.

It is important to distinguish an original character from an adaptation of an open question. Tolkien wrote about Orcs as a people but left major debates about their origins and moral status unresolved across drafts. That does not mean Marnûkh’s specific personality or mission is secretly present in the books. The show has created this individual to carry a story about fear, loyalty and resistance. His alliance with the Elves therefore changes the screen narrative without rewriting a named character’s established biography.

The choice gives the series room to explore a point of view that is difficult to access in the source material. Marnûkh is not automatically a hero because he opposes Sauron at a particular moment, and the show does not make the history of violence disappear. Instead, it gives the audience a character whose motives remain under pressure. Sauron’s later capture and interrogation underline that his freedom is limited. This is an outright invention in the sense that the specific character and plot are new, while the wider questions about Orcs draw on uncertainties within Tolkien’s changing writings.

9. Thráin’s Relationship to Durin IV Is Reimagined

Eddie Marsan as Thráin, a red-bearded dwarf in armor, in The Rings of Power Season 3.

Season 3 presents Thráin as Durin IV’s older brother and a rival claimant to the throne of Khazad-dûm. Their conflict is a major invention in the show’s Second Age storyline. Tolkien’s histories include several Dwarves named Durin and Thráin, but the series’ specific family relationship, return and struggle over the throne are not a scene lifted from a detailed account of these events. The name may sound familiar to readers of later Dwarven history, but that familiarity should not be mistaken for the same individual or the same chronology.

The show uses the brother relationship to make the politics of Khazad-dûm immediate. A claim to rule becomes a source of emotional conflict between people who have a shared past, and the Dwarven Rings give the struggle a supernatural pressure that can affect judgement. Thráin’s victory over Durin and his increasingly ruthless search for the Seven create consequences for Disa and the children as well as for the kingdom. Those family details are part of the television version’s effort to connect dynastic change with the cost to ordinary people inside the royal household.

This is a clear adaptation invention, not simply a gap filled from an obscure chapter. The wider legendarium gives the writers names, lineages and a Second Age setting, but the detailed brother-versus-brother crisis belongs to the series. That distinction does not automatically make the change a problem; it identifies what the adaptation is doing. The question for viewers is whether the invented relationship helps express the themes of inheritance and corruption in a way that feels coherent within the show.

8. The Series Expands Khamûl’s Personal History

Zubin Varla as Khamûl in dark armor stands before a blazing fire in The Rings of Power Season 3.

Tolkien identifies Khamûl as one of the Nazgûl and gives him a place among the servants of Sauron, but offers little personal history compared with the major figures in The Lord of the Rings. Season 3 moves that name earlier in the narrative and imagines Khamûl as an Easterling leader in Rhûn, with political standing and relationships that can be explored before his eventual transformation is complete. The show’s Ring storyline asks how a person with authority might respond to the promise of greater power and what it costs to accept it.

That is an expansion of a gap rather than a direct contradiction of a detailed biography. Tolkien’s texts do not offer a full account of Khamûl’s life before he became a Ringwraith, so the series has considerable space to invent. The name and broad eventual role come from the books; the specific political life shown on screen does not. Through Episode 6, the viewer sees the character connected to a Ring and to Sauron’s plans, but the series has not yet depicted every stage of his transformation.

The change is potentially one of the season’s most fruitful because it turns a name from a later story into a developing person. The series can build suspense around how Khamûl’s choices narrow, rather than introducing him only as a finished servant. At the same time, the article should not claim Tolkien confirms the show’s version of his earlier life. The adaptation is using a sparsely documented figure as a point of invention, and later episodes may define more of the path from Easterling leader to Nazgûl.

Explore Prime Video through our affiliate link.

7. Pallando and the Dark Wizard Reframe the Blue Wizards

Ciarán Hinds as the Dark Wizard seated on a carved stone throne in The Rings of Power.

The show’s Dark Wizard storyline brings Gandalf into conflict with a figure identified in season coverage as Pallando, one of the Blue Wizards. Tolkien’s writings about the Blue Wizards are notably incomplete and changed over time. In the better-known published accounts, Alatar and Pallando travel into the East and their fate is left largely unknown to the West. Later material offers more possibilities, including different ideas about their purpose and whether they succeeded or failed. That uncertainty gives an adaptation room to create a specific conflict, but it does not mean Tolkien wrote this exact rivalry with Gandalf.

Season 3 makes the East a visible stage for the Blue Wizard’s choices. Pallando has influence over people in Rhûn, and Gandalf’s attempt to keep the region from falling under Sauron’s power becomes a personal confrontation as well as a political mission. The television narrative gives Pallando an immediate relationship to the Dark Lord’s war and to the people who may be pulled into it. Tolkien’s texts do not provide a complete episode-by-episode account of the Blue Wizards, so the show’s actions and loyalties are largely its own construction.

The careful description is that the series develops an underwritten part of the legendarium, while making a significant invention in the process. It is not accurate to say Tolkien gave no account of the Blue Wizards; he did, but the accounts are fragmentary and not entirely consistent. Nor should viewers assume that the show’s Pallando is simply a book character whose screen plot was already established. The series is choosing one path through a deliberately open corner of Middle-earth’s history.

6. Disa’s Role in Dwarven Politics Is an Original Addition

Sophia Nomvete as Disa grips Owain Arthur as Durin IV while they stand in a dimly lit Dwarven hall.

Disa, played by Sophia Nomvete, is a television-original character. Tolkien’s published histories do not name Durin IV’s wife or provide a detailed account of a queen or royal partner acting in the political life of Khazad-dûm in this period. The show adds Disa as a stone-singer, a partner to Durin and a mother whose choices affect the kingdom’s future. Her ability to hear the mountain gives the series a distinctive way to dramatise Dwarven knowledge and turns the landscape itself into part of the political story.

Season 3 makes that role especially consequential. With Thráin in control of Khazad-dûm and seeking the Seven Rings, Disa’s knowledge and family position become important to the struggle. She must decide whether helping Thráin locate the Rings will protect the children or deepen the threat to them. Her scenes are not only domestic interludes; they place her in the middle of a succession crisis and make her expertise a resource that rulers try to command.

This is an outright invention of a named character and her particular skill, though it draws on the broader world of Dwarven culture and the series’ interpretation of the people who live under the mountains. Disa gives the show a perspective not supplied by Tolkien’s sparse accounts of Durin’s reign. Her role also makes the cost of political and magical power visible at home. The change works as an adaptation choice when the audience can see how her character contributes to the story rather than treating her as an unexplained addition.

5. Elendil’s Political and Family Story Is Expanded

Lloyd Owen as Elendil in The Rings of Power.

Elendil is an established figure in Tolkien’s Second Age history, but the series adds many details to his life before the fall of Númenor. Tolkien’s broad account identifies him as a leader of the Faithful, father of Isildur and Anárion, and a central figure in the events that follow the Downfall. The show fills in the political pressures that lead toward those outcomes and gives his family more on-screen history. Eärien, his daughter in the series, is a television invention; Anárion is part of the source family history but receives far less narrative detail in the texts.

Season 3 makes the expansion especially clear through the conflict with Pharazôn’s regime. Elendil investigates a suspected spy, is lured into a trap and captured by Kemen’s forces. His conversation with Kemen adds personal history and a moral appeal that are not laid out in Tolkien’s narrative in this form. The show also uses Eärien and Anárion to give the Faithful a household perspective: their choices can involve intelligence work, dissent and danger inside the same family.

This entry is a mix of adaptation and elaboration. Elendil’s role in Númenor’s history is not invented, but the exact investigations, relationships and scenes are. The distinction matters because the series is working from a compressed history and a limited set of source details. It can add family drama around an established figure, but the added material should not be presented as though it were a passage Tolkien wrote.

4. Númenor’s Timeline Is Compressed for Television

A wide view of Númenor’s white stone city rising above a green cliffside in The Rings of Power.

Tolkien’s Second Age stretches across thousands of years, with Númenor’s kings and political changes separated by long periods. A television drama following a continuous cast cannot reproduce that chronology literally without repeatedly replacing characters or leaping across generations. The Rings of Power therefore compresses events and brings figures and developments into a more tightly connected narrative. Season 3’s five-year time jump is only one visible example; the broader series has already reorganised the distance between major events so that separate historical threads can interact on screen.

The compression changes the meaning of political events. In Tolkien’s chronology, the rise of Númenor, the history of the Rings and the final conflict with Sauron occur across a long span. The show brings the audience closer to the characters’ decisions by making those changes part of a more immediate dramatic arc. That can strengthen emotional continuity, but it also means that the ages and generations of the source are not being represented one-to-one. Viewers should distinguish a chronological adjustment from an invention of the underlying historical event.

This is a structural adaptation choice rather than a single scene-level divergence. It allows the writers to keep the same characters present as the political landscape shifts, and it makes the series easier to follow as a multi-season story. The trade-off is that the scale of time in Tolkien’s world can feel smaller. For comparisons, use the Tale of Years and the Second Age material as a guide to the source chronology, while remembering that Tolkien’s own manuscripts sometimes contain differing versions of the past.

Explore Prime Video through our affiliate link.

You May Also Like

3. Gandalf Appears in the Second Age

Daniel Weyman as Gandalf in The Rings of Power Season 3.

The series places Gandalf in the Second Age and gives him a journey through Rhûn while Sauron is forging the One Ring. In the familiar published account in The Lord of the Rings appendices, the Istari arrive in Middle-earth in the Third Age, long after the One Ring has been made and lost. Gandalf’s presence in Season 3 therefore changes the chronology of a recognisable character. The show is not merely filling in an undocumented meeting; it is moving his activities to an earlier age than the standard account describes.

The adaptation uses that change to make Gandalf a participant in the Second Age conflict. His encounter with Pallando and his attempt to prevent Rhûn from joining Sauron’s campaign give the character a role in events that the books leave to other peoples and powers. Prime Video’s version can bring a familiar wizard into the story for audience continuity, while using the Blue Wizards to anchor the Eastern setting. That creates a substantial difference in timeline and function.

It ranks third because the change is easy to identify against the familiar chronology, even though the exact histories of the Blue Wizards remain less complete. Tolkien’s texts do not provide a full account of what every wizard did in the East, but the published arrival of the Istari is placed in the Third Age. The series’ Gandalf is therefore a clear example of an adaptation choice that goes beyond filling a blank. The article should acknowledge that some later notes complicate wizard histories, without obscuring the central timeline difference.

2. Galadriel and Celeborn’s Long Separation Is a Major Invention

Jamie Campbell Bower as Celeborn in The Rings of Power Season 3.

Galadriel and Celeborn’s marriage is part of Tolkien’s history, but the series builds a prolonged disappearance and captivity around Celeborn. The show has Galadriel believe that he was lost in the First Age, then reveals that he survived and has been held for centuries. Tolkien’s writings about the couple’s movements in the Second Age vary across drafts and posthumously assembled texts; in some accounts they live apart for periods or travel to different realms. But the specific story of Celeborn vanishing in battle, being imprisoned at Gundabad and reuniting with Galadriel in this dramatic form is not established in the source material.

The television version uses the separation to give Galadriel a private loss that can return during the war against Sauron. Season 3’s flashback to their courtship changes how viewers understand her present, while the reunion makes a personal relationship part of the main plot. The show also gives Celeborn information about the making of the Rings and uses his captivity as a means for Sauron to exploit their bond. These choices connect romance, trauma and the central One Ring story.

This is best described as a major invention built around a source relationship whose history is not consistent in every Tolkien manuscript. It would be too strong to say Tolkien’s texts present the couple as inseparable in every version; their movements and residences differ across accounts. It is accurate, however, to say that the show’s long presumed death, captivity and reunion are not a direct retelling of a known Tolkien episode. The series is creating dramatic space from an unevenly documented history.

1. Galadriel’s Relationship With Sauron Takes a New Form

Galadriel faces Sauron in a battlefield confrontation in The Rings of Power Season 3.

The show gives Galadriel and Sauron a sustained psychological connection that shapes her personal story. Their interactions in earlier seasons create an intimacy and emotional charge that Season 3 continues through visions, disguises and Sauron’s attempts to influence her decisions. In Episodes 1–6, that history becomes especially unsettling when Galadriel sees Sauron where she expects to see Celeborn. The series uses the image to show how the Dark Lord can turn memory and desire into tools, making his power feel invasive even when he is not physically present.

Tolkien’s account does not present a comparable personal or romantic relationship between Galadriel and Sauron. In the Second Age material, Sauron appears as Annatar among the Elves and helps Celebrimbor and the smiths of Eregion forge the Rings; Galadriel is associated with mistrust of him in relevant versions of the story. The precise details vary across Tolkien’s writings, but the show’s prolonged bond and psychological history are not in those texts. This is an adaptation invention rather than a missing scene from the books.

The change takes the top position because it affects how the series frames Galadriel’s character, Sauron’s methods and the emotional stakes of the One Ring plot. It also changes the audience’s experience of scenes that would otherwise be strategic encounters. That does not mean the show simply declares Sauron in love with Galadriel; the connection is manipulative, ambiguous and open to interpretation. The important contrast is that Tolkien’s texts do not establish this sustained interpersonal dynamic, while the television series makes it one of its defining story choices.

One point needs special care: Tolkien’s posthumous writings are not a single, perfectly consistent encyclopedia. Christopher Tolkien’s editorial work brings together drafts that sometimes disagree, and later texts can revise earlier ideas. That is why this article calls some details “uncertain” or “variant” instead of treating every popular timeline as a fixed canon. The series still makes clear choices—such as introducing a named Orc commander or placing Gandalf in the Second Age—but the comparison should respect where the source itself leaves room.

Season 3’s most consequential changes are the ones that alter the emotional architecture of the story. Galadriel’s bond with Sauron becomes a personal pressure point, while Celeborn’s return gives her marriage a new on-screen history. The inventions around Thráin, Disa and Marnûkh make the Second Age more intimate and character-led. Whether those choices work is a separate question from whether they are in Tolkien. Being precise about the difference lets readers assess both the adaptation and its source without confusing one for the other.

Readers can make the comparison more rewarding by keeping two questions separate: what is the show changing, and what dramatic purpose does that change serve? A compressed timeline may help a television ensemble stay present across events that originally span generations. An invented character may give the story a way to explore the lives of people Tolkien left at the edge of the surviving record. Neither explanation turns a new plot into book canon, but it helps show why an adaptation might choose it.

You May Also Like

For more Tolkien-inspired recommendations, visit our Fellowship of the Ring review or support That Love Podcast through Ko-fi. Join our newsletter for future book and screen coverage; a verified signup page was not available to link in this draft.

Affiliate disclosure: If you use this affiliate link, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Explore Prime Video.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Tolkien’s writing give one complete account of the Second Age?

No. The Second Age is described through the appendices to The Lord of the Rings, The Silmarillion and later-published materials such as Unfinished Tales. Those sources are not a single continuous novel, and Tolkien revised some histories over time. Adaptations therefore have to interpret gaps and sometimes choose among differing accounts.

Did Tolkien create Marnûkh?

No. Marnûkh is an original character for The Rings of Power. Tolkien wrote about Orcs and their role in Middle-earth, but this named Orc, his history and his mission with Galadriel and Arondir are television inventions.

Is Thráin Durin IV’s brother in Tolkien’s books?

The series presents Thráin as Durin IV’s older brother. That exact relationship and the resulting struggle for Khazad-dûm are part of the show’s adaptation, not an established episode in Tolkien’s Second Age narrative. Tolkien’s writings include several Dwarves with the names Durin and Thráin, which can create confusion across generations.

Did Tolkien write a detailed history of Khamûl?

Tolkien identifies Khamûl among the Nazgûl, but provides little detail about his earlier personal or political life. The Rings of Power’s depiction of him as an Easterling leader and his connection to a Ring expand that sparse record rather than adapt a complete biography.

Are the Blue Wizards’ histories certain?

No. Tolkien’s notes about the Blue Wizards are incomplete and include differing ideas about when they arrived and what they did in the East. The show’s Pallando storyline is one specific adaptation of that open material, not a complete account Tolkien supplied.

Was Disa created for The Rings of Power?

Yes. Disa is an original character created for the series. Tolkien does not provide a named wife of Durin IV with Disa’s role as a stone-singer and political figure. The character expands the television story around Khazad-dûm and its royal family.

Does Tolkien’s account include Galadriel and Celeborn separating?

Their movements and residences differ across Tolkien’s manuscripts, and some accounts place them in different locations for a time. The show’s specific story of Celeborn being presumed lost, held captive for centuries and reunited with Galadriel is not a direct retelling of an established episode.

Did Tolkien write that Gandalf came to Middle-earth in the Second Age?

The familiar published account places the Istari’s arrival in the Third Age, long after the One Ring was forged. Tolkien’s writings about the wizards developed over time, but the series’ Second Age Gandalf and his Rhûn storyline are a significant adaptation choice.

Did Tolkien connect Galadriel romantically with Sauron?

Tolkien’s writings do not establish the show’s sustained emotional or psychological relationship between Galadriel and Sauron. The Second Age material concerns Sauron’s deception as Annatar and the forging of the Rings; Galadriel is associated with mistrust of him in relevant accounts.

Is Season 3 a direct adaptation of The Silmarillion?

The series adapts Second Age material and draws from Tolkien’s writings, but it is not simply a scene-by-scene adaptation of The Silmarillion. The show uses its own characters, compressed chronology and invented relationships alongside events and names from the legendarium.

If you want to watch the adaptation, explore Prime Video through this affiliate link. A qualifying transaction may earn That Love Podcast a commission at no extra cost to you.

Similar Posts