Paul Giamatti, Dominic Sessa and Da'Vine Joy Randolph at the dinner table in The Holdovers
|

10 Christmas Movies of the 2020s That Deserve to Become Holiday Classics, Ranked

Christmas films need only a few minutes to announce their intentions: a twinkling street, a familiar carol, a family travelling home, or a lonely person discovering that the season has quietly changed their plans. The best ones do something more lasting. They create characters and rituals that viewers want to revisit after the decorations are packed away. The 2020s have already produced a varied group of candidates, from animated fables and contemporary romances to a sharply funny boarding-school drama. This ranking considers which films have the strongest chance of becoming annual favourites, rather than simply which had the biggest launch.

Our countdown weighs rewatchability, emotional staying power, memorable performances, visual identity and how naturally Christmas belongs to each story. A film can be bittersweet and still feel festive; it can also be a family movie without talking down to adults. The selections are ranked from promising to most likely to endure. That means a beautiful new release can sit below a film that has already demonstrated how easily it invites a yearly return. For older seasonal favourites, see 15 Best 90s Christmas Movies That Make the Holidays Feel Magical, Ranked and our broader guide to Best Christmas Romantic Comedies of All Time.

Some of these titles are warm comfort watches; others work because they complicate the season. The list includes romance, comedy, adventure, animation and a deliberately unsentimental look at loneliness. Their availability moves between services and regions, so check local listings before planning a watch night. For more cold-weather picks, explore 10 Cozy British Movies for Winter Nights, Ranked and our guide to 10 Cozy Self-Care Movies for Winter Nights, Ranked.

The order is not a claim that every viewer should love the same kind of Christmas film. It is an editorial ranking of the strongest combination of craft, seasonal atmosphere and long-term repeat appeal. A classic is made by the relationship audiences build with it: the jokes they remember, the scenes they anticipate, and the feelings that still arrive on a second or tenth viewing.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an Amazon affiliate link. If you join Prime through it, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Explore Amazon Prime.

10. The Noel Diary (2022)

The Noel Diary (2022)

The Noel Diary begins with a homecoming rather than a party. Best-selling novelist Jake Turner returns to his childhood house at Christmas to settle his estranged mother’s estate. While sorting through the rooms and possessions left behind, he finds a diary that may illuminate both his own past and the life of Rachel, a woman searching for answers about her birth mother. Their intertwined investigation gives the film a mystery to follow, while the snowbound setting and gradual romance keep it within the familiar territory of a holiday drama.

Justin Hartley plays Jake as a man whose professional success has not repaired the emotional distance in his family. Barrett Doss brings Rachel a directness that keeps her from becoming merely a catalyst for his self-discovery. The film’s best scenes let the two characters compare incomplete memories and decide how much truth they are ready to hear. That makes its Christmas setting feel emotionally relevant: the holiday is a time when old family stories resurface, sometimes in inconvenient ways.

It ranks tenth because it is more polished and affecting than distinctive. Its plot turns are easy to anticipate, and its romantic beats follow a familiar streaming-era pattern. Yet the diary device adds an appealing thread of discovery, and the film is gentle enough for viewers who want their seasonal melancholy softened by a hopeful ending. It is a good choice for a quiet evening when you want romance, family history and snowy scenery without a high-comedy pace. The film has the makings of a comfort watch, though it needs a few more years of audience attachment before it can claim classic status.

9. Single All the Way (2021)

Michael Urie as Peter with Jennifer Coolidge as Aunt Sandy in Single All the Way

Single All the Way sends Peter home for Christmas with a problem familiar to many romantic comedies: his family is already planning his romantic future. He persuades his best friend Nick to pose as his boyfriend, hoping to avoid another round of matchmaking. The arrangement becomes complicated when Peter’s mother sets him up with someone else, and the charade forces both friends to consider what they have been avoiding. The film uses the fake-dating setup as a route into friendship, family pressure and the vulnerability of admitting that a long-standing bond may have changed.

Michael Urie gives Peter an energetic, expressive centre, while Philemon Chambers plays Nick with a quieter warmth. Kathy Najimy and Jennifer Coolidge supply much of the broad comedy as members of a family who mean well but do not always understand the effect of their enthusiasm. The comedy is intentionally heightened: family games, matchmaking schemes and Christmas decorations all contribute to a cheerful, almost storybook atmosphere. Its romantic arc is not meant to surprise so much as to make the inevitable feel earned through the characters’ familiarity.

This lands at nine because its charm is immediate but its construction is conventional. The film is significant as a mainstream holiday romance centred on a gay couple, and its open-hearted approach gives it a welcome place in the seasonal rotation. It is best for viewers who want a cosy, low-stress story with an affectionate chosen-family message. The movie could become a durable annual favourite if audiences keep returning to its ensemble and lightness; its central fake-dating premise, however, is less singular than the strongest entries here.

8. Something from Tiffany’s (2022)

Something from Tiffany’s holiday romantic comedy

In Something from Tiffany’s, an engagement ring intended for one person ends up with another, setting two couples on intersecting paths through New York at Christmas. Rachel, a bakery owner, receives the ring after an accident involving the gift bags of strangers. The mix-up brings her closer to Ethan, the man who bought it for his girlfriend, while the original couple’s expectations begin to shift. The premise is classic screwball-romance machinery: a small mistake creates an opening for characters to question whether the life they planned is the life they want.

Zoey Deutch gives Rachel a grounded sweetness that balances the movie’s polished holiday gloss. Kendrick Sampson’s Ethan is appealingly earnest, and the New York setting supplies shop windows, city streets and the recognisable bustle of December without making the film feel like a travel advert. The jewellery-store inciting incident gives the story a neat visual symbol for mistaken assumptions: people can hold the right object and still be pursuing the wrong relationship.

It ranks eighth because the film understands the pleasures of a seasonal romantic comedy even when its plot relies on coincidence. The mix-up is contrived, but the characters’ eventual choices are more important than the accident itself. This is a strong pick for viewers who want contemporary romance, attractive city locations and a happy ending rather than a complicated emotional challenge. It has annual-watch potential for fans of glossy comfort movies, though it shares enough DNA with many holiday romances that it must depend on its cast and setting to stand apart.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an Amazon affiliate link. If you join Prime through it, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Explore Amazon Prime.

7. Happiest Season (2020)

Kristen Stewart and Mackenzie Davis in Happiest Season

Happiest Season turns a Christmas visit into a test of honesty. Abby intends to propose to her girlfriend Harper during Harper’s family holiday gathering, only to discover that Harper has not come out to her conservative parents. The couple must navigate the pressure of presenting a relationship as a friendship, while Harper’s family moves through its own competitions, secrets and carefully maintained image. The central conflict gives this romantic comedy a sharper edge than a simple misunderstanding: the question is not whether Abby and Harper care for each other, but what concealment costs them.

Kristen Stewart and Mackenzie Davis create a couple with genuine affection and genuine friction. Their chemistry matters because the film does not treat love as a solution that instantly erases fear. The large ensemble, including Dan Levy, Alison Brie, Aubrey Plaza and Mary Steenburgen, brings different comic energies to the family gathering. Some of the broadest jokes land unevenly, but the social choreography of a holiday visit—who gets believed, who is invited into the family story, and who is asked to wait—gives the film more to discuss than its festive surface suggests.

At seven, it is one of the list’s most emotionally specific titles. Its conflict may be painful for viewers who recognise the pressure to hide a relationship, and its resolution is more complicated than a universal fantasy of instant acceptance. That complexity is also its strength. It is a worthwhile annual choice for people who want a modern queer Christmas romance that can prompt conversation as well as deliver jokes. Its place in the holiday canon will depend on audiences valuing that mix of warmth, discomfort and family messiness.

For other seasonal viewing ideas across services, browse 10 Netflix Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic, 10 Hulu Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic, 10 Peacock Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic, 10 Apple TV Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic and 10 NOW Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic.

6. 8-Bit Christmas (2021)

Neil Patrick Harris as adult Jake with his daughter at the family table in 8-Bit Christmas

8-Bit Christmas is framed as an adult Jake telling his daughter about his childhood quest for the video-game system every kid wanted in 1980s Chicago. Young Jake and his friends pursue the Nintendo Entertainment System through increasingly elaborate schemes, while parents try to preserve the season’s meaning beyond the year’s must-have present. The framing device gives the story a useful double perspective: the child remembers the Christmas as a high-stakes adventure, while the parent understands how the obsession looked to the adults around him.

Neil Patrick Harris narrates with a knowing affection that keeps the nostalgia from turning wholly saccharine. Winslow Fegley plays young Jake as determined and impulsive, and the suburban setting is full of period details that support the joke without requiring the audience to have owned the same console. The film’s real subject is not a particular piece of hardware but the way a childhood desire can feel enormous when the entire world seems to be telling you that everyone else will have one.

Sixth place reflects its reliable family appeal and unusually clear point of view. The quest structure makes it easy for children to follow, while adults can recognise the inflation of memory and the compromises parents make at Christmas. The movie also makes nostalgia accessible to people who did not grow up in the exact period: the emotional logic of wanting to belong is timeless. It is a natural double feature with other childhood-memory stories, and a promising choice for households seeking comedy that grandparents and children can enjoy together.

5. A Boy Called Christmas (2021)

Henry Lawfull as Nikolas with Miika the mouse on his shoulder in A Boy Called Christmas

A Boy Called Christmas imagines the life of Nikolas before he becomes the figure associated with Christmas. When his father sets out to find the fabled village of Elfhelm, Nikolas follows, accompanied by a loyal mouse and a reindeer. The journey takes him through a world of danger, wonder and competing ideas about whether hope is naïve or necessary. Rather than treating Father Christmas as a finished legend, the film asks what kind of hardship and generosity could shape a child into someone who brings joy to others.

Henry Lawfull gives Nikolas a sympathetic sincerity, and the film’s supporting cast adds theatrical colour to a story that moves between danger and whimsy. Its production design builds an old-fashioned fairy-tale world with enough texture to reward a large screen, while the central journey provides familiar landmarks for younger viewers. The story does not pretend that kindness fixes every injustice; it gives the hero setbacks and grief, then asks him to choose what he will do with those experiences.

At number five, it earns its place through a strong seasonal mythmaking instinct. The film has the scale and visual atmosphere of a holiday event, but it also has the sadness required to make its hope feel earned. Families looking for a fantasy adventure with a clear moral centre should find it an easy recommendation. Its chances of becoming a classic depend on whether viewers revisit its world rather than simply recall the premise. The combination of a young hero, a mouse companion and a reindeer gives it the ingredients for a story children can adopt as part of their own Christmas traditions.

4. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2024)

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2024), Grace and Imogene

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever begins when the Herdman siblings, known around town for mischief, end up with the lead roles in the local church’s annual pageant. The children initially appear to be interested in the church because of the snacks, but their arrival unsettles the adults who have long treated the production as a comfortable routine. As the rehearsals continue, the Herdmans’ blunt questions and unfamiliar perspective force the community to look again at the story it performs every year.

The film’s central idea is simple and durable: a tradition can become so familiar that people stop noticing what it means. The Herdmans are not instantly polished into perfect children, and the comedy depends on the clash between their disruptive honesty and the pageant’s rules. That tension gives the adaptation both comic set pieces and a reason to exist beyond nostalgia for the source book. The children bring energy to a film that might otherwise have treated the pageant as a sentimental backdrop.

This ranks fourth because it combines family accessibility with a meaningful seasonal theme. Its humour is broad enough for younger viewers, while its argument about hospitality and the purpose of a tradition gives adults something to take away. It is an especially good choice for families who enjoy community-centred Christmas stories and do not mind a gentle religious context. The movie’s recent release means its classic status remains a possibility, not a settled fact, but its message is adaptable to annual conversation: who gets welcomed into the story, and who has been left outside it?

If you enjoy the holiday traditions around the film as much as the film itself, see Best British Sitcom Christmas Specials, Ranked, Best Friends Christmas Episodes, Ranked, Sufjan Stevens: Worst Christmas Ever Review, Christmas Staycation by Meghan Quinn Book Review and A Married Little Christmas by Abby Jimenez Book Review for more seasonal reading and listening.

3. That Christmas (2024)

The children of Wellington-on-Sea in the animated film That Christmas

That Christmas weaves together several stories in the seaside town of Wellington-on-Sea, where families and neighbours face loneliness, misunderstandings and holiday plans that go wrong. The animated film draws on Richard Curtis’s children’s books and gives Santa a particularly consequential mistake to make. Instead of following one hero through a single problem, it moves among children and adults whose experiences overlap, building a picture of a community trying to make the day work for everyone.

The ensemble structure is the film’s defining pleasure. A missed connection or small disappointment in one household can sit beside a more comic mishap somewhere else, and the animation gives the coastal setting an inviting, storybook quality. Curtis’s writing brings a recognisable interest in awkward social encounters and emotional reconciliation, while director Simon Otto gives the film a visual rhythm that can carry several characters without making the town feel like a collection of unrelated sketches.

Third place recognises its potential as a modern family staple. It has the wide cast, interlaced plot and annual-season stakes that reward repeat viewing; children can follow the Santa and turkey chaos, while older viewers may respond to the moments of isolation underneath it. Its emotional range keeps the film from being only a string of festive gags. The test will be whether families continue returning to Wellington-on-Sea after the novelty of a new release fades. As a recent animated Christmas film, it already offers the kind of communal world that can support that habit.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an Amazon affiliate link. If you join Prime through it, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Explore Amazon Prime.

2. Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey (2020)

Jeronicus and Journey in the Jingle Jangle workshop

Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey centres on Jeronicus Jangle, a once-celebrated inventor and toymaker whose life changes after his trusted apprentice steals his most important invention. Years later, Jeronicus is withdrawn and struggling to keep his shop alive. His clever granddaughter Journey arrives, and her belief in his imagination helps restart a story about family, invention and the possibility of beginning again. The film uses the workshop as a place where mechanical marvels and emotional repair can happen side by side.

David E. Talbert’s musical fantasy is unusually vivid: saturated colours, elaborate costumes, kinetic dance and a score that announces the film’s ambitions from the first numbers. Forest Whitaker plays Jeronicus with the weight of a person who has allowed disappointment to become a habit; Madalen Mills gives Journey the confidence and curiosity needed to challenge him. The musical sequences are not decorative interruptions. They externalise the characters’ hopes and doubts, and give the story a sense of spectacle that sets it apart from the more modest domestic Christmas films on this list.

It takes second place because it has a distinctive world and a generous emotional core. The betrayal and its consequences give the film real sadness, but its central relationship is restorative rather than cynical. Families who want a musical, imaginative Christmas adventure should find it one of the strongest recent options, while viewers who prefer naturalistic stories may find its theatricality a little much. Its visual identity, songs and family themes give it excellent annual-rewatch potential; it feels like a world audiences can revisit, not just a plot they can summarise.

1. The Holdovers (2023)

Paul Giamatti, Dominic Sessa and Da'Vine Joy Randolph at the dinner table in The Holdovers

The Holdovers is a Christmas film for people who do not want Christmas cheer served as an instant cure. In 1970, strict classics teacher Paul Hunham is ordered to remain at his New England boarding school over the holiday break with a small group of students who have nowhere else to go. When the others leave, one student, Angus, stays behind, and the school cook, Mary, is also dealing with a season marked by personal grief. Three lonely people share an almost empty campus and slowly discover that their assumptions about one another are incomplete.

Paul Giamatti gives Hunham the irritability and intelligence of a man who has learned to make isolation look like principle. Dominic Sessa’s Angus is bright, defensive and less invulnerable than he wants adults to believe. Da’Vine Joy Randolph’s Mary brings the film its deepest ache, carrying a loss that the institution’s routines cannot solve. Alexander Payne’s period details and restrained visual style create a lived-in 1970s winter, while the screenplay allows conversation, conflict and kindness to change the characters gradually instead of arranging a sudden festive transformation.

The film takes the top position because it understands the emotional shape of a holiday classic: a confined setting, mismatched companions, loneliness made visible, and a form of connection that feels earned. It is not a conventional family comedy, and its language and subject matter make it better suited to older teens and adults. But its humour, compassion and imperfect people reward repeated viewings. The Christmas setting is not a decoration; the break from ordinary life creates the conditions for these characters to see each other. That combination makes The Holdovers the strongest 2020s candidate here for an enduring annual tradition.

Why These 2020s Christmas Films Could Last

A holiday classic is not simply a film with snow in the frame. It needs scenes that become part of a viewer’s seasonal memory and enough emotional texture to survive repeat exposure. The entries above achieve that in different ways: The Holdovers uses a school holiday to bring three lonely people into contact; Jingle Jangle builds a musical fantasy around intergenerational belief; That Christmas turns a whole town into an ensemble; and The Best Christmas Pageant Ever asks what familiar traditions are meant to do. The range matters. Future Christmas traditions will be made by viewers with different families, identities and tastes.

Some titles may become annual favourites in particular households without becoming universal classics. Single All the Way offers a joyful queer romance; Happiest Season finds comedy and conflict in the gap between love and family acceptance; 8-Bit Christmas turns nostalgia into a child-sized quest. A classic does not need to be flawless, and it does not need to be loved by everyone. It needs to keep offering something to the people who return to it.

Where to Find More Seasonal Picks

For current platform-specific winter viewing, see 10 BBC iPlayer Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic and 10 ITVX Movies That Perfectly Capture Winter Magic. For practical viewing and shopping ideas, our Amazon Prime Holiday Guide: Movies, Shopping and Membership Benefits and 10 Ways Amazon Prime Can Help with Last-Minute Christmas Shopping offer a separate guide to Prime membership. Streaming rights change, so verify availability in your country before subscribing or renting.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an Amazon affiliate link. If you join Prime through it, That Love Podcast may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Explore Amazon Prime.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which 2020s Christmas movie is most likely to become a classic?

The Holdovers is the strongest candidate in this ranking because its winter-break setting, memorable characters and earned emotional connection reward repeat viewing. Jingle Jangle and That Christmas are close alternatives for families who prefer fantasy or animation.

Is The Holdovers a Christmas film?

Yes. The story takes place during Christmas break, and the holiday separation from everyday routines is central to why Paul, Angus and Mary spend time together. Its tone is adult, dry and bittersweet rather than conventionally cheerful.

What is the best recent Christmas movie for families?

That Christmas, Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey and The Best Christmas Pageant Ever are strong family options, with animation, musical fantasy and community comedy respectively. Check age guidance and individual sensitivities before a family viewing.

Which film on the list is a Christmas romantic comedy?

Single All the Way, Something from Tiffany’s and Happiest Season are the clearest contemporary romantic comedies. The Noel Diary also blends romance with family mystery and a more reflective tone.

Is Happiest Season suitable for a family movie night?

It is a romantic comedy aimed more at teens and adults than young children. Its story includes family conflict around a character who is not out to her parents, alongside romantic and comedic material.

What is 8-Bit Christmas about?

An adult Jake recalls his childhood effort to get the popular video-game system of the 1980s for Christmas. It is a family comedy about childhood desire, friendship, nostalgia and the perspective parents gain over time.

Is A Boy Called Christmas an origin story for Santa?

It imagines a fictional origin for the future Father Christmas, following Nikolas as he journeys to find his father and the village of Elfhelm. It is a fantasy adventure rather than a historical account.

Which movie has the strongest musical numbers?

Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey is the list’s most overt musical, with elaborate songs, dance and colourful fantasy production design. It is a good pick when spectacle is the priority.

Are these movies available to stream in the UK?

Availability varies by title and changes over time. Check the current listings on Netflix, Prime Video and other UK services, or use a reputable local streaming guide before renting or subscribing.

Why is The Best Christmas Pageant Ever ranked so highly?

Its comedy about the unruly Herdman children is built around a thoughtful question: what happens when a familiar Christmas tradition is seen from an outsider’s perspective? That gives the family story more staying power than nostalgia alone.

Further Reading

For romance-first viewing, revisit Best Christmas Romantic Comedies of All Time and browse Christmas Staycation by Meghan Quinn Book Review and A Married Little Christmas by Abby Jimenez Book Review. For entertainment around seasonal routines, read Best British Sitcom Christmas Specials, Ranked, Best Friends Christmas Episodes, Ranked and Sufjan Stevens: Worst Christmas Ever Review.

Sources and Further Information

Official film information: Netflix Media Center, The Noel Diary; Lionsgate, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever; Focus Features, The Holdovers.

Want more ways to make a festive film night easier? Explore Amazon Prime through our affiliate link. If you join, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Similar Posts