Klaus (2019)
|

10 Overlooked Christmas Movies of the 2010s That Deserve to Be Rediscovered, Ranked

The 2010s were a particularly lively decade for Christmas films. Alongside glossy romances and family comedies, filmmakers tried quieter independent dramas, musical horror, literary biopics and fresh takes on the Santa legend. Some were overlooked because they arrived without a huge campaign; others were simply too unusual to fit the familiar holiday shelf. Revisiting them now reveals a decade with far more seasonal variety than the usual streaming carousel suggests.

This countdown brings together ten overlooked Christmas movies from 2010 to 2019 that deserve to be rediscovered. It moves from a lonely New York tree seller and an English village’s miracle candle to gospel musical drama, foul-mouthed stoner comedy, a zombie musical and an animated Santa origin story. Your order is preserved, with #10 opening and #1 closing the list. The ranking considers originality, performances, how well Christmas shapes the plot and whether each film stays with you after the decorations come down.

The tone changes from entry to entry, so this is not a single family-night watchlist. Get Santa and Klaus are accessible family adventures; Anna and the Apocalypse is a horror musical with adult content; A Very Harold & Kumar 3D Christmas is an explicitly adult comedy; and Christmas, Again is a quiet independent drama. The notes explain what kind of viewing experience each offers, so you can match a film to the right evening.

If you want more seasonal options from other decades, explore our 15 Best 90s Christmas Movies That Make the Holidays Feel Magical, Ranked and 15 Best Christmas Romantic Comedies of All Time. These lists include familiar favourites as well as films that sit outside the most repeated holiday classics. We have also noted UK availability only where a current listing was found, since streaming rights can change between seasons.

The best films here use the holiday as a real part of their story. A Christmas tree stand becomes a place for unexpected companionship; a community’s tradition is challenged by modern technology; a group of teenagers have to sing and fight their way to safety; and a postman’s selfish errand becomes a legend about generosity. That range makes the decade worth another look. Let’s get into it 👇

Support That Love Podcast

If you enjoy our entertainment coverage, you can help support That Love Podcast and keep independent articles and original audio stories coming. Donate to That Love Podcast. We also make original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories; explore the episodes.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. If you sign up or make a qualifying purchase through one of these links, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Try Amazon Prime.

10. Christmas, Again (2014)

Kentucker Audley as Noel standing among lit Christmas trees at the tree lot in Christmas, Again

Noel is a heartbroken Christmas-tree seller who returns to New York City and spends the season working from a small stand. He sells trees to strangers, sleeps in a trailer and tries to move past the relationship that has left him emotionally adrift. The plot is deliberately slight: customers arrive, the city moves around him and the holiday rush continues while Noel struggles to re-enter ordinary life. Small encounters begin to make the stand a place of companionship, even though he has not yet decided what he wants next.

Kentucker Audley plays Noel with a quiet, inward quality that gives the film room to notice gestures and silences. Charles Poekel’s 16mm photography makes the city feel close and cold, not like a glossy holiday postcard. The film’s pace is slow by design; its drama comes from the routines of seasonal work and the small warmth between people who might otherwise pass without speaking. It is a portrait of loneliness that does not insist on a dramatic cure.

It opens at #10 because its understated style and believable city atmosphere are distinctive, but the slow pace will not suit every Christmas-movie audience. Viewers who enjoy intimate independent films and stories about quiet recovery should consider it a strong late-night choice. People looking for jokes, romance or a big festive payoff may find it too slight. The film is a genuine rediscovery for those willing to settle into its rhythm.

Where to watch: UK streaming availability is unconfirmed; check a current rental guide. Film at Lincoln Center describes its wistful portrait of loneliness and companionship.

🎧 Need something to listen to after your binge? Discover original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories from That Love Podcast. Listen to That Love Podcast.

9. The Christmas Candle (2013)

Two villagers talking by candlelight in a cottage in The Christmas Candle

In a 19th-century English village, a new minister arrives with ideas about modern life, including the introduction of electricity. His plans put him at odds with residents who believe an angel touched a candle in a local shop and that whoever receives it will experience a Christmas miracle. As the village prepares for the holiday, the minister’s practical beliefs and the community’s tradition collide. The story asks whether faith should be measured by a miracle or by the everyday actions people take for one another.

Hans Matheson plays the minister as a thoughtful outsider, while the village ensemble gives the candle’s legend a range of responses—from deep belief to affectionate scepticism. The period setting and religious themes make the film feel closer to a parable than a romantic comedy. Its conflict between technology and tradition is simple but clear, and the candle gives the film a visual object around which the community can gather. The film is earnest and sometimes over-sincere, yet its village atmosphere is carefully built.

This ranks #9 because the premise is unusual and the village setting gives it an identity, while its moral and religious tone can feel too direct for viewers who prefer subtlety. It is best for audiences seeking a faith-centred Christmas drama or a slower period story. Those wanting a contemporary comedy will find other choices higher in the countdown. The official Angel Studios page explains the candle’s village legend.

Where to watch: UK streaming availability is not confirmed; check current digital rentals.

8. All Is Bright (2013)

Paul Giamatti and Paul Rudd selling Christmas trees on a New York street in All Is Bright

After Dennis is released from prison, he learns that his former partner Rene has built a life with Dennis’s ex-wife and daughter. The two men travel to New York to sell Christmas trees, hoping to earn enough money for Rene’s new piano business. Their tree stand brings them into contact with customers, rivals and the city’s holiday crowds, but the emotional tension between the former friends makes the work harder. Dennis must decide whether he wants to rebuild his own life or keep trying to prove that Rene owes him something.

Paul Giamatti and Paul Rudd play the men with a prickly chemistry that keeps the comedy from becoming cosy. The film’s Christmas trees are not magical props; they are inventory, cold-weather work and a difficult way to make money. That grounded perspective gives the story a rough, sometimes melancholy edge. Sally Hawkins adds a different register to the characters’ unsettled lives. The film is more interested in friendship, resentment and the compromises of starting over than in seasonal sentiment.

At #8, it earns its place for a fresh, unvarnished holiday setup and two strong lead performances, though its humour can be bleak and its characters are intentionally hard to like. It suits viewers who prefer indie comedy-dramas to polished Christmas romances. The ranking reflects its originality and the restraint of its storytelling, while the more emotionally expansive choices above it offer a warmer payoff. The UK title may also appear as Almost Christmas, so check both names in catalogues.

Where to watch: UK availability is not confirmed; check a current listing under both All Is Bright and its UK title, Almost Christmas.

Explore Amazon Prime for more seasonal viewing options.

7. Black Nativity (2013)

Black Nativity (2013)

Teenager Langston is sent from Baltimore to spend Christmas with his estranged relatives, Reverend Cornell and Aretha Cobbs, in New York. His mother hopes the visit will provide support, but Langston feels out of place in the church household and wants to return home. As he learns more about the family’s history, the holiday gathering becomes a chance to confront old wounds and discover the value of a community he had rejected. The story adapts Langston Hughes’ stage play and frames family reconciliation through gospel music and a contemporary city setting.

Kasi Lemmons stages the musical numbers as part of the story’s emotional language, with Forest Whitaker, Angela Bassett, Jennifer Hudson and Mary J. Blige anchoring the ensemble. Jacob Latimore gives Langston the guarded energy of a teenager who does not want adults making decisions for him. The film’s songs provide lift, but the family conflict keeps it from being only a concert of holiday standards. It may feel uneven when the dramatic and musical parts compete, yet the performances give the material conviction.

It sits at #7 because the musical approach is distinctive and the family story has real feeling, while the adaptation’s transitions do not always flow smoothly. Viewers who enjoy gospel, musical drama and stories about estranged families should be the first to try it. It is less suited to anyone who wants a secular, light comedy. Searchlight’s official film page and the 20th Century Studios archive provide production details.

Where to watch: UK availability is unconfirmed; check digital rental listings.

You May Also Like

Keep exploring with these published winter and holiday movie guides from That Love Podcast.

10 Cozy British Movies for Winter Nights, Ranked
10 Netflix Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 Hulu Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 Peacock Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 Apple TV Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 NOW Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic

🎧 Taking a break from the screen? Listen to original romance, comedy and drama stories from That Love Podcast. Explore the latest episodes.

6. A Very Harold & Kumar 3D Christmas (2011)

John Cho and Kal Penn as Harold and Kumar in a lift with friends and a baby in A Very Harold & Kumar 3D Christmas

Years after their previous adventure, Harold and Kumar are living separate lives when Kumar receives a mysterious package at his apartment. His attempt to deliver it to Harold ends with the destruction of Harold’s father-in-law’s prized Christmas tree. The two friends have to find a replacement before the family celebration, sending them into a night of outrageous mishaps, drug-fuelled comedy and 3D spectacle. The holiday deadline forces the old friends back into each other’s orbit, even though their adult lives have pulled them in different directions.

John Cho and Kal Penn still have the easy friendship that made the earlier films work, and the Christmas setting gives their reunion a useful time limit. The jokes are deliberately crude and surreal, with the film using 3D effects as part of the gag rather than merely a technical gimmick. Neil Patrick Harris returns as an exaggerated version of himself, adding another layer of celebrity absurdity. This is emphatically an adult comedy, not a family holiday film, and its humour has a narrow target audience.

It ranks #6 because it commits to its outrageous premise and makes the friendship matter beneath the shock comedy. It sits below the top five because the humour is intentionally explicit and the story has less emotional range than the strongest entries. Fans of the franchise, stoner comedies and unrestrained holiday chaos will likely enjoy it; viewers wanting cosy Christmas sentiment should look elsewhere. The cast and premise are summarised by Danny Trejo’s project page.

Where to watch: UK streaming availability is not confirmed; check current rentals.

5. Almost Christmas (2016)

Almost Christmas (2016)

Walter Meyer is grieving the death of his wife when he invites his adult children and extended family home for Christmas. His request is simple: spend five days together without tearing one another apart. The relatives arrive with romantic troubles, money concerns, resentments and habits that test the family’s patience. Walter wants the gathering to honour his wife’s memory, but the siblings have to decide whether they can stop competing long enough to be present for one another. The holiday meal becomes the centre of a family comedy-drama about grief and staying connected.

Danny Glover gives Walter a gentle authority, while the ensemble—including Gabrielle Union, Kimberly Elise, Romany Malco and Mo’Nique—fills the house with lively, contrasting personalities. The comedy comes from the friction of people who love one another but know exactly how to irritate one another. Its broadest moments can be loud, yet the film’s emotional centre is more tender than its title’s farce suggests. The family’s grief is not instantly resolved; instead, it shapes why the gathering matters.

This earns #5 for its ensemble warmth and a clear emotional stake, though some of the family storylines feel familiar. It is a good group-watch choice for viewers who like big family reunions, sibling tension and comedy with a sentimental finish. It ranks below the top four because its episodic subplots do not always receive equal attention. Universal’s official page describes Walter’s wish for family harmony.

Where to watch: NOW currently lists the film in the UK; confirm its current availability.

4. Get Santa (2014)

Get Santa (2014)

Young Tom discovers that Santa’s sleigh has crashed and that Santa himself is hiding in the family shed. Tom asks his father Steve for help, but Steve has recently been released from prison and is trying to rebuild his life and relationship with his son. Santa is arrested after a chaotic attempt to get back to Lapland, so Tom and Steve have to help him escape and deliver presents. Their rescue mission becomes an unexpected chance for Steve to show Tom that he can be trusted.

Jim Broadbent gives Santa a warm comic presence, while Rafe Spall plays Steve as a father whose love is real but whose reliability has to be earned. The film’s British locations and everyday details keep its fantasy grounded. The adventure moves between police, prison and family life, making Santa’s crisis part of a larger story about responsibility. Its jokes are broad, but the father-son connection gives the film more heart than a simple chase to save Christmas.

At #4, it is a strong family pick with a clear adventure engine and one of the countdown’s most effective parent-child stories. It ranks just below the top three because its plot is more conventional than the films above it, and some comic set pieces are broad. Families with younger children and viewers who like British Christmas comedy should put it high on the list. The British Council’s film database entry verifies the film’s release and premise.

Where to watch: Netflix UK currently lists Get Santa; check the catalogue before watching.

3. The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017)

The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017)

In 1843, Charles Dickens is struggling financially after several books fail to sell well. With debts mounting and a family to support, he decides to write a new Christmas story in a matter of weeks. As he develops A Christmas Carol, the characters appear in his imagination and begin to shape the writing process. Dickens draws on memories, people he meets and the pressures of Victorian London to create Scrooge, Tiny Tim and the rest of the story’s world. His task is both artistic and practical: finish a book that can restore his fortunes.

Dan Stevens plays Dickens as imaginative, anxious and sometimes self-involved, while Christopher Plummer gives Scrooge a vivid presence inside the writer’s mind. The film turns drafting into visual action, making the characters feel like companions and critics. Its fictionalised approach takes liberties with the creative process, but it makes literature accessible without pretending that inspiration arrives fully formed. The period sets and lively performance style balance the familiar story with a fresh point of view.

It reaches #3 because it is an entertaining companion to a Christmas classic and gives the act of writing a playful dramatic shape. It sits below the top two because its imaginative scenes are more charming than historically rigorous, and the plot depends on knowing the source story. Dickens readers, families with older children and viewers curious about A Christmas Carol should enjoy it. The British Council’s official UK films database page confirms the premise.

Where to watch: Netflix UK has listed the film; verify current availability.

🎧 Before we reveal our No. 1 pick, discover original romantic audio dramas from That Love Podcast. Listen here.

Watch more with Amazon Prime.

2. Anna and the Apocalypse (2017)

Ella Hunt as Anna walking down a wintry suburban street in Anna and the Apocalypse

At Christmas, Anna and her friends are preparing for the end of school and thinking about their futures when a zombie outbreak hits their town. Anna teams up with her best friend John and other classmates to fight through the chaos, find their loved ones and reach safety. The story combines high-school relationships, a zombie survival plot and musical numbers, so the characters are often singing while trying to get across town. Their personal disagreements do not disappear when the undead arrive; they become part of the group’s struggle to survive.

Ella Hunt gives Anna a lively determination, and the film’s songs turn the genre mash-up into more than a novelty. Its humour is dark, its violence can be bloody, and its musical sequences are staged with energetic precision. The high-school setting gives the characters a familiar coming-of-age dilemma just as the world becomes unfamiliar. The film is a true holiday horror musical, not a broadly suitable family option, and the mix works best for viewers happy to let comedy and horror share the same scene.

This takes #2 for its audacity, memorable songs and tightly defined point of view. It only loses the top position because the number of tonal shifts makes it less universally appealing than the winner’s animated fable. Horror fans, musical-comedy viewers and older teens who enjoy genre mash-ups should seek it out. Screen Scotland’s production page confirms the story and creative team.

Where to watch: UK streaming availability is not confirmed; the film has been carried by BFI Player, so check its current listing.

1. Klaus (2019)

Klaus (2019)

Jesper, a lazy postman, is sent to the remote northern town of Smeerensburg and told to establish a functioning postal service. The town’s feuding families make the assignment seem impossible. Jesper meets Klaus, a reclusive toymaker living beyond the settlement, and discovers that delivering the toys Klaus has made can bring children together. Their arrangement begins as a way for Jesper to meet his quota, but it grows into a friendship that changes the town and gives Klaus a reason to share his work. The story offers a new origin for the Santa legend without losing its human scale.

Jason Schwartzman voices Jesper as a selfish comic lead who has room to grow, while J.K. Simmons gives Klaus a quiet, generous presence. The hand-drawn animation has a tactile warmth, with light and shadow making Smeerensburg feel both cold and inviting. The film’s central friendship develops naturally, and the town’s transformation is earned through many small acts rather than one grand speech. Its visual style and emotional clarity make it equally satisfying for children and adults.

It deserves #1 because it combines an original Santa origin, strong character growth, precise humour and striking animation. Anna and the Apocalypse is more daring, but Klaus is more cohesive and easier to recommend across age groups. It turns generosity into something practical: each kind act gives the next person a reason to participate. Netflix’s official media centre page describes the film’s story and release.

Where to watch: Available on Netflix UK; verify the current title page.

Why These 2010s Christmas Movies Deserve to Be Rediscovered

The decade’s most interesting holiday films did not all try to make Christmas look perfect. Christmas, Again looks at the season through lonely work and quiet companionship; All Is Bright makes tree-selling a rough, funny job; Black Nativity uses music and family history to tell a story of belonging. At the other end of the spectrum, Anna and the Apocalypse takes the season into horror, while Klaus finds a new origin story in one postman’s unexpected friendship.

That variety matters when choosing a watch. If you want a film for the whole family, choose Klaus or Get Santa. For something musical, Black Nativity offers gospel and family drama, while Anna and the Apocalypse pairs songs with zombies and should be treated as an adult genre film. Christmas, Again is the best fit for a quiet, independent-film mood. Each title gives Christmas a different job in the story.

The top-ranked film wins because it makes a familiar legend feel newly human. Klaus has the visual invention and strong character change to reward children on first viewing and adults on a repeat watch. Its story of generosity is not just a moral at the end; it is the action that changes the town, one delivery at a time. That blend of warmth, craft and accessibility makes it the most complete recommendation in this decade’s group.

You May Also Like

10 BBC iPlayer Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 ITVX Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic
10 Cozy Self-Care Movies for Winter Nights, Ranked
Amazon Prime Holiday Guide: Movies, Shopping and Membership Benefits
10 Ways Amazon Prime Can Help With Last-Minute Christmas Shopping
10 Best British Sitcom Christmas Specials of All Time, Ranked

If you enjoyed the countdown, support That Love Podcast or listen to our original audio stories.

More Holiday Reading

10 Best Friends Christmas Episodes, Ranked
Sufjan Stevens’ Worst Christmas Ever! Review
Christmas Staycation by Meghan Quinn Book Review
A Married Little Christmas by Abby Jimenez Book Review

Explore Amazon Prime.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best overlooked Christmas movie from the 2010s?

Klaus is the strongest overall pick for its original Santa story, expressive animation and satisfying character growth. If you want an adult genre film, Anna and the Apocalypse is a bold musical-horror option. For a quieter independent drama, try Christmas, Again.

Is Klaus available on Netflix UK?

Netflix UK has a title page for Klaus, but catalogues can change. Check the service directly before watching. The animated film follows postman Jesper and reclusive toymaker Klaus as their partnership gradually brings kindness to a feuding northern town.

Is Anna and the Apocalypse suitable for children?

It is a zombie horror musical with violence and adult humour, so it is not a general family Christmas film. Check the current UK age rating and content guidance before watching with teenagers. Viewers seeking a more accessible family adventure from this list should consider Klaus or Get Santa.

What is Black Nativity about?

The film follows Langston, a teenager from Baltimore who travels to New York to spend Christmas with estranged relatives, Reverend Cornell and Aretha Cobbs. The visit brings family tensions to the surface, while gospel music and the holiday gathering create a path toward reconciliation. It is a contemporary musical adaptation of Langston Hughes’ play.

What happens in Christmas, Again?

A heartbroken Christmas-tree seller returns to New York City and works through the holiday season at a tree stand. The film focuses on his repetitive work, loneliness and small encounters with customers and passers-by. It is a quiet independent drama rather than a conventional festive comedy.

Is All Is Bright the same film as Almost Christmas?

No. All Is Bright is a 2013 indie comedy-drama about two French-Canadian men selling Christmas trees in New York. In the UK it has also been released under the title Almost Christmas. The 2016 film Almost Christmas is a separate family comedy about the Meyers family reunion.

What is the story of Get Santa?

A boy named Tom discovers that Santa has crashed his sleigh and asks his recently released father Steve to help. Santa is arrested, so Tom and Steve work to get him out and back to Lapland in time for Christmas. The adventure also gives Steve an opportunity to rebuild his relationship with his son.

Where can I stream these 2010s Christmas movies in the UK?

Streaming rights change, and a title page does not guarantee a film remains in a service’s catalogue. This article names current services only where a UK listing was checked. For the other films, use a current UK streaming guide or digital rental catalogue before subscribing.

Which film on this list is a Christmas musical?

Black Nativity is a gospel musical drama, and Anna and the Apocalypse is a musical horror comedy. They have very different audiences: the former centres family and faith, while the latter uses songs within a zombie outbreak and contains horror violence.

Why does Klaus rank above Anna and the Apocalypse?

Anna and the Apocalypse is daring and memorable, but its horror-musical style is more specialised. Klaus combines a fresh Santa origin, strong animation, humour and character growth in a story that works for a wider range of viewers. That balance makes it the top overall recommendation.

More Places to Find Great Movies and TV Shows

The BFI and Screen Scotland provide film listings, production context and curated recommendations. Official studio and distributor pages can confirm release information and synopses, while Netflix’s Media Center includes details about its original film catalogue.

Enjoyed this list? Share it with another movie fan, or discover That Love Podcast’s original romantic audio dramas, comedies and stories.

Try Amazon Prime.

Similar Posts