5 Best Julia Donaldson Books of All Time, Ranked
Why These Five Picture Books Stand Out
Julia Donaldson has written across many genres and age groups, but her collaborations with illustrator Axel Scheffler have become especially familiar in family storytime. These five books span dragons, woodland journeys, witches, a tiny snail and a creature who lives in the deep dark wood. Each offers a different kind of pleasure: repeated rhyme, escalating encounters, visual detail, a satisfying reversal or a comforting return home.
This is an editorial ranking of five widely recognized Donaldson-and-Scheffler picture books, using the sequence supplied for this list. We considered how memorable the story structure is, how naturally the language works aloud, how much the illustrations contribute, and whether the book rewards rereading. Those criteria favour books that offer more than a single surprise: a child can enjoy them on the first pass and still discover new details later.
Rankings are subjective, particularly with books that families may have shared for years. A child who loves dragons may place Zog first; a household that reads Room on the Broom every autumn may consider it the definitive favourite. The order below is meant to help readers compare the books, not to tell families that one response is correct.
All five books are written by Julia Donaldson and illustrated by Axel Scheffler. They use rhyme and strong visual storytelling, but they do not feel interchangeable. Some are more cumulative, some build toward a journey or reunion, and others depend on a clever reversal. The distinctions can help a parent, teacher or gift-giver choose the right story for a particular child.
For publisher descriptions and editions, see Pan Macmillan’s pages for The Gruffalo, Room on the Broom, and The Snail and the Whale.
5 Best Julia Donaldson Books of All Time, Ranked
#5: Zog (2010)
A keen dragon-in-training, a memorable school setting and an unlikely friendship give this story a lively shape. Zog is determined to do well at dragon school, even though his enthusiasm is matched by a knack for accidents. A girl repeatedly helps him after mishaps, and his lessons build toward a dramatic test. Donaldson’s rhyming text gives the story a clear sequence—practice, setback, encouragement, another attempt—while Axel Scheffler’s illustrations make each stage easy to follow. Children can enjoy the broad comedy of a dragon who is trying very hard, then notice the caring relationship growing alongside the school adventure.
Why it stands out
What lifts Zog into this top five is its blend of humour and forward motion. The school structure gives young listeners a satisfying rhythm: Zog learns a new skill, something goes awry, and the reader wonders whether he will manage the next challenge. The story also gives friendship a practical form. The girl does not simply praise Zog; she helps him recover, and that care becomes part of how he approaches his goals. The book is funny without making his mistakes feel like a reason to give up.
Who should read it
Choose Zog for a child who enjoys dragons, magical settings and characters who keep trying. It is also a useful read-aloud for families who like to pause and predict what might go wrong next. Its school-year pattern can resonate with preschool and early-primary readers who are learning new skills themselves, though every child will take something different from it.
How it compares
For a first-time Donaldson reader, Zog is an inviting introduction to the author and Scheffler’s partnership, but it is placed fifth here because the other four books have an especially distinctive combination of repetition, cumulative structure or emotional resonance. That is a ranking choice rather than a verdict on its quality. A dragon-loving child may well choose it as their personal favourite.
See current editions and formats: check Amazon.
#4: Stick Man (2008)
A journey home turns an ordinary stick into a character with an unmistakable family and identity. Stick Man begins with a simple but affecting idea: a stick is mistaken for something else by people and animals who encounter it, while he is trying to return to his family tree. Donaldson’s rhymes carry him through a sequence of increasingly inconvenient detours. The repeated contrast between what others think he is and what he knows about himself makes the story easy to join in with, and Scheffler’s expressive drawings add new visual interpretations to each encounter.
Why it stands out
The emotional centre is belonging. Stick Man wants to get back to his partner and children, and every new use someone finds for him delays that reunion. The situation is funny, but the longing is clear enough for young readers to understand. That balance gives the book a different feeling from a pure cumulative comedy: the repeated setbacks build anticipation toward home, and readers can care about whether Stick Man will make it back.
Who should read it
This is a good choice for children who enjoy a clear journey, repeated phrases and stories about family. It can also prompt creative play: after reading, children may invent other objects that could be mistaken for something else. The wintery associations and seasonal editions make it popular for holiday reading, but its core story works year-round.
How it compares
Stick Man ranks fourth because its emotional arc and refrain are memorable, though its episodic travels may feel more familiar to some children than the tightly escalating encounters in the top three. It remains one of Donaldson and Scheffler’s most distinctive collaborations, and it often grows richer on rereading as children recognize the pattern and anticipate each new detour.
See current editions and formats: check Amazon.
#3: The Snail and the Whale (2003)
A tiny traveller and a huge companion set out to see the world, then discover that help can come from an unexpected place. A little snail longs to travel beyond the rock where she lives and leaves a message asking for a lift. A whale carries her across oceans and landscapes, giving the story a sense of scale and movement that is unusual among picture books. When the whale becomes stranded, the snail’s size does not stop her from finding a way to help. The reversal gives the adventure its heart: the smallest traveller proves capable of making a difference to the friend who showed her the world.
Why it stands out
The contrast between tiny snail and enormous whale gives children an immediate visual idea to hold onto, while the rhyme makes the journey musical and memorable. Each new setting invites a pause to look at the illustrations and imagine what the snail is seeing. The final problem brings the long voyage back to friendship and resourcefulness. The story feels expansive, but its emotional message remains easy for a young listener to grasp: being small does not mean being powerless.
Who should read it
This is a particularly strong read-aloud for children who like animals, travel and a reassuring friendship story. It can lead naturally to conversations about oceans and habitats, though it also works simply as an adventure. For younger toddlers, a sturdy board-book adaptation can make the story easier to handle; the full picture-book edition offers more of the original journey and artwork.
How it compares
The Snail and the Whale takes third place for its scale, rhythm and satisfying reversal. It pairs a journey story with an emotional problem in a way that encourages both discussion and rereading. Its central friendship is gentle rather than sentimental, and the small snail’s actions give children a memorable example of courage expressed through thoughtfulness.
See current editions and formats: check Amazon.
#2: Room on the Broom (2001)
A witch’s lost belongings lead to a growing group of animal companions and a clever answer to danger. A witch and her cat fly across a landscape when gusts of wind carry away several important belongings. One by one, animals find and return them, each hoping for a place on the broom. The group grows until the broom can no longer hold everyone, and a hungry dragon appears. The story’s simple chain of events gives children an easy structure to follow: something is lost, a new friend helps, the group makes room, and the situation becomes more complicated.
Why it stands out
Room on the Broom is a superb example of cumulative storytelling. Each new character joins the journey and adds a little more to the rhyme, so children can anticipate the pattern and take part in repeated reading. The growing group also gives the story its emotional warmth. The witch’s willingness to share the ride turns a rescue into friendship, while the climax lets all the animals contribute to solving a frightening problem together.
Who should read it
Choose this for a child who enjoys joining in, repeating lines and tracking a cast of characters. The suspense is mild and quickly resolved, making it a comfortable choice for many preschool listeners. A board-book or lift-the-flap edition can suit younger hands, while the standard picture book lets families enjoy the full text and Scheffler’s detailed scenes.
How it compares
It ranks second because its rhythm, escalating structure and ensemble cast make it exceptionally satisfying to read aloud. The Gruffalo edges it out for the way its central verbal trick and mouse’s cleverness create a more unusual story engine. Still, for many families Room on the Broom will be the book they reach for most often when they want an interactive, communal story.
See current editions and formats: check Amazon.
#1: The Gruffalo (1999)
A quick-witted mouse invents a fearsome creature to outsmart predators in a deep, dark wood. The Gruffalo takes the top spot because its premise is instantly gripping and its storytelling rewards both first readings and many returns. A small mouse walks through a wood where larger animals see him as a possible meal. He answers their invitations with descriptions of a frightening creature, expecting that the Gruffalo exists only in his imagination—until the creature turns up. The mouse must then use the same cleverness a second time, and the story’s repeating encounters make that reversal deliciously satisfying.
Why it stands out
The book’s structure is its great strength. Each meeting echoes the last, creating a pattern that young children can recognize and anticipate. The mouse’s confidence is playful rather than forceful; he changes how others see him by telling a story and thinking quickly. Scheffler’s illustrations give the imagined creature a vivid physical presence and reward close looking, while Donaldson’s rhyme helps the lines stay with readers long after storytime ends.
Who should read it
The Gruffalo is an excellent shared-reading choice for families who like suspense, humour and a strong refrain. Children can join in with familiar parts, point out details in the deep dark wood and predict what the mouse might say next. It also makes a natural first Donaldson-and-Scheffler book because the central situation is easy to explain and the characters are memorable.
How it compares
Its top rank reflects a rare combination: a compact plot with real suspense, language made for reading aloud, a clever central character and illustrations that deepen the jokes. Pan Macmillan describes it as a bestselling modern classic, and its influence can be seen in how many children and adults know the mouse and the creature. Its staying power makes it the strongest all-time pick on this list.
See current editions and formats: check Amazon.
What makes a picture book worth rereading?
Rereadability often starts with a pattern. When children recognize what may happen next, they can join in without having to know every word. Repeated refrains, familiar sequences and returning characters create a shared rhythm between reader and listener. Donaldson’s rhyming stories are especially easy to return to because they invite a voice and a beat; adults can make each character sound different, while children can anticipate a line or help turn the page.
The illustrations matter just as much. Scheffler’s pictures show more than the words describe, so a reread can become a search for expressions, small background jokes and changes in the setting. The mouse’s encounters in The Gruffalo, the growing group on the broom and the landscapes travelled by the snail all give children something to inspect. A child may ask to revisit a page not because they missed the story, but because they enjoy seeing it again.
A memorable story also gives families a reason to talk. The questions can be simple: which character was kind, what might happen next, what did the mouse notice, or how did Stick Man keep going? These conversations support comprehension without turning storytime into a lesson. If a child only wants the funny part repeated, that is a valid way to enjoy the book too.
Books that mix suspense with reassurance can be particularly satisfying at bedtime or during quiet reading. The child knows that something uncertain is coming, but the rhythm and familiar structure create a sense of safety. Room on the Broom and The Gruffalo use this balance in different ways: the first builds a group before danger arrives, while the second lets the mouse face a larger creature through quick thinking.
Different editions can change the experience. A standard picture book gives room for the full text and illustrations; a board-book edition may be sturdier for very young children; lift-the-flap or pop-up versions add a tactile element. These formats may adapt or abridge the original wording, so consider whether the child wants the complete story or an interactive introduction. The right format depends on age, handling and how the book will be used.
Read-aloud value is not simply about rhyme. A book works well aloud when the listener can follow the action, hear a change in mood and enjoy how the words sound. Donaldson’s lines encourage pacing and expressive reading, while Scheffler’s scenes let a child follow even if they are still learning to listen for every detail. That combination makes these stories useful for one-to-one bedtime reading as well as group storytime.
A story’s emotional theme can be subtle and still matter. Stick Man’s wish to get home gives its comic detours a reason to matter. The Snail and the Whale lets the unlikely pair help one another. Zog’s friendship supports him through repeated challenges. The Gruffalo and Room on the Broom lean more heavily on cleverness and group action. The range means families can choose based on whether they want a gentle emotional thread or a bolder comic adventure.
Children often return to books they can participate in. They may recite a repeated phrase, point out a character before the adult reads the words, or finish a sentence from memory. Participation turns listening into a shared performance. Caregivers can leave a pause before a familiar line and let the child fill it in, or ask them to choose who speaks next. This makes the book feel active without adding new activities or materials.
A child’s favourite book may change over time. At two, they may want a sturdy edition they can handle independently; at four, they may enjoy the full rhyme and ask questions about the story; later, they may notice humour or character details they did not understand before. Keeping a well-loved book nearby gives it room to grow with the reader. An older child may even enjoy reading it aloud to a younger sibling.
These five books also offer different entry points to conversation about language. Families can listen for rhyme, notice words that sound alike, or compare how a repeated phrase changes in meaning as a story develops. Teachers may use the illustrations to discuss sequence, point of view or character motivation. The book does not need a formal activity attached; a quick observation can deepen appreciation while leaving the story’s playfulness intact.
How to choose among the five
Choose Zog when the child is drawn to dragons, school stories or a character who learns through practice. Choose Stick Man for a family-centred journey with repeated setbacks and a homecoming at its heart. Choose The Snail and the Whale for a broad adventure that pairs travel with friendship and a clever rescue. Choose Room on the Broom for a growing cast, repetition and a group solution. Choose The Gruffalo for suspense, a quick-witted hero and a refrain many children love to join.
If the child has already heard one of these many times, try another title with a different structure rather than assuming they have outgrown picture books. A familiar author can offer a new setting or kind of story while keeping the comfort of rhyme and strong illustration. For younger toddlers, select a sturdy board edition where available; for preschoolers who enjoy longer read-alouds, the standard picture book may give them more of the original experience.
A practical choice can also depend on the moment. A short, comforting story may suit a tired child; an adventure with repeating lines may work well in a group; a book about returning home may resonate during a transition. Adults do not need to predict exactly what a child will take from the story. Let the child’s interest guide the next reading.
You May Also Like
What the Ladybird Heard at the Seaside Review
More Picture-Book Recommendations
A Guide to Must-Read Children’s Literature
Diary of a Wimpy Kid Books Ranked
Explore More Reading Lists
A Series of Unfortunate Events Ranked
Books Like Harry Potter for Kids
Best DreamWorks Animated Movies
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Julia Donaldson’s most famous book?
The Gruffalo is widely regarded as one of Julia Donaldson’s best-known books. Pan Macmillan describes it as a bestselling modern classic and lists Axel Scheffler as illustrator.
Are all five books illustrated by Axel Scheffler?
Yes. Zog, Stick Man, The Snail and the Whale, Room on the Broom and The Gruffalo are collaborations between Julia Donaldson and Axel Scheffler.
Which Julia Donaldson book is best for preschoolers?
The Gruffalo and Room on the Broom are popular read-aloud choices for preschoolers. Choose an edition that suits the child’s age and handling needs.
Which book is best for a child who likes dragons?
Zog is the obvious choice for a dragon-loving child. It follows an enthusiastic dragon at school who keeps trying as he learns new skills.
Which book has the strongest family theme?
Stick Man centres on a character trying to return to his family tree. It combines comic detours with a clear emotional wish to get home.
Which Julia Donaldson book is best for a read-aloud?
All five work well aloud, but Room on the Broom and The Gruffalo are especially easy to share because of their repeated patterns and memorable rhymes.
What is The Snail and the Whale about?
A little snail travels on a whale’s tail to see the world. When the whale becomes stranded, the snail finds a way to help him.
Should toddlers get a board-book edition?
A board book can be easier for toddlers to handle. Some board-book versions shorten or adapt the full story, so check the edition details if you want the complete text.
What age range are these stories for?
Publisher editions commonly position several of these picture books for preschool and early-primary readers. Children’s interests and listening preferences vary, so read together and choose what suits them.
Which book should I buy first?
The Gruffalo is a strong first choice because its premise is clear and the story is easy to share. A child’s favourite subject—dragons, witches or animals—can also guide you.
Final Thoughts
The strongest Julia Donaldson book depends on what a child loves, but The Gruffalo earns the top spot here for its clever structure, lasting refrain and combination of suspense and humour. Room on the Broom makes group reading feel lively, The Snail and the Whale gives a sweeping friendship adventure, Stick Man offers a moving journey home, and Zog brings school-day comedy and encouragement. Each rewards rereading in its own way.
For more family book and listening recommendations, explore That Love Podcast episodes or support the show. Sign up for our newsletter for new recommendations and family listening ideas.
Read-Aloud Strengths, Book by Book
Zog has a clear sequence that supports a lively read-aloud. An adult can give the dragon a determined voice, pause when a new school task appears and let the child guess how he will manage it. The repeated pattern helps younger listeners understand what is happening even if they are still learning to follow a longer narrative. At the end, families can talk about what helped Zog keep going, or simply enjoy the relief of seeing his efforts pay off.
Stick Man works through accumulation: each new encounter is another delay on his way home. The reader can emphasize the difference between how other characters see the stick and how he describes himself. Children may quickly pick up the repeated identity and family details. That makes the story especially rewarding when shared with a listener who likes to join in or predict what might happen to him next.
The Snail and the Whale invites an expansive style of reading. The journey moves through varied places, and an adult can slow down to look at the changing landscapes before returning to the rhyme. The contrast between the tiny snail and the enormous whale is easy to make visible with gestures or voices. When the whale needs help, the story shifts from sightseeing to problem-solving, giving the read-aloud a satisfying change of energy.
Room on the Broom is ideal for a group because each new animal can have its own voice. Listeners can join the pattern as the witch loses things and friends appear. The growing group creates a playful sense of anticipation: how many more characters can fit, and what will happen when the broom can no longer carry them? The final challenge brings the animals’ separate contributions together, which makes the resolution feel shared.
The Gruffalo balances a repeated encounter with a twist. An adult can let the pauses build a little suspense before the mouse describes the creature, then use a different tone when the Gruffalo actually appears. Children often enjoy recognizing the pattern and predicting how each animal will react. The final reversal rewards attention to what the mouse has said throughout the story.
Illustrations That Extend the Story
Axel Scheffler’s pictures are not merely decoration alongside the rhyme. They help young readers follow action, recognize returning characters and notice emotion that may not be spelled out in the text. In The Gruffalo, looking at the mouse beside the different woodland animals can make the size contrast instantly clear. In Room on the Broom, the crowded broom becomes a visual joke that builds as the group grows.
In The Snail and the Whale, the scale of the settings gives the journey its sense of wonder. A tiny traveller can appear against a huge ocean or landscape, inviting the child to look carefully and imagine how it feels to see such a vast world. Stick Man similarly uses ordinary settings to show how the same object can be interpreted differently by people who encounter it. The images make those changes concrete and comic.
When reading with a child, allow time for looking. Ask what they notice before reading the next line, or let them point out a detail they have spotted. A child may understand a scene through the pictures before they can explain it in words. That is part of the book’s design, and it can make a shared reading session more conversational and less hurried.
How to Pick a First Julia Donaldson Book
If you are choosing a first story, start with the child’s interests. A dragon fan may be drawn to Zog; an animal-loving child might choose The Snail and the Whale; a listener who enjoys group participation may respond to Room on the Broom. For a classic story with a clever protagonist, The Gruffalo is an easy recommendation. If family and the wish to get home feel important, Stick Man has a strong emotional through-line.
Age and edition matter too. Pan Macmillan lists editions of several of these stories for ages three to seven, while a range of board-book and interactive formats exists for younger readers. Those labels describe editions and publishing choices, not a strict rule about when every child can enjoy a story. Browse a few pages, consider the length of the text and the way the book will be handled, then choose the version that feels right.
For toddlers, sturdy pages can make independent handling easier, and a short adapted version may be better for a quick read. For preschoolers who enjoy longer stories, a full-length picture book gives more room for the rhyme and illustrations. Some children will want to repeat the same book nightly; others prefer to choose a new one each time. Both habits can build an enjoyable relationship with stories.
A gift-giver should check whether the family already owns a copy. These five books are common favourites, so a duplicate is possible. If you cannot ask directly, consider an edition that is meaningfully different—such as a board-book version for a very young child, or the standard picture book if they only have an audio recording. A receipt or exchange option can also help the gift land well.
Why the Ranking Is Only a Starting Point
All-time rankings are helpful for discovering books, but children build their own personal canon. One story may become associated with a parent’s voice, a favourite holiday or a first library visit. Another may become a source of jokes that the family repeats long after storytime. Those experiences shape how a book is remembered, and they cannot be reduced to a single universal score.
The list places The Gruffalo first for its particularly strong combination of suspense, repetition, humour and visual storytelling. Room on the Broom is close behind because of its cumulative structure and ensemble solution. The other three offer distinct strengths: the scale and friendship of The Snail and the Whale, the emotional homeward journey of Stick Man, and the humorous determination at the heart of Zog. A family may rank them in an entirely different order and still have excellent reasons.
That flexibility is part of what makes these books last. They invite adults and children to read together, give younger listeners recognizable patterns to join and leave space for illustrations to tell their own side of the story. If a child asks for one of these books again, the rereading is not a failure to move on; it is evidence that the story has become part of their world.
